Punjab and Haryana High CourtAdministrative and Public LawProperty and Real Estate Law

Review of an earlier order, sought without hearing affected parties, shows predetermined mind and is unsustainable.

Amarjit Singh And Anr.v.The Financial Commissioner Revenue Pb. And Anr.

Review of an earlier order, sought without hearing affected parties, shows predetermined mind and is unsustainable.. Amarjit Singh And Anr. vs The Financial Commissioner Revenue Pb. And Anr.. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the land transferred by Binder Kaur to respondents No. 4 and 5 by registered sale deeds dated 09.05.1972 must be ignored or taken into account while computing surplus land in the hands of Surjan Singh.

The court held

The court did not finally determine whether the 09.05.1972 transfers must be ignored; that question is left to the revenue authorities, who must assess bona fides on the evidence under Section 4(5) without being influenced by the court's observations.

It also directed

Holding that the review was tainted by predetermined mind and the absence of a prior hearing, the court set aside the Commissioner's order dated 17.09.1984 (Annexure P-4) and the Financial Commissioner's order dated 27.04.1993 (Annexure P-5).

The matter is remanded to the Divisional Commissioner, Ferozepur, to hear all parties and State authorities, consider both orders dated 28.04.1980 and 19.11.1981, and decide whether either requires review. The parties are directed to appear before the Divisional Commissioner, Ferozepur, on 01.12.2026. Both writ petitions are disposed of.

01Facts

Petitioner No. 1, Surjan Singh, filed a declaration under Section 5(1) of the Punjab Land Reforms Act, 1972 ("the 1972 Act"), claiming 189 Kanal 8 Marla as owner on the appointed date, 24.01.1971.

¶ 4

The family's total holding, including sons' land, was 12.2951 hectares.

¶ 4

On 09.05.1972, petitioner No. 2, Binder Kaur, sold 3.4400 hectares to respondent No. 4 and 1.8443 hectares to respondent No. 5 by registered sale deeds.

¶ 4

On 03.10.1977, the Collector (Agrarian), Fazilka declared the land surplus, ignoring these sales.

¶ 4

On 28.04.1980, the Divisional Commissioner accepted Surjan Singh's appeal, holding the sales must be accepted and no surplus existed.

¶ 5–6

On 19.11.1981, on the transferees' appeal, the Divisional Commissioner upheld the Collector's order.

¶ 7

Facing conflicting orders, the Collector sought clarity, and the Divisional Commissioner sought and obtained the Financial Commissioner's permission to review the 28.04.1980 order.

¶ 8

On 17.09.1984, the Commissioner reviewed and set aside the 1980 order, upholding the 1981 order.

¶ 9

The Financial Commissioner dismissed both revisions on 27.04.1993.

¶ 10–11

Both parties filed writ petitions: the landowners (CWP 11214/1993) and the transferees (CWP 8981/1993).

¶ 12–13

Petitioners contended that the review was impermissible, that the authorities showed a predetermined mind, that no hearing was given before seeking review permission, and that the pre-Act sale deeds were bona fide and wrongly ignored.

¶ 14

02Issues

i.1. Whether the land transferred by Binder Kaur to respondents No. 4 and 5 by registered sale deeds dated 09.05.1972 must be ignored or taken into account while computing surplus land in the hands of Surjan Singh.

¶ 16

ii.2. Whether the review of the Divisional Commissioner's order dated 28.04.1980, undertaken without first hearing the stakeholders, is sustainable.

¶ 20–21

03Law Applied

Section 4 of the 1972 Act fixes the permissible area and, under Section 4(5), requires that any land transferred after the appointed day but before the Act's commencement be counted as if not transferred, unless the transfer is proved to be bona fide, with the onus on the transferor.

¶ 17–18

Where competing rights of stakeholders are affected, they must be heard before a reviewing authority acts; a review sought with a predetermined mind is unsustainable.

¶ 20

The bona fides of a transfer is a question of fact for the revenue authorities on the evidence on record.

¶ 24

No precedent is cited in the judgment.

Provisions in the judgment · 2

Punjab Land Reforms Act, 1972 Section 4Section 5

04Reasoning

Applying Section 4(5), the court held that the sales of 09.05.1972 fell after the appointed day and before the Act's commencement, so the transferor (Binder Kaur) bore the onus of proving bona fides.

¶ 19

Stakeholders holding valuable rights, both the landowners and the transferees, were not heard before the Divisional Commissioner sought permission to review only the 1980 order.

¶ 20

The review targeted only the order favouring the landowner while leaving the conflicting 1981 order untouched, which led the court to infer a predetermined mind.

¶ 20

Because the review process was vitiated, the Commissioner's order of 17.09.1984 and the Financial Commissioner's order of 27.04.1993 could not stand.

¶ 21

The court did not decide whether the sales were bona fide. It noted that the sale deeds were ignored merely because no specific khasra numbers were mentioned, and that inadequacy of consideration alone is not a ground to invalidate them, but it left these factual questions to the revenue authorities.

¶ 14, 24

05Holding

The court did not finally determine whether the 09.05.1972 transfers must be ignored; that question is left to the revenue authorities, who must assess bona fides on the evidence under Section 4(5) without being influenced by the court's observations.

¶ 19, 24

Holding that the review was tainted by predetermined mind and the absence of a prior hearing, the court set aside the Commissioner's order dated 17.09.1984 (Annexure P-4) and the Financial Commissioner's order dated 27.04.1993 (Annexure P-5).

¶ 21

The matter is remanded to the Divisional Commissioner, Ferozepur, to hear all parties and State authorities, consider both orders dated 28.04.1980 and 19.11.1981, and decide whether either requires review. The parties are directed to appear before the Divisional Commissioner, Ferozepur, on 01.12.2026. Both writ petitions are disposed of.

¶ 22–23, 25
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Amarjit Singh And Anr.vsThe Financial Commissioner Revenue Pb. And Anr.

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment