Punjab and Haryana High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Statutory orders must be judged by the reasons stated in them; fresh grounds cannot supplement them.

Attar Singhv.State Of Haryana And Others

Statutory orders must be judged by the reasons stated in them; fresh grounds cannot supplement them.. Attar Singh vs State Of Haryana  And Others. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the respondents can justify the orders of recovery and termination dated 25.08.2023 by supplementing or substituting grounds not stated in the impugned orders.

The court held

A statutory order cannot be justified by grounds not stated in it, and orders founded on a factually disproved premise cannot stand.

It also directed

Both writ petitions were allowed. The impugned orders dated 25.08.2023 terminating the petitioner's services (CWP-24172-2023, Annexure P-1) and directing recovery of salary for 2019 to August 2022 (CWP-19658-2023, Annexure P-1/P-4) were set aside. Pending applications, if any, were disposed of. The Court did not separately adjudicate the audi alteram partem ground.

01Facts

The petitioner was appointed Pump Operator (Jal Karmi) by Resolution No. 5 dated 17.03.2020 passed by Gram Panchayat, Hidayatpur (respondent No. 5).

¶ 3

On 22.06.2023 he received a notice from respondent No. 2 seeking a reply to a Gram Panchayat resolution dated 15.02.2023 alleging unsatisfactory work. He replied on 26.06.2023, stating he had worked for five years and no complaint had been received.

¶ 3

By order dated 25.08.2023 (CWP-19658-2023, Annexure P-4), respondents directed recovery of salary paid from 2019 to August 2022 on the ground that the tubewell was not commissioned before August 2022 for want of an electric connection.

¶ 4, 16

The same date's order (CWP-24172-2023, Annexure P-1) terminated his services, again without a hearing and without being conveyed to him.

¶ 6, 18

The recovery order was stayed on 05.09.2023, and the termination order was stayed on 20.10.2023.

¶ 5, 6

The petitioner produced electricity bills from 01.09.2018 to 10.07.2021 showing an electric connection and payments by the PHED.

¶ 5, 20

By letter dated 18.09.2023, respondents admitted the tubewell had been commissioned since 2018-19 and electricity bills were paid, but shifted the justification to the laying of a Jal Jeevan Mission (JJM) pipeline completed in August 2022.

¶ 7, 21

The written statement dated 09.02.2024 repeated this stance and alleged the appointment resolution was fraudulently procured.

¶ 8, 21

An RTI reply dated 15.02.2025 admitted an old pipeline existed but records were unavailable.

¶ 8, 9, 22

A letter dated 27.10.2023 stated JJM work was conducted in August 2021.

¶ 10, 12

02Issues

i.1. Whether the respondents can justify the orders of recovery and termination dated 25.08.2023 by supplementing or substituting grounds not stated in the impugned orders.

¶ 11 · ¶ 22–23

ii.2. Whether the termination order dated 25.08.2023 can be sustained where the sole ground stated in it is factually incorrect on the petitioner's documentary evidence.

¶ 18–20, 22

iii.3. Whether recovery of salary paid from 2019 to August 2022 under the "no work, no pay" principle is sustainable where the stated basis for non-work is disproved.

¶ 16–21

03Law Applied

The Court's reasoning rests on writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.

¶ 1

A statutory authority's order must be judged by the reasons stated in it and cannot be supplemented by fresh reasons in affidavits or otherwise, drawn from Rashmi Metaliks Ltd. v. Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority and Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner, AIR 1978 SC 851.

¶ 11, 23

Public orders must be construed objectively from their language, not from later explanations of the officer's intent, following the principle in Gordhandas Bhanji.

¶ 23

The petitioner's prayer invoked the principle of audi alteram partem (no hearing before termination), but the Court did not expressly decide that ground.

¶ 11

The recovery and termination orders were tested against the "no work, no pay" premise on which they were founded.

¶ 16, 18

04Reasoning

The Court first examined the stated basis of both orders dated 25.08.2023. Both rested on the premise that the tubewell was not commissioned before August 2022 for want of an electric connection.

¶ 17–19

The petitioner's electricity bills from 2018 to 2021 disproved that premise, and respondents later admitted the tubewell was commissioned in 2018-19.

¶ 20–21

Respondents then advanced a new ground, the absence of a pipeline before the JJM work of August 2022. The Court held this was impermissible. Applying Mohinder Singh Gill and Gordhandas Bhanji, an order must stand or fall on its own stated reasons, and the impugned orders did not mention any pipeline deficiency.

¶ 18, 21, 23

The Court also found the new ground factually unsupported. The RTI reply admitted an old pipeline existed, and the JJM completion dates in respondents' own correspondence were inconsistent.

¶ 8–10, 22

The Court treated respondents' allegation that the appointment resolution was fraudulent as unsubstantiated. Respondents' own pursuit of termination and recovery indicated ill intent, since the resolution would have been irrelevant had it been fraudulent.

¶ 15

Because the stated ground was false and the substituted ground was impermissible, the orders could not be sustained. The "no work, no pay" recovery therefore lacked any valid factual basis.

¶ 19–21

05Holding

A statutory order cannot be justified by grounds not stated in it, and orders founded on a factually disproved premise cannot stand.

¶ 25

Both writ petitions were allowed. The impugned orders dated 25.08.2023 terminating the petitioner's services (CWP-24172-2023, Annexure P-1) and directing recovery of salary for 2019 to August 2022 (CWP-19658-2023, Annexure P-1/P-4) were set aside. Pending applications, if any, were disposed of. The Court did not separately adjudicate the audi alteram partem ground.

¶ 11, 25, 26
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Attar SinghvsState Of Haryana And Others

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 19, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment