Punjab and Haryana High CourtWills, Inheritance, and TrustsCivil Procedure and Evidence

Daughter Loses Challenge To Father's Will Favouring Sons, as P&H HC Holds Mere Exclusion Of Heirs Doesn't Invalidate It

Ranjit Kaurv.Tehal Singh And Others

Daughter Loses Challenge To Father's Will Favouring Sons, as P&H HC Holds Mere Exclusion Of Heirs Doesn't Invalidate It. Ranjit Kaur vs Tehal Singh And Others. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Will dated 01.10.2004 was duly executed and proved in accordance with law, so as to be free from suspicious circumstances and binding on the plaintiff.

The court held

The High Court held that the Will dated 01.10.2004 was duly executed and proved, free from suspicious circumstances, and that the exclusion of the plaintiff did not invalidate it.

It also directed

It further held that the concurrent findings of the courts below could not be disturbed under Section 100 CPC, and that no substantial question of law arose.

The regular second appeal was dismissed, and the Trial Court and First Appellate Court judgments and decrees were affirmed. Pending applications, if any, stood closed.

01Facts

The plaintiff, Ranjit Kaur, daughter of Sardara Singh, sued for a declaration that she owns a 1/7th share in her late father's agricultural land in Village Daudhar Sharki, Moga, and for a declaration that a Will dated 01.10.2004 and consequent mutation No. 13357 were void and not binding on her, with consequential permanent injunction.

¶ 3

She pleaded that the Will was forged and that Sardara Singh never executed it.

¶ 4.1

Defendants 1 to 4, the sons and beneficiaries under the Will, asserted that the testator executed it voluntarily in favour of those who had cared for him, and that the plaintiff had earlier challenged the Will before the revenue authorities without denying its execution.

¶ 5

The Trial Court framed nine issues, including whether the Will was illegal and void.

¶ 6

The plaintiff examined only herself as PW-1. The defendants examined both attesting witnesses, Ranjit Singh (DW-2) and Jagtar Singh (DW-3), along with the Office Kanungo (DW-1) who produced the Will record and mutation.

¶ 12

The Trial Court dismissed the suit on 05.07.2019.

¶ 8

The First Appellate Court (Additional District Judge, Moga) dismissed the appeal on 16.01.2023, holding the Will duly proved under Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, free from suspicious circumstances, and that exclusion of daughters and the wife did not vitiate it.

¶ 14

The plaintiff filed the present regular second appeal.

¶ 2, 10

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Will dated 01.10.2004 was duly executed and proved in accordance with law, so as to be free from suspicious circumstances and binding on the plaintiff.

¶ 12–14

ii.2. Whether the exclusion of the natural heir (the plaintiff) from the testator's estate, by itself, constitutes a suspicious circumstance vitiating the Will.

¶ 14, 15

iii.3. Whether the High Court, in second appeal under Section 100 CPC, can reappreciate evidence or interfere with concurrent findings of fact, and whether any substantial question of law arises.

¶ 16–18

03Law Applied

Section 68 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, which requires proof of a Will by at least one attesting witness, as applied by the First Appellate Court.

¶ 14

Parvathi Nairthi (Dead) v. Laxmi Nairthy (Dead), 2026(3) RCR (Civil) 96, that a Will is valid when executed in compliance with statutory requirements, attested, and free from suspicious circumstances, and that mere exclusion of natural heirs is not by itself a suspicious circumstance; concurrent findings on genuineness should not be lightly disturbed.

¶ 15

Jaichand v. Sahnulal, 2025(2) Apex Court Judgments (SC) 336, which, citing Navaneethammal v. Arjuna Chetty, AIR 1996 SC 3521, Kshitish Chandra Purkait v. Santosh Kumar Purkait, (1997) 5 SCC 438, Dnyanoba Bhaurao Shemade v. Maroti Bhaurao Marnor, (1999) 2 SCC 471, and Kondira Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai Sopan Gujar, AIR 1999 SC 2213, holds that under Section 100 CPC the High Court must not reappreciate evidence or substitute its view on fact, and may interfere only where a substantial question of law arises, or where the findings are contrary to mandatory law, Supreme Court precedent, inadmissible evidence, or made without evidence.

¶ 17, 18

Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100

04Reasoning

The Trial Court and First Appellate Court found that both attesting witnesses deposed to the Will's due execution, that the scribe and the testator's sound mental condition were established, and that the plaintiff's cross-examination of these witnesses produced nothing raising suspicion.

¶ 12, 13, 14

The plaintiff's case rested on a bald assertion of forgery and on the testator's alleged illiteracy, which the Trial Court rejected.

¶ 13

The First Appellate Court held that the testator's intent to exclude daughters, the absence of a regular deed writer, and the witness's inability to name other persons present did not amount to suspicious circumstances.

¶ 25–27

Applying Parvathi Nairthi, the High Court held that exclusion of the plaintiff, given the Will's explicit recital of the reasons for the bequest, did not invalidate it.

¶ 15

The appellant's counsel identified no suspicious circumstance and did not show that the concurrent findings were illegal, perverse, or based on misreading of evidence.

¶ 16

Under Jaichand, these concurrent findings of fact could not be reappreciated in second appeal, and no substantial question of law was shown.

¶ 17, 18

05Holding

The High Court held that the Will dated 01.10.2004 was duly executed and proved, free from suspicious circumstances, and that the exclusion of the plaintiff did not invalidate it.

¶ 15, 16

It further held that the concurrent findings of the courts below could not be disturbed under Section 100 CPC, and that no substantial question of law arose.

¶ 17, 18

The regular second appeal was dismissed, and the Trial Court and First Appellate Court judgments and decrees were affirmed. Pending applications, if any, stood closed.

¶ 18, 19, 20
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Ranjit KaurvsTehal Singh And Others

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment