01Facts
The petitioner was granted a licence by a sub-committee of the Panchayat Samiti, Pathankot, to use a plot measuring 27 ft x 15 ft (405 sq. ft.) for business. A 1978 resolution fixed a licence fee of ₹100 per month, with construction costs to vest in the Samiti on expiry.
¶ 2On 05.01.1994 the petitioner sought allotment of the plot at reserve price. After the Chief Minister directed allotment at reserve price on 11.01.1994, the Samiti passed Resolution No. 98 on 05.05.1995, a resolution signed only by the Executive Officer and approved by the Administrator, because no elected Samiti then existed. It requested Government sanction under Section 137 of the Punjab Panchayati Raj Act, 1994.
¶ 2.1, 2.2, 6On 12.06.1995 the Government granted conditional approval for allotment at ₹42,000 or the Tehsildar's valuation, whichever was higher, in relaxation of Rules 4(2) and 5 of the 1964 Rules. The conditions were that the elected Samiti pass a sale resolution and that the Samiti obtain clear Government approval before executing the sale deed.
¶ 2.2The petitioner deposited ₹1,08,000 (at ₹60,000 per marla) in 1996.
¶ 2.3An elected Samiti resolution dated 16.01.1997, signed only by the Chairperson, authorised the Executive Officer to execute the sale deed.
¶ 2.4The Department objected on 24.09.1997 that the resolution lacked the signatures of all members. The Samiti's explanation of 01.10.1997 that members had signed only to mark attendance was not accepted, and approval was withheld.
¶ 2.6, 2.7The petitioner's representation of 15.05.1998 was rejected on 05.08.1998 under the 1964 Rules as amended in 1984.
¶ 2.8The Samiti refunded ₹1,34,867 by cheque dated 09.03.1999, which was never encashed.
¶ 2.9The petitioner then filed this writ of mandamus seeking execution of the sale deed.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the Department was justified in withholding approval for execution of the sale deed on the ground that the Samiti's resolution dated 16.01.1997 was not signed by all members, where the Chairperson had signed it and the Samiti had acted under the Government's conditional sanction.
¶ 3, 4, 6.1ii.2. Whether the conditions of the Government's sanction dated 12.06.1995 were complied with, such that the allotment could be completed.
¶ 6, 6.1iii.3. Whether the proposed allotment, made at reserve price for the petitioner's business interests, could be sanctioned under Section 137 of the 1994 Act and Rules 4 to 7 of the 1964 Rules when it did not serve the interest of the Samiti.
¶ 7, 7.103Law Applied
Section 137(1) of the Punjab Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 empowers a Panchayat Samiti to acquire, hold and dispose of property, subject to the proviso that it must obtain the State Government's previous approval for any disposal of immovable property.
¶ 7Rules 4(1), 4(2), 5, 6 and 7 of the Punjab Panchayat Samitis and Zila Parishads (Sale, Lease and other Alienation of Property and Public Places) Rules, 1964. Rule 4(1) provides that property shall not ordinarily be sold if it can be leased out or profitably maintained, and Rule 4(2) requires sales by auction.
¶ 7Rule 6 requires prior Government sanction for disposal otherwise than by sale or lease.
¶ 7.1Rule 7 bars sanction for any sale, lease or disposition that is not in the interest of the Samiti or that causes public inconvenience.
¶ 7, 7.1A conditional sanction must be complied with before its benefit can be claimed, as reflected in the Government's rejection of the proposal.
¶ 6.1No precedents were cited in the judgment.
Provisions in the judgment · 1
Punjab Panchayati Raj Act, 1994 Section 137
04Reasoning
The 12.06.1995 sanction was expressly conditional. The Samiti had to pass a sale resolution and obtain clear Government approval before execution.
¶ 6No resolution signed by the members was ever submitted, and the petitioner did not show that member signatures were not required by statute. The Department's rejection therefore rested on non-compliance with a condition of sanction, and that rejection was not challenged.
¶ 6.1The allotment failed the substantive test under Rule 7. The 1995 resolution's stated reason, a reward for the petitioner's past help in obtaining Samiti land, was not an interest of the Samiti. The petitioner had found the rent unsatisfactory and sought a reserve-price allotment for his business needs. The 1997 resolution merely authorised execution and did not address the Samiti's interest.
¶ 7.1Government sanction could not properly be granted under the 1964 Rules, independently of the non-compliance point.
¶ 7.1The Court's reasoning does not expressly address the petitioner's claims of long possession and payment of the Tehsildar-determined price. It treats them as insufficient to override the statutory approval requirement and the Rule 7 bar.
¶ 305Holding
The Department was justified in rejecting the proposal for allotment. The conditions of the 12.06.1995 sanction were not met, and the allotment was not in the Samiti's interest under Rule 7 of the 1964 Rules.
¶ 6.1, 7.1No mandamus could issue to compel execution of the sale deed. The writ petition was dismissed, and pending applications were disposed of. No refund or other relief was directed.
¶ 8–9Original Court PDF
Mohan LalvsState Of Punajb & Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
