01Facts
The appellant was tried before the Additional Sessions Judge, Ludhiana, under Sections 307 and 506 IPC in FIR No. 12 dated 13.01.2002, Police Station Division No. 2, Ludhiana. He was convicted and sentenced to four years' rigorous imprisonment and a fine of Rs. 5,000 under Section 307 IPC, and six months' rigorous imprisonment under Section 506 IPC, with sentences to run concurrently.
¶ 2The prosecution case was that at about 1:30 p.m. on 13.01.2002, the complainant Harish Singh, after visiting a temple, sat in a car when the appellant emerged from a crowd, allegedly attacked him with a dagger, was kicked by Resham Singh so that the dagger fell, and then threatened to kill him.
¶ 3The alleged motive was that the appellant's brother was accused in a rape case and the complainant had supported the victim's family in a panchayat.
¶ 4The prosecution examined three witnesses: the complainant (PW-1), eye-witness Resham Singh (PW-2), and the Investigating Officer, ASI Harbans Lal (PW-3).
¶ 10The appeal was filed against the judgment of conviction and order on sentence dated 02.06.2005.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the prosecution proved beyond reasonable doubt that the appellant committed offences under Sections 307 and 506 IPC, given that the prosecution story was improbable, the eye-witness testimony was self-contradictory, and material witnesses were withheld.
¶ 7, 17ii.2. Whether the contradictions in the testimonies of PW-1 and PW-2 were material and fatal to the prosecution case.
¶ 1403Law Applied
The court applied Sections 307 (attempt to murder) and 506 (criminal intimidation) of the IPC, which formed the basis of the charges and conviction.
¶ 2, 12(a)The prosecution must establish its case beyond reasonable doubt through evidence that is natural, probable, and internally consistent, and material contradictions in eye-witness testimony that lack independent corroboration cannot sustain conviction.
¶ 14, 17The unexplained withholding of material eye-witnesses weighs against the prosecution.
¶ 12(e), (f)The judgment does not cite any precedent.
Provisions in the judgment · 3 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 307Section 506
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 173
04Reasoning
The court found the prosecution story unnatural and improbable. Although the FIR alleged no injury, the incident occurred in broad daylight at a crowded place with the complainant's supporters present, and the appellant remained on the spot long enough to be caught, yet was not apprehended.
¶ 12(a)–(c)The alleged motive was not supported by any evidence of a prior rape accusation against the appellant or his brother.
¶ 12(d)The prosecution did not examine Anil Jeet Singh Bedi, who was allegedly present, and did not name or examine the driver "Jony," who surfaced only in cross-examination.
¶ 12(e), (f)The alleged rescue by Resham Singh, who kicked the assailant through a closed window from the left side of the rear seat, was held physically impossible given the seating arrangement and the appellant's approach from the right side.
¶ 12(g), 15The court identified material contradictions between PW-1 and PW-2 regarding the brother's involvement in the rape case, the driver's identity, the location (Vishawakaram Chowk versus Bhagwan Chowk), the time (1:30 p.m. versus 2:00 p.m.), and the position of the dagger.
¶ 13(i)–(v)As there was no independent corroboration, these contradictions were held material.
¶ 14The inaction of the driver and co-passengers was considered unnatural.
¶ 16Cumulatively, the court held that the conviction rested on conjecture and surmise rather than proved facts.
¶ 1705Holding
The prosecution failed to prove the charges under Sections 307 and 506 IPC beyond reasonable doubt, because the story was improbable, the eye-witness evidence was materially contradictory and uncorroborated, and material witnesses were withheld without explanation.
¶ 14, 17The appeal was allowed. The impugned judgment of conviction and order on sentence dated 02.06.2005 were set aside, and the appellant was acquitted of all charges.
¶ 18Pending miscellaneous applications, if any, were disposed of.
¶ 19Original Court PDF
Gurnam SinghvsState Of Pb.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
