01Facts
Surat Singh died intestate on 10.01.1987.
¶ 3Defendant No. 1, Nishan Singh, relied on a Will dated 15.10.1986 allegedly executed in his favour and took possession of the suit land (20 kanal 6 marla, village Kheri Sharaf Ali, Tehsil Assandh, District Karnal). Mutation No. 3426 was sanctioned in his favour on the basis of the Will in 1987.
¶ 3, 5, 9The plaintiffs, as legal heirs, filed a suit in 2002 seeking a declaration that the Will and the mutation were illegal and not binding, and joint possession.
¶ 2, 9The plaintiffs pleaded fraud, undue influence and incompetence, and that the property was ancestral.
¶ 3The Trial Court upheld the Will and dismissed the suit as time-barred.
¶ 5The First Appellate Court reversed the findings on due execution and attestation of the Will, holding that the Will was not duly proved, and held that the property devolved on the heirs under Section 8 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
¶ 6–7The First Appellate Court nevertheless dismissed the suit as barred by limitation, as the plaintiffs had not explained the delay.
¶ 7The plaintiffs appealed under Section 100 CPC.
¶ 1, 8–1202Issues
i.1. Whether the First Appellate Court was justified in holding the suit for declaration and joint possession barred by limitation, having itself held that the Will was not duly proved and that the plaintiffs were entitled to inherit.
¶ 14 · ¶ 7, 25ii.2. Whether the limitation period for a suit by heirs seeking possession on the basis of inherited title runs from the date of the Will, the death of the predecessor, or the sanctioning of mutation, or is governed by Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963.
¶ 15, 17, 21iii.3. Whether defendant No. 1 can claim title by adverse possession, which would defeat the plaintiffs' inherited rights, when he neither pleaded nor proved it.
¶ 22–2403Law Applied
Article 58 of the Limitation Act, 1963 governs a suit for a declaration simpliciter regarding an instrument's invalidity, whereas a suit founded on title seeking possession of immovable property ordinarily falls under Article 65.
¶ 15Under Mohinder Singh v. Kashmira Singh (P&H DB, 1985), inheritance does not remain in abeyance; rights vest on the predecessor's death, an heir need not sue merely to establish devolved title, and a possession suit based on inherited title is governed by Article 65, with limitation running from the defendant's adverse possession, not from death or mutation.
¶ 17A Will relied upon as the source of title must be proved under Section 63 of the Indian Succession Act, 1925 read with Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872; an unproved Will cannot displace succession under the law of inheritance.
¶ 18Shyam Lal @ Kuldeep v. Sanjeev Kumar ((2009) 12 SCC 454) is confined to its facts and does not lay down an inflexible rule that every inheritance suit filed beyond three years is barred.
¶ 20–21Adverse possession must be specifically pleaded and proved, showing the nature of possession, the point from which it became hostile, and its open, continuous and unequivocal character for the statutory period (Karnataka Board of Wakf v. Government of India, (2004) 10 SCC 779; P.T. Munichikkanna Reddy v. Revamma, (2007) 6 SCC 59).
¶ 23Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
Hindu Succession Act, 1956 Section 8
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 58Section 65
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 43
Indian Succession Act, 1925 Section 63
04Reasoning
The Court first distinguished between a declaration simpliciter, governed by Article 58, and a suit for possession founded on inherited title, governed by Article 65. It examined the substance of the plaint and found that the plaintiffs' claim to their shares rested on succession and not on any title created by the declaratory decree. The declaration about the Will was therefore incidental to enforcing their inherited rights.
¶ 15–16Applying Mohinder Singh, the Court held that the death of Surat Singh and the sanctioning of mutation did not furnish the starting point of limitation for such a suit. The Court then held that the First Appellate Court erred in reckoning time from the execution of the Will, the mutation and the institution of the suit, because that approach ignored the distinction between the two types of suit.
¶ 17, 25On the defence, the Court noted that defendant No. 1 pleaded only ownership under the Will and never pleaded adverse possession. Since the Will had been held unproved, his claim of exclusive ownership could not stand, and mere possession, or the plaintiffs' admission of it, did not amount to ouster of co-heirs or substitute for the pleading and proof of adverse possession.
¶ 19, 22–24The Court held that Shyam Lal was distinguishable on its pleadings and facts.
¶ 2005Holding
The Court answered the substantive question of law in favour of the appellants. The suit was not time-barred, and the finding on Issue No. 5 was held legally unsustainable.
¶ 26–27The Second Appeal was allowed, and the judgments of the First Appellate Court and the Trial Court were set aside insofar as they dismissed the suit. The Court decreed the suit to the extent that the unproved Will dated 15.10.1986 would not affect the plaintiffs' lawful inheritance rights, and that Mutation No. 3426 would not defeat those rights. The plaintiffs are entitled to joint possession of the suit property to the extent of their respective shares in the estate of Surat Singh, as determined under the applicable law of succession, without prejudice to the other legal heirs. No order as to costs.
¶ 28–30Original Court PDF
Dhurlab Singh And AnrvsSukhwinder Singh And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
