Punjab and Haryana High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

Relaxation of a statutory transfer policy requires prior Chief Minister approval and recorded reasons; unreasoned cut-off changes are quashed.

Kuldeep Kumarv.State Of Haryana And Another

Relaxation of a statutory transfer policy requires prior Chief Minister approval and recorded reasons; unreasoned cut-off changes are quashed.. Kuldeep Kumar vs State Of Haryana And Another. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the respondents could alter the cut-off date from 31.03.2025 to 30.11.2024 through the impugned letter dated 11.12.2024, in violation of the Transfer Policy dated 13.01.2023 as amended on 10.05.2023.

The court held

The cut-off date of 30.11.2024 was fixed without valid exercise of the Clause 12 power, because prior Chief Ministerial approval and reasons were absent from the record.

It also directed

The petitioner's 2024 participation did not estop him from challenging the change in the cut-off date.

The writ petition was allowed and the letter dated 11.12.2024 (Annexure P-4) was quashed. The interim direction dated 01.04.2025, permitting the petitioner to participate provisionally with consideration held in abeyance, was made absolute. The Court did not expressly address the mandamus prayer (cut-off of 31.03.2025 and a bar on transfer drive pending that).

01Facts

The petitioner was appointed Section Officer on 28.12.2011 and promoted Accounts Officer on 10.10.2022.

¶ 2

The State notified an Online Transfer Policy on 13.01.2023 for Accounts Officers of the SAS (OB) Cadre in the Finance Department. It required the qualifying date for vacancies, merit points and stay to be 31 March of the transfer year, with the process to be completed by 31 March and implemented on 1 May.

¶ 3

A notification dated 10.05.2023 amended Clause 3(c) so that an employee could participate in the transfer drive after one year's service in a Zone.

¶ 4

The petitioner completed one year on 16.02.2025.

¶ 5

By letter dated 11.12.2024, the respondents fixed the verification cut-off date as 30.11.2024, which rendered the petitioner ineligible.

¶ 5

A list dated 18.03.2025 of eligible Accounts Officers omitted the petitioner's name.

¶ 5

On 01.04.2025 the Court permitted the petitioner to participate provisionally, with any decision on his consideration held in abeyance.

¶ 7

The State contended that the petitioner had participated in the 2024 drive under a 30.11.2023 cut-off without objection, and that the cut-off was relaxed under Clause 12 because the 2025 drive could not begin in time.

¶ 10-11

The petitioner relied on Vijay Garg v. State of Haryana, CWP-3-2025, decided 16.01.2025.

¶ 8

02Issues

i.1. Whether the respondents could alter the cut-off date from 31.03.2025 to 30.11.2024 through the impugned letter dated 11.12.2024, in violation of the Transfer Policy dated 13.01.2023 as amended on 10.05.2023.

¶ 5, 9, 12

ii.2. Whether the power of relaxation under Clause 12 was validly exercised, given the requirements of prior approval of the Chief Minister and recording of reasons.

¶ 6, 13-14

iii.3. Whether the petitioner is estopped from challenging the cut-off date because he participated in the 2024 transfer drive without objection.

¶ 10, 16

03Law Applied

The Transfer Policy dated 13.01.2023, as amended on 10.05.2023, fixes 31 March as the qualifying date for vacancies, merit points and stay, and permits participation after one year's service in a Zone.

¶ 3-4

The Policy is treated as a statutory instrument published in the Haryana Government Gazette, with compliance mandatory.

¶ 14

Clause 12 empowers the Administrative Secretary, Finance Department, to relax any provision, but only with the prior approval of the Chief Minister and after recording reasons justifying the relaxation.

¶ 13-14

Following Vijay Garg v. State of Haryana, the State cannot supply justification in its reply. Reasons must appear in the file noting and the order itself, and the prior approval must be genuinely obtained and reflected in the record.

¶ 14, quoting Vijay Garg · ¶ 8

There is "no negative parity", so an employee's earlier acquiescence in a different cut-off does not estop him from challenging an unlawful change in a later drive.

¶ 16

Provisions in the judgment · 3

Transfer Policy dated 13.01.2023 Section 3Section 4Section 12

04Reasoning

The impugned letter altered an essential term of a statutory policy by moving the cut-off from 31.03.2025 to 30.11.2024. This excluded the petitioner, who had completed one year's service by 16.02.2025 and was therefore eligible under the amended Clause 3(c).

¶ 5, 14, 16

The State had not shown prior Chief Ministerial approval under Clause 12, and the impugned order recorded none of the reasons the State now advanced, namely delay in starting the 2025 drive. Those reasons were therefore post hoc and could not be considered, following Vijay Garg.

¶ 14-15

The estoppel argument was rejected because the petitioner's ineligibility arose solely from the unauthorised change in the cut-off date, not from any waiver on his part.

¶ 16

The present case was held to be covered by Vijay Garg, and the State cited no contrary authority.

¶ 15

05Holding

The cut-off date of 30.11.2024 was fixed without valid exercise of the Clause 12 power, because prior Chief Ministerial approval and reasons were absent from the record.

¶ 14

The petitioner's 2024 participation did not estop him from challenging the change in the cut-off date.

¶ 16

The writ petition was allowed and the letter dated 11.12.2024 (Annexure P-4) was quashed. The interim direction dated 01.04.2025, permitting the petitioner to participate provisionally with consideration held in abeyance, was made absolute. The Court did not expressly address the mandamus prayer (cut-off of 31.03.2025 and a bar on transfer drive pending that).

¶ 1, 9, 17
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Kuldeep KumarvsState Of Haryana And Another

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment