01Facts
The petitioners, who had served on a daily-labour (DLR) basis, sought regularization before the Odisha Administrative Tribunal.
p. 2The Tribunal directed the Director, Family Welfare to decide their claims in light of Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Uma Devi (3) and State of Karnataka v. M.L. Kesari.
p. 2Instead, the CDMO, Jajpur rejected the claims by a common order dated 11 July 2019, which the petitioners challenged in these writ petitions.
pp. 2–3By the time the High Court considered the petitions, all three petitioners had retired.
p. 3The State defended the rejection on the grounds that the petitioners had not been recruited through a regular process and that reservation requirements had not been followed.
p. 2002Issues
i.1. Whether the CDMO, Jajpur could decide and reject the petitioners’ regularization claims when the Tribunal had directed the Director, Family Welfare to make that decision.
pp. 2–3, 21ii.2. Whether the petitioners’ claims, including their claims for regularization and consequential pensionary benefits after retirement, should be reconsidered in light of the cited Supreme Court decisions.
p. 3, 2103Law Applied
Under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution, the High Court may review administrative action and grant appropriate relief.
The Tribunal’s order required the designated authority—the Director, Family Welfare—to decide the claims by considering Uma Devi (3) and M.L. Kesari.
p. 2, 21The judgment also directed consideration of the principles in Jaggo v. Union of India, Shripal v. Nagar Nigam, Ghaziabad, Dharam Singh v. State of U.P., Bhola Nath v. State of Jharkhand, and Sukhendu Bhatacharjee v. State of Assam, concerning prolonged temporary or contractual service, fair treatment by the State as a model employer, and the assessment of regularization claims.
pp. 3–19, 21–22The Court did not itself determine that the petitioners satisfied the substantive requirements for regularization; it required a fresh decision by the competent authority.
04Reasoning
The Tribunal had specifically directed the Director, Family Welfare to decide the petitioners’ claims, but the impugned rejection was made by the CDMO, Jajpur.
pp. 21–22The High Court therefore found that the Tribunal’s direction had not been carried out by the authority to whom it was addressed and quashed the rejection on that ground.
p. 22Rather than decide the petitioners’ substantive eligibility, the Court directed a fresh decision that would take account of the later Supreme Court authorities and the petitioners’ retirement and pension position.
p. 2205Holding
The writ petitions were disposed of, and the CDMO’s order dated 11 July 2019 was quashed.
p. 22The Court directed Opposite Party No. 1 to reconsider the petitioners’ regularization claims, treating them as having retired as regular employees for the purpose of considering coverage under the OCS (Pension) Rules, 1992, and to take a reasoned decision within three months of receiving the order.
p. 22The petitioners were permitted to submit the judgment, the cited Supreme Court decisions, and relevant orders granting benefits to similarly situated persons.
p. 22The Court granted reconsideration, not regularization itself.
p. 22Original Court PDF
BIDYADHAR SAHOOvsSTATE OF ODISHA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
