Punjab and Haryana High CourtTransport, Maritime, and Aviation LawCivil Law

P&H HC Upholds Rs 21.69 Lakh Compensation For Man's Death, Rejects Claimed Rs 50,000 Monthly Income For Lack Of Proof

Sushma And Anrv.Devender And Ors.

P&H HC Upholds Rs 21.69 Lakh Compensation For Man's Death, Rejects Claimed Rs 50,000 Monthly Income For Lack Of Proof. Sushma And Anr vs Devender And Ors.. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased's monthly income at Rs.11,000/- where the claimants pleaded Rs.50,000/- per month without supporting documents

The court held

The court held that the Tribunal's income assessment of Rs.11,000/- per month was correct in the absence of documentary proof of higher income

It also directed

It held that future prospects and consortium had been duly awarded, so those grounds were rejected

It held that the 7.5% interest rate was a valid exercise of discretion and did not require enhancement to 12%

The appeal was dismissed, and pending applications were closed. The compensation of Rs.21,69,190/- with 7.5% interest stands.

01Facts

On 22.07.2024, Rakesh (aged 35), riding motorcycle HR-15E-3626, was allegedly struck head-on near Village Desh Khera by motorcycle HR-16AA-3289, driven by Devender (Respondent No. 1) and insured with Respondent No. 3 (Insurance Company)

¶ 2

Rakesh was hospitalised at several facilities and died on 25.07.2024.

FIR No. 212 was registered on 25.07.2024 at Police Station Julana

¶ 2.1

The claimants (the widow and minor son) filed a claim under Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988

¶ 2

The owner and driver denied negligence and alleged collusion, while the Insurance Company pleaded a three-day FIR delay, absence of eyewitnesses, and that the driver lacked a valid licence

¶ 3–4.1

The Tribunal (MACP-239-2024) held Devender solely responsible, assessed income at Rs.11,000/- per month (minimum wages), applied 40% future prospects, a one-third personal deduction, and a multiplier of 16, and awarded Rs.21,69,190/- with 7.5% interest. Liability was fixed on the insurer

¶ 7–7.3

The claimants appealed on four grounds: (a) income assessment, (b) omission of future prospects, (c) omission of consortium for the minor son, and (d) interest at 7.5% instead of 12%

¶ 8

The delay of 20 days in filing the appeal was condoned

CM-3934-CII-2026 order

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Tribunal erred in assessing the deceased's monthly income at Rs.11,000/- where the claimants pleaded Rs.50,000/- per month without supporting documents

¶ 11–12.1

ii.2. Whether the Tribunal omitted future prospects, warranting enhancement

¶ 13

iii.3. Whether the Tribunal omitted loss of parental consortium to the minor son

¶ 13

iv.4. Whether the 7.5% rate of interest should be enhanced to 12% per annum

¶ 14

03Law Applied

The court applied Section 166 of the Motor Vehicles Act, 1988, under which compensation is determined by the Tribunal on the evidence

¶ 2

For income, the court relied on the principle that, absent reliable documentary proof of earnings, the Tribunal may adopt the minimum wage notified by the State, as applied in Smt. Neeta v. Divisional Manager, MSRTC, Kolhapur (cited by the Tribunal)

¶ 7.1, 12.1

For interest, the court relied on Section 171 of the Act, which leaves the rate to the Tribunal's discretion, as explained in Puttamma v. K.L. Narayana Reddy

¶ 14, 14.1

For the overall standard, the court relied on State of Haryana v. Jasbir Kaur, (2007) 7 SCC 484, and Divisional Controller, KSRTC v. Mahadeva Shetty, (2003) 7 SCC 197, holding that compensation must be just and reasonable, neither a bonanza nor a pittance, and that Chapter XII is beneficial legislation not to be treated as a source of profit

¶ 15

Provisions in the judgment · 10 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Motor Vehicles Act, 1988 Section 166Section 134Section 158Section 171

Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 Section 106Section 125Section 281

Interest Act, 1978 Section 3

Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 34

Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 31

04Reasoning

On income, the court found the claimants produced no bank statements, lease deed, J-Form, or other document showing Rs.50,000/- monthly earnings from the RO plant partnership, agricultural land, or leased land. Since the Tribunal's own appraisal found no reliable evidence, the minimum-wage approach was upheld

¶ 11, 12, 12.1

On future prospects and consortium, the court found the appellants' grievance factually incorrect: the Tribunal had in fact awarded 40% future prospects and loss of parental consortium to the minor son

¶ 7.2, 13

On interest, the court held that the rate under Section 171 is a matter of judicial discretion. A 7.5% rate from the date of claim was neither arbitrary nor inadequate, so no interference was warranted

¶ 14.1

Finally, the court held that the overall award was just and fair, and nothing justified enhancement

¶ 15

05Holding

The court held that the Tribunal's income assessment of Rs.11,000/- per month was correct in the absence of documentary proof of higher income

¶ 12.1

It held that future prospects and consortium had been duly awarded, so those grounds were rejected

¶ 13

It held that the 7.5% interest rate was a valid exercise of discretion and did not require enhancement to 12%

¶ 14.1

The appeal was dismissed, and pending applications were closed. The compensation of Rs.21,69,190/- with 7.5% interest stands.

¶ 15–17
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Sushma And AnrvsDevender And Ors.

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment