01Facts
The Petitioner-wife sought transfer under Section 24 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, of Matrimonial Case No. 50 of 2025, filed by the Opposite Party-husband, from the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, Sundargarh, to the Court of the Senior Civil Judge, Padampur.
¶ 1The pleadings were complete, and the petition was heard at the admission stage with the parties' consent.
¶ 2The Petitioner states she is deserted and lives with her elderly widowed mother at Kendumunda, Bargarh, on whom she is wholly dependent. The distance to Sundargarh is about 205 km.
¶ 4Her counsel, on latest instructions and not pleaded in the petition, stated she has no male family member to accompany her to Sundargarh.
¶ 4.1The Opposite Party-husband, a daily-wage helper at M/s Suraj Products Limited through a contractor, contended that frequent leave would be difficult and that he faces a threat to life if the case is transferred.
¶ 5He further alleged that the Petitioner is a skilled teacher earning about Rs. 30,000 per month and that her claim of dependency is false.
¶ 5Asked to identify her institution and the basis for this allegation, his counsel could not answer.
¶ 5.1The Court's interim order dated 17.12.2025 in I.A. No. 451 of 2025 was later vacated.
¶ 1502Issues
i.1. Whether the transfer of Matrimonial Case No. 50 of 2025 from Sundargarh to Padampur is warranted under Section 24 CPC, having regard to the Petitioner-wife's convenience, her economic circumstances, and the Opposite Party's objections on employment and safety.
¶ 4, 4.1, 5, 6, 7ii.2. Whether the unpleaded factual assertions of dependency and lack of an escort, and the contested allegation of the Petitioner's income, can be given weight in deciding the transfer.
¶ 4.1, 5, 5.103Law Applied
Section 24 CPC permits transfer of a proceeding where the ends of justice so require.
¶ 6In matrimonial transfer pleas, courts must consider the economic soundness of both parties, their social standing, their standard of life, and their livelihood circumstances, and, given prevailing socio-economic conditions in India, the wife's convenience must generally be considered (N.C.V. Aishwarya v. A.S. Saravana Karthik, 2022 SCC OnLine SC 1199).
¶ 6The High Court of Orissa and District Courts Use of Electronic Communication and Audio-Video Electronic Means Rules, 2025 permit virtual appearance for non-effective hearings, while requiring physical presence on dates of evidence and effective hearing.
¶ 10Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 24
04Reasoning
Applying the Aishwarya principle, the Court treated the wife's convenience as the central consideration.
¶ 6, 7The Petitioner's dependence on her widowed mother, the roughly 205 km distance, and the absence of an escort together supported transfer, since these factors bear directly on her ability to attend proceedings.
¶ 4, 4.1The Court did not rely on the escort fact alone, because it was not pleaded and was raised only on instructions at the hearing.
¶ 4.1The Opposite Party's objections received less weight. His claim of difficulty in taking leave from daily-wage work was a matter of inconvenience, and his allegation of a threat to life was not discussed in the reasoning.
¶ 5The Court found his allegation that the wife is a skilled teacher earning Rs. 30,000 per month unsubstantiated, because his counsel could not identify her employer or the basis for the claim.
¶ 5.1The Court noted that the husband was "allegedly" working at a company in Barpali, Rajgangpur, and used that to justify video-conferencing facilities at Padampur for his convenience, while preserving physical attendance for evidentiary hearings.
¶ 10The reasoning does not explicitly resolve the contested income dispute, and the Court relied on the wife's convenience without making a finding on her actual financial position.
¶ 5.1, 6, 705Holding
Under the Aishwarya principle and Section 24 CPC, the Petitioner-wife's convenience justified transfer, and the petition was allowed.
¶ 6, 7The Senior Civil Judge, Sundargarh, was directed to transmit the record of Matrimonial Case No. 50 of 2025 to the Senior Civil Judge, Padampur, preferably within one week of receiving a certified copy of the judgment.
¶ 8The Padampur court was directed to re-register the case if required and proceed in accordance with law, giving both parties due opportunity.
¶ 9The Padampur court was asked to explore video-conferencing for non-effective hearings, with physical presence required for evidentiary hearings.
¶ 10The parties were directed to monitor listing dates, avoid unnecessary adjournments, and cooperate for early disposal.
¶ 11, 12The interim order dated 17.12.2025 in I.A. No. 451 of 2025 was vacated.
¶ 15Original Court PDF
MANINI PRADHANvsLENIN KUMAR SHA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
