01Facts
The petitioner's minor son (aged 17 per petitioner) was found dead near a nala on 5.9.2024.
¶ 3–4The FIR in Dharmasala P.S. Case No. 670/2024 was registered on 4.9.2024 under s.137(2) BNS, and the case was later converted to ss.103(2) and 238(a) BNS.
¶ 3–4The police theory was that the deceased had a relationship with the sister of the accused juvenile (aged about 15), and that the juvenile found them together, chased the deceased, and assaulted him with a katuri.
¶ 4, 14The juvenile's mother allegedly washed his clothes and disturbed the scene.
¶ 4Both were arrested on the juvenile's disclosure, and a chargesheet was filed on 8.12.2024 with further investigation kept open under s.193(8) BNSS.
¶ 4The petitioner alleged political interference, suspected hired killers, and an unexplored role of a friend who had dropped the deceased near the house, and relied on the post-mortem report showing head and frontal injuries, arguing that a juvenile's sole responsibility was improbable.
¶ 5, 7Forensic reports found the blood group undeterminable, some blood stains undetectable, no diatoms, and a homicidal rather than drowning death.
¶ 9Blood drops, a rakhi and blood-stained yellow plastic ropes were seized from the accused's house.
¶ 7, 13The State contended that the investigation was thorough and that the juvenile's disclosure was voluntary and corroborated by recovery of the weapon.
¶ 8, 1302Issues
i.1. Whether the investigation, which rested primarily on the juvenile's disclosure and left physical evidence and the body's recovery unexplained, was so incomplete or tainted as to warrant further investigation by the CID CB, Odisha.
¶ 12, 14, 20ii.2. Whether a Constitutional Court may direct further investigation or re-investigation by an independent agency after a chargesheet has been filed and trial may be pending.
¶ 10–11, 15–18iii.3. Whether the juvenile's confession is admissible, and what evidentiary value attaches to the discovery of the weapon.
¶ 13, 16, 2003Law Applied
Section 25 of the Indian Evidence Act renders a confession to a police officer inadmissible, and only the portion of the disclosure leading to discovery of the weapon is admissible.
¶ 13Section 173(8) CrPC, now s.193(8)–(9) BNSS, permits further investigation; a Magistrate may order further investigation by the same police but not re-investigation by another agency.
¶ 15, 17Section 183 BNSS on judicial confessions provides that a confession cannot sustain conviction if contradicted by medical or physical evidence.
¶ 17Article 21 of the Constitution, which guarantees fair investigation, is the basis for Constitutional Court intervention.
¶ 17–18Hasanbhai Valibhai Qureshi v. State of Gujarat (2004) 5 SCC 347: further investigation may be directed to arrive at the truth, and is not barred by delay.
¶ 11, 18Dharam Pal v. State of Haryana (2016) 4 SCC 160: transfer of investigation is possible even after chargesheet and commencement of trial where necessary.
¶ 11, 18Pooja Pal v. Union of India (2016) 3 SCC 135: a chargesheet does not curtail the constitutional power to transfer a probe, and the investigation must be fair.
¶ 18–19Vinay Tyagi v. Irshad Ali (2013) 5 SCC 762: distinction between further investigation and re-investigation.
¶ 18Babubhai v. State of Gujarat (2010) 12 SCC 254 and Bharati Tamang v. Union of India (2013) 15 SCC 578: a tainted investigation warrants intervention.
¶ 18State of West Bengal v. Committee for Protection of Democratic Rights (2010) 3 SCC 571, K. Saravanan (2014) 10 SCC 406 and Sudipta Lenka (2014) 11 SCC 527: transfer of investigation is permitted only in exceptional cases, and is not a matter of course.
¶ 11, 19Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 Section 137Section 103Section 238
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 193Section 183
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 173
04Reasoning
The investigation relied almost entirely on the juvenile's disclosure, which is inadmissible as a confession except to the extent it led to discovery; the discovery of the katuri was accepted as admissible under that limited principle.
¶ 13–14The body was found floating in a nala after about two days, which, absent explanation, suggested it was moved from the scene, and the juvenile's account of falling near the nala did not explain this.
¶ 14–15The blood drops, rakhi and ropes inside the house had not been linked to the offence, and the forensic findings (no diatoms, homicidal death) were not reconciled with the prosecution's narrative.
¶ 9, 14–15The prosecution's case that the assault occurred outside the house was contradicted by physical evidence suggesting an indoor event, which created a "fatal inconsistency".
¶ 16–17CDR analysis and examination of other family members and the friend had not been carried out.
¶ 7, 14A Magistrate could order only further investigation by the same police, but the High Court, exercising its constitutional jurisdiction, could direct investigation by another agency where the investigation was perfunctory and failed to ensure fairness.
¶ 17–18The fact that a chargesheet had been filed did not bar such relief.
¶ 18–19The Court considered the petitioner's suspicion of other participants and the scope for hidden facts relevant to fairness, and did not find that the petitioner's allegations of political interference were established, resting its decision on the investigative gaps.
¶ 2005Holding
The investigation, which depended on an inadmissible confession and left unexplained physical and forensic contradictions, required a thorough probe to determine the truth and rule out others.
¶ 20The petition was disposed of with a direction for further investigation in Dharmasala P.S. Case No. 670/2024 (C.T. Case No. 2074/2024, J.M.F.C. Chandikhole) by the CID CB, Odisha. The chargesheet and connected materials are to be handed over forthwith to opposite party No. 5 for further investigation, to be concluded within a reasonable time through supplementary chargesheet.
¶ 22Original Court PDF
NARAHARI BEHERAvsSTATE OF ODISHA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
