Odisha High CourtInsurance LawCivil Procedure and Evidence

Orissa HC Makes Insurer Pay Injured Gratuitous Passenger First, Recover From Car Owner Later

GOPAL KRISHNA CHAKRAv.SATYAPRIYA SAMANTRAY

Orissa HC Makes Insurer Pay Injured Gratuitous Passenger First, Recover From Car Owner Later. GOPAL KRISHNA CHAKRA vs SATYAPRIYA SAMANTRAY. Odisha High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the quantum of compensation assessed by the Tribunal, including the income assessment of Rs. 15,000/- per annum, requires interference in appeal.

The court held

(1) The quantum of Rs. 1,43,000/- is upheld, as the Tribunal's non-earning finding was sustained on the claimant's failure to prove income.

It also directed

(2) The exclusion of the insurer is set aside; R2 is liable to pay as a matter of "pay and recover" and (3) the 9% default interest is set aside.

The appeal is allowed against R2 and ex parte against R1, without costs. R2 is directed to pay the compensation with 4% simple interest from 02.11.1996 within eight weeks, with liberty to recover from R1 in separate proceedings.

On deposit before the Tribunal, 70% of the amount is to be placed in a fixed deposit for five years in a Nationalized Bank in the claimant's name, with the balance disbursed to him.

01Facts

The claimant-appellant was injured in a motor accident on 02.11.1996 while travelling in a Car owned by R1, which was insured with R2, New India Assurance Co. Ltd.

¶ 1.1 · pp. 1–2

He filed MAC Case No. 269 of 1996 before the 1st Motor Accident Claims Tribunal, Keonjhar.

¶ 1.1 · pp. 1–2

The Tribunal, by judgment dated 31.01.2011, awarded Rs. 1,43,000/- with 6% simple interest from 02.11.1996 against R1, with 9% default interest, and dismissed the claim against R2 on the ground that the claimant was a gratuitous passenger.

¶ 1.1 · pp. 1–2 · ¶ 6 · p. 5

R1 was set ex parte.

¶ 3 · p. 2

On disability, the Orthopaedic Specialist certified 45% disability.

¶ 4 · p. 3

The Tribunal found that the claimant claimed income of Rs. 4,000/- per month from business but did not disclose his income in evidence, and that he was in employment with Baitarani Gramya Bank since 1988 without disclosing salary.

¶ 4 · pp. 3–4

The Tribunal held him a non-earning person, assessed annual income at Rs. 15,000/-, applied multiplier 16 (age 38), and computed Rs. 1,08,000/- (15,000 × 16 × 45%), Rs. 10,000/- for pain and suffering, Rs. 10,000/- for medical expenses, and Rs. 15,000/- for three grievous injuries.

¶ 4 · pp. 3–4

The appellant challenged (i) quantum and (ii) the exclusion of the insurer.

¶ 2 · p. 2

02Issues

i.1. Whether the quantum of compensation assessed by the Tribunal, including the income assessment of Rs. 15,000/- per annum, requires interference in appeal.

¶ 4–5 · pp. 3–4

ii.2. Whether the insurer (R2) can be exonerated merely because the injured claimant was travelling as a gratuitous passenger in the offending vehicle, or whether it must be directed to pay and recover from the owner.

¶ 6–7 · pp. 5–6

iii.3. Whether the Tribunal's imposition of 9% default interest is sustainable.

¶ 7 · pp. 6–7

03Law Applied

The appeal was preferred under Section 173(1) of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988.

¶ 1 · p. 1

On quantum, the Court applied the Tribunal's evidence-based finding that a claimant who fails to disclose or prove his income may be treated as non-earning, with notional income fixed accordingly.

¶ 4–5 · pp. 3–4

On the insurer's liability, the Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in Sunita & Ors. v. United India Insurance Co. Ltd. (Civil Appeal No. 9538 of 2025, decided 17.07.2025), which, following Anu Bhanvara v. IFFCO Tokio (2020) 20 SCC 632 and a line of authorities including Amrit Lal Sood (1998) 3 SCC 744, New India Assurance v. C.M. Jaya (2002) 2 SCC 278, National Insurance v. Challa Upendra Rao (2004) 8 SCC 517, Manuara Khatun v. Rajesh Kumar Singh (2017) 4 SCC 796, and Puttappa v. Rama Naik (2018 SCC OnLine SC 3496), adopts the "pay and recover" principle: the insurer must first indemnify the third-party award and may then recover from the owner.

¶ 6 · pp. 5–6

The Court also held that default interest at 9% is not permissible on such awards.

¶ 7 · p. 6

Order XLI Rule 14(4) CPC was invoked to dispense with re-issuance of notice to the ex parte R1.

¶ 3 · p. 2

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 173

04Reasoning

On quantum, the Court found no infirmity in the Tribunal's reasoning. The claimant did not prove his avocation or income, and his evidence was inconsistent: he claimed Rs. 4,000/- monthly income from business, yet in cross-examination disclosed employment with a bank and a previously auctioned transport business, without stating any salary.

¶ 4 · pp. 3–4 · ¶ 5 · p. 4

No material was placed to displace the Tribunal's finding, so the Rs. 15,000/- annual income, multiplier, and disability computation were upheld.

¶ 5 · p. 4

On liability, the Court held that the Tribunal erred in exonerating the insurer solely because the claimant was a gratuitous passenger. Applying Sunita and the cited precedents, the insurer must satisfy the award first, with a right of recovery against the owner.

¶ 6–7 · pp. 5–6

The insurer's right to recover is preserved, subject to establishing the gratuitous-passenger fact in separate proceedings.

¶ 8 · p. 7

The 9% default interest was set aside as impermissible, and the Court directed 4% simple interest from 02.11.1996.

¶ 7 · p. 6 · ¶ 8 · p. 7

05Holding

(1) The quantum of Rs. 1,43,000/- is upheld, as the Tribunal's non-earning finding was sustained on the claimant's failure to prove income.

¶ 5 · p. 4

(2) The exclusion of the insurer is set aside; R2 is liable to pay as a matter of "pay and recover" and (3) the 9% default interest is set aside.

¶ 7 · p. 6 · ¶ 8 · p. 7

The appeal is allowed against R2 and ex parte against R1, without costs. R2 is directed to pay the compensation with 4% simple interest from 02.11.1996 within eight weeks, with liberty to recover from R1 in separate proceedings.

¶ 8 · p. 7

On deposit before the Tribunal, 70% of the amount is to be placed in a fixed deposit for five years in a Nationalized Bank in the claimant's name, with the balance disbursed to him.

¶ 9 · p. 7
Odisha High Court

Original Court PDF

GOPAL KRISHNA CHAKRAvsSATYAPRIYA SAMANTRAY

Odisha High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment