Punjab and Haryana High CourtAdministrative and Public LawTax Law

Reply period for a fresh show-cause addition must be realistically achievable; holiday-only windows vitiate faceless assessment.

Wingreens Farms Private Limitedv.National Faceless Assessment Centre Through Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax

Reply period for a fresh show-cause addition must be realistically achievable; holiday-only windows vitiate faceless assessment.. Wingreens Farms Private Limited vs National Faceless Assessment Centre Through Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the writ petition should be entertained despite the statutory alternative remedy of appeal under Section 246A.

The court held

The writ petition was maintainable despite the alternative remedy of appeal.

It also directed

The time given in the notice of 23.03.2024 was not reasonable and could not realistically be complied with.

The refusal of the petitioner's timely request for time, without considering the relevant factors under Section 144B(1)(xiii), was unjustified.

The assessment order is therefore vitiated for breach of natural justice and of Section 144B.

The assessment order dated 27.03.2024, the computation sheet, the Section 156 demand notice, and the penalty notices (Annexures P-32 to P-36) are set aside. The matter is remanded to the stage of the show-cause notice dated 23.03.2024 for fresh proceedings under Section 144B.

The Department must enable e-proceedings within one week of receiving a certified copy. The petitioner must file its complete reply within two weeks thereafter. All uploaded material, including that of 27–28.03.2024, forms part of the record. Any personal hearing requested must be held by video-conference with at least five working days' notice. Any extension application must be made within the allowed time and decided by a reasoned order. Penalty proceedings may be initiated afresh if warranted. The fresh assessment must be completed within the period permitted by law under Section 153(6)(i). Merits, including the applicability of Sections 68 and 56(2)(viib) and Rule 11UA, are left open. The petition is allowed. No costs were awarded. The ruling rests on its particular facts and does not entitle assessees to extensions as a matter of course.

01Facts

The petitioner, a Gurugram-based food products company, filed its return for AY 2022-23 declaring a loss of Rs. 41.07 crore.

The case was selected for scrutiny on a "mismatch in expenditure and large share premium received".

¶ 3(i)

Between July 2023 and February 2024, five notices under Section 142(1) were issued, including a query on whether the excess of share price over fair market value should be taxed under Section 56(2)(viib). The petitioner replied and stated that the excess had already been offered to tax.

¶ 3(ii)

The first show-cause notice dated 06.03.2024 proposed only two disallowances and did not mention the share premium. The petitioner replied and attended a hearing on 14.03.2024.

¶ 3(iii)

On 21.03.2024 at 5:09 PM, the Assessment Unit sought valuation and supporting documents for the share premium "on Top Priority Basis." The petitioner replied on 23.03.2024.

¶ 3(iv)

At 4:01:59 PM on Saturday, 23.03.2024, a second show-cause notice was issued. It proposed treating the entire securities premium of Rs. 133.92 crore as unexplained cash credit under Section 68. It required a reply by 5:00 PM on Monday, 25.03.2024, a gazetted Holi holiday, and stated that no further adjournment would be given.

¶ 3(v)–(vi)

On 26.03.2024, the petitioner sought two days to reply, citing receipt during holidays. The request was refused as the assessment would be "time barred by 31/03/2024".

¶ 3(vii)

On 27.03.2024, the petitioner sought time till 28.03.2024. The order-sheet records only "Action Taken – Ok." The draft order was approved the same day, noting that the assessee "has choosen not to respond".

¶ 3(viii)

The petitioner uploaded its reply, referring to 94 annexures, on 27–28.03.2024. The parties dispute whether the portal closed mid-upload.

¶ 3(ix)

The final assessment order dated 27.03.2024 made all three additions, assessed income at Rs. 113.13 crore, stated that the petitioner "failed to reply" on the Section 68 addition, taxed that addition under Section 115BBE, and initiated penalty proceedings.

¶ 3(x)

This Court issued notice and stayed further proceedings on 18.04.2024.

¶ 3(xi)

02Issues

i.1. Whether the writ petition should be entertained despite the statutory alternative remedy of appeal under Section 246A.

¶ 10(i) · ¶ 11–12

ii.2. Whether the time of less than one working day (two non-working days and a holiday) given in the show-cause notice dated 23.03.2024 was reasonable and realistically capable of compliance.

¶ 10(ii) · ¶ 13–16

iii.3. Whether the petitioner showed sufficient cause, and whether the refusal of its request for time was justified.

¶ 10(iii) · ¶ 17–19

iv.4. Whether the assessment order is vitiated and, if so, what relief should follow.

¶ 10(iv) · ¶ 20–28

03Law Applied

Section 143(3), which requires assessment after hearing the assessee, and Section 144B (as substituted by the Finance Act, 2022). Under Section 144B(1)(xii)(b), a show-cause notice must be issued before a prejudicial addition is made. Clause (xiii) requires a reply within the specified time or such extended time as is granted on application. Clauses (xiv) and (xv) allow the Unit to proceed on the record if no reply is filed. Section 144B(6)(vii)–(viii) provides a right to a video-conferenced personal hearing.

¶ 7(a)–(d)

The NFAC SOP dated 03.08.2022 normally allows seven days, which may be shortened in light of limitation.

