01Facts
The petitioner was appointed as a Cleaner in the Haryana State Roadways Department on 20.07.1968, promoted as Assistant Fitter on 04.11.1970, and promoted as Fitter on 01.05.1974.
¶ 2He retired on 31.05.2008.
¶ 2He claimed the 3rd Assured Career Progression (ACP) benefit on completing 30 years' service, which he states fell due in 1998.
¶ 3The respondents rejected the claim on 09.03.2018, citing an adverse "honesty doubtful" ACR for 2004-05, relying on the 21.05.1973 instructions that such an ACR remains effective for 10 years.
¶ 3, 12In CWP-2269-2019, the Court on 31.10.2023 held that the 2004-05 report could not defeat a claim based on service up to 20.07.1998 and directed fresh consideration on that record.
¶ 8-9, 13On 03.01.2024 the respondents again denied the claim on the adverse-ACR ground.
¶ 14That order was withdrawn in CWP-7615-2024, which was disposed of as infructuous on 05.04.2024.
¶ 15The impugned order dated 08.08.2024 denied the claim on new grounds: the petitioner had already availed two promotions (last on 01.05.1974), the 07.01.1998 instructions contained no third ACP, and the 1998 Rules governed as he retired before the 2008 Rules were notified.
¶ 16The petitioner also alleged that junior Kishan Chand had received the 3rd ACP.
¶ 7, 1702Issues
i.1. Whether the respondents, after the Court's directions in CWP-2269-2019 to consider service up to 20.07.1998, could lawfully deny the 3rd ACP on grounds different from those in the earlier orders.
¶ 16-18ii.2. Whether the Haryana Civil Service (Assured Career Progression) Rules, 2008 apply to a petitioner who retired on 31.05.2008 but completed 30 years' service in 1998, such that the 3rd ACP is admissible.
¶ 3, 10, 12, 17iii.3. Whether the petitioner is entitled to the 3rd ACP, revised pension and stepping up of pay, and whether the impugned order dated 08.08.2024 is sustainable.
¶ 11, 1903Law Applied
The Haryana Civil Service (Assured Career Progression) Rules, 1998, under which ACP was available at 10 and 20 years of service.
¶ 3The Haryana Civil Service (Assured Career Progression) Rules, 2008, notified on 30.12.2008 and effective from 01.01.2006, which provide a 3rd ACP on completion of 30 years' regular satisfactory service.
¶ 3, 12The Government instruction dated 21.05.1973, under which an ACR with an "integrity doubtful" entry remains effective for 10 years.
¶ 6, 14The principle, from Rashmi Metaliks Ltd. v. Kolkata Metropolitan Development Authority (SC), quoting Mohinder Singh Gill v. Chief Election Commissioner (AIR 1978 SC 851), that a statutory order must be judged by the reasons stated in it and cannot be supplemented by fresh grounds.
¶ 18The rule that an employee with 10/20/30 years' service who has not received promotion is entitled to ACP, as recorded in the order dated 31.10.2023.
¶ 1304Reasoning
The Court held that the 2004-05 ACR could not be used against the petitioner, because the 31.10.2023 order directed that his record be assessed only up to 20.07.1998, and an adverse entry made after 30 years' service falls outside that period.
¶ 13, 17The respondents' new ground, that the 1998 Rules contain no 3rd ACP, was treated as an attempt to circumvent that direction.
¶ 17The Court found the reasoning untenable because the 2008 Rules were stated to be effective from 01.01.2006, when the petitioner was still in service, so they applied to him.
¶ 17The Court applied Rashmi Metaliks to hold that the respondents could not justify the order by reasons not stated in it.
¶ 18The Court noted that the respondents did not dispute that a junior had received the 3rd ACP.
¶ 1705Holding
The Court held that the impugned order dated 08.08.2024 (Annexure P-8) is unsustainable and quashed it.
¶ 19The Court held that the petitioner is entitled to the 3rd ACP upon completing 30 years' satisfactory service, with all consequential benefits, including revised pension and stepping up of pay to match juniors.
¶ 17, 19The respondents were directed to comply within six months, failing which they must pay interest at 6% per annum.
¶ 19Original Court PDF
Raj KumarvsState Of Haryana And Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
