01Facts
The petitioner-wife, who is the opposite party in C.P. No. 713 of 2026 pending before the Family Court No. I, Bhubaneswar, sought transfer of that matrimonial proceeding to the Family Court, Rourkela, under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908
pp. 1–2 / para. 1She contended that she is a deserted woman with no independent source of income, and relied on other grounds set out in the petition
p. 2 / para. 3No written objection was filed. With the consent of counsel, the petition was heard and disposed of at the admission stage, with leave to the husband to raise oral objections
p. 2 / para. 2The husband, who is serving at the State Bank of India's Head Office in Bhubaneswar, stated on instructions that he had no objection to the transfer
pp. 2–3 / para. 4He submitted that travelling to Rourkela on each date of hearing would cause considerable inconvenience and sought permission to appear virtually after transfer
pp. 3 / para. 4.1–4.202Issues
i.1. Whether the matrimonial proceeding in C.P. No. 713 of 2026 should be transferred from the Family Court, Bhubaneswar, to the Family Court, Rourkela, under Section 24 CPC, given the petitioner's desertion and lack of independent income and the absence of objection from the respondent
pp. 2–3 / para. 3–5ii.2. Whether the respondent-husband may be permitted to appear through virtual mode following such transfer
p. 3 / para. 4.2 · pp. 4–5 / para. 8–903Law Applied
The Court's power was invoked under Section 24 CPC, which empowers the High Court to transfer suits or proceedings between courts
p. 1 / para. 1The Court relied on the "settled position of law" governing such transfers, without citing any specific authority
p. 3 / para. 5It also relied on the High Court of Orissa and District Courts Use of Electronic Communication and Audio-Video Electronic Means Rules, 2025, which govern the use of video conferencing for appearances
p. 5 / para. 9The Court further applied the principle that effective hearing stages, such as examination and cross-examination of witnesses, require physical presence unless the court orders otherwise
p. 5 / para. 10No judicial precedent is cited in the judgment
Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 24
04Reasoning
The Court considered the pleadings, the documents on record, and the submissions of both counsel
p. 3 / para. 5The petitioner's averment that she is deserted and lacks independent income supported the transfer request
p. 2 / para. 3The husband's unconditional consent removed any contest on the transfer, and his practical concern about frequent travel from Bhubaneswar to Rourkela, given his employment there, was a legitimate ground for allowing virtual appearance
pp. 2–3 / para. 4 · p. 3 / para. 4.1The Court balanced these factors. It allowed the transfer, but preserved physical presence on dates of effective hearing, such as the recording of evidence, where the Court may so order
p. 5 / para. 10It also directed both parties to avoid unnecessary adjournments to ensure early disposal
p. 6 / para. 12The judgment does not expressly state how the statutory test under Section 24 was satisfied beyond the petitioner's stated grounds and the consent of the respondent
p. 3 / para. 505Holding
The transfer petition is allowed
p. 4 / para. 6The Family Court No. I, Bhubaneswar, is directed to transmit the record of C.P. No. 713 of 2026 to the Family Court, Rourkela, preferably within seven days of receiving a certified copy of the judgment. The Rourkela court shall re-register the case if required, proceed in accordance with law, and endeavour to conclude it expeditiously. Both parties may appear virtually with the court's permission, and the Rourkela court is requested to allow video conferencing under the 2025 Rules. Physical presence is required on dates of effective hearing where ordered. The parties must monitor the case listing and avoid unnecessary adjournments. The Office is to communicate the judgment to the Rourkela court. Any interim order stands vacated and the pending I.A. is disposed of
p. 4 / para. 6 · p. 4 / para. 7 · pp. 4–5 / para. 8–9 · p. 5 / para. 10 · pp. 5–6 / para. 11–12 · p. 6 / para. 14 · p. 6 / para. 15Original Court PDF
CHHAYA PURABI DASHvsDEEPTIMANTA KUMAR MALIK
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