¶ 8 · ¶ N.1.3.1–N.1.3.2

The period must leave the right to reply real. It must be reasonable in the circumstances, and a timely request for time must be considered and decided by a reasoned order.

¶ 9(ii)–(iv)

Natural justice requires a real, not illusory, opportunity.

¶ 9(v)

An appeal is no bar where natural justice is violated, following Whirlpool Corporation v. Registrar of Trade Marks (1998) 8 SCC 1, Radha Krishan Industries v. State of Himachal Pradesh (2021) 6 SCC 771, and Godrej Sara Lee Ltd. v. Excise and Taxation Officer (2023).

¶ 11

Sona Builders v. Union of India (2001) 10 SCC 280: inadequate time is a gross breach of natural justice.

¶ 21(a)

Raj Kumar Dey v. Tarapada Dey (1987) 4 SCC 398: lex non cogit ad impossibilia.

¶ 18

Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner (1978) 1 SCC 405: an order cannot be supported by reasons first given in an affidavit.

¶ 19

The prejudice test in State Bank of Patiala v. S.K. Sharma (1996) 3 SCC 364 was applied.

¶ 20

Section 153(6)(i) governs limitation for fresh assessments following a court direction.

¶ 26

Provisions in the judgment · 14

Income Tax Act, 1961 14 provisionsSection 36Section 37Section 56Section 68Section 115BBESection 142Section 143Section 144BSection 153Section 156Section 246ASection 270ASection 271AACSection 274

04Reasoning

The objection was based on violation of natural justice, which is an accepted exception to the alternative-remedy rule. The relevant facts came from the Department's own order-sheet and letters, and the appellate remedy could not cure the denial of a hearing that occurred through no fault of the assessee.

¶ 11–12

The show-cause notice was issued at 4:01 PM on a Saturday, with the reply due on a holiday after a Sunday. No working day was available to gather investor-wise confirmations, bank records, and identity documents. The reference to a round-the-clock portal did not make holidays working days.

¶ 13

Although the SOP permits shortening the seven-day period, shortening does not permit a period that cannot be met. Two or three working days could easily have been granted, since the Department finished the draft and final order within two days of 25.03.2024. The urgency arose from the Department's own delay: the share premium was flagged in June 2023 but omitted from the first show-cause notice.

¶ 14

The addition was qualitatively different. Section 68 requires proof of identity, creditworthiness, and genuineness for each investor, whereas the earlier queries concerned Section 56(2)(viib).

¶ 15

The petitioner acted at the first working day and sought only two days, well within limitation.

¶ 17

Since the entire window fell on holidays, a request for time made at the first reasonable opportunity was a timely application under clause (xiii) that the authority was bound to consider with reasons.

¶ 18

The refusal was based solely on limitation and did not consider the holidays, the new nature of the proposal, or the two-day request. The later reasons in the affidavit could not supply the missing reasoning. The second request received only "Action Taken – Ok."

¶ 19

The finding that the petitioner "failed to reply" was contrary to the record and was not a harmless error. The Section 68 addition, which was the bulk of the assessed income, attracted Section 115BBE and penalty, and the denial of opportunity caused real and demonstrable prejudice.

¶ 20

The Court relied on comparable decisions, including Dish TV India Ltd. (Bombay HC), Advance Realty Developers (Gujarat HC), Ramesh Kumar Jain (Chhattisgarh HC), and this Court's decisions in Arihant Roller Flour Mills and A.D. Enterprises.

¶ 21(c)–(f)

The right to reasonable time is not a licence to delay, and an assessee who lets reasonable time lapse without cause cannot reopen the stage.

¶ 22

The pressure of completing assessments before limitation did not justify denying each assessee the statutory opportunity.

¶ 23(c)

05Holding

The writ petition was maintainable despite the alternative remedy of appeal.

¶ 12

The time given in the notice of 23.03.2024 was not reasonable and could not realistically be complied with.

¶ 16

The refusal of the petitioner's timely request for time, without considering the relevant factors under Section 144B(1)(xiii), was unjustified.

¶ 19

The assessment order is therefore vitiated for breach of natural justice and of Section 144B.

¶ 27

The assessment order dated 27.03.2024, the computation sheet, the Section 156 demand notice, and the penalty notices (Annexures P-32 to P-36) are set aside. The matter is remanded to the stage of the show-cause notice dated 23.03.2024 for fresh proceedings under Section 144B.

¶ 28(i)–(ii)

The Department must enable e-proceedings within one week of receiving a certified copy. The petitioner must file its complete reply within two weeks thereafter. All uploaded material, including that of 27–28.03.2024, forms part of the record. Any personal hearing requested must be held by video-conference with at least five working days' notice. Any extension application must be made within the allowed time and decided by a reasoned order. Penalty proceedings may be initiated afresh if warranted. The fresh assessment must be completed within the period permitted by law under Section 153(6)(i). Merits, including the applicability of Sections 68 and 56(2)(viib) and Rule 11UA, are left open. The petition is allowed. No costs were awarded. The ruling rests on its particular facts and does not entitle assessees to extensions as a matter of course.

¶ 24, 25, 26, 28(iii)–(viii), 29, 30
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Wingreens Farms Private LimitedvsNational Faceless Assessment Centre Through Principal Chief Commissioner Of Income Tax

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment