01Facts
The plaintiffs (respondents 1–4) purchased 118K-2M of land at village Rohat, Sonipat, from defendants 1–3 under a sale deed dated 10.04.2003. Mutation was not sanctioned in their favour, but they remained in cultivating possession.
¶ 3.1Defendants 1 and 3 later sold 6K-8M from the same joint land to defendant 4 (the appellant, Mahendri) under a sale deed dated 30.08.2005, and mutation No. 5816 was sanctioned.
¶ 3.1 · ¶ 12The plaintiffs sued for a declaration that the 2005 sale deed and mutation were illegal, null, void and not binding on them.
¶ 3.2The Trial Court (Civil Judge (Junior Division), Sonipat) decreed the suit on 24.01.2017. It declared the 2005 sale deed and mutation not binding on the plaintiffs and restrained the defendants from interfering with possession or alienating the land.
¶ 7The Additional District Judge, Sonipat, dismissed defendant 4's appeal on 22.12.2021.
¶ 8Defendant 4 then filed the present regular second appeal.
¶ 902Issues
i.1. Whether the concurrent findings of the Trial Court and First Appellate Court, that the 2005 sale deed and mutation are not binding on the plaintiffs, can be disturbed in second appeal.
¶ 14ii.2. Whether the appeal raises any substantial question of law under Section 100 CPC.
¶ 1603Law Applied
Under Section 100 CPC, the High Court may interfere with findings of fact only where a substantial question of law arises, and not merely a question of law, as laid down in Kshitish Chandra Purkait v. Santhosh Kumar Purkait and Dnyanoba Bhaurao Shemade v. Maroti Bhaurao Marnor.
¶ 15The High Court may not reappreciate evidence to reach a different possible view, as laid down in Navaneethammal v. Arjuna Chetty.
¶ 15Interference is permissible only where the lower appellate court's findings are contrary to mandatory law or settled Supreme Court principles, are based on inadmissible evidence, or are without evidence, as laid down in Kondira Dagadu Kadam v. Savitribai Sopan Gujar.
¶ 15A mutation does not confer title, and a transferee's claim fails without proof of the transferor's ownership at the time of sale, as relied on by the First Appellate Court.
¶ 13These principles were applied through Jaichand v. Sahnulal, 2025(2) Apex Court Judgments (SC) 336.
¶ 15Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The appellant could not show that the lower courts' findings were illegal, perverse, or based on misreading of evidence, and the Court treated the findings as concurrent.
¶ 14The First Appellate Court found that the vendors' recitals in the 2005 sale deed (Ex. P-4) conflicted with their earlier 2003 sale deed (Ex. P-1). By Ex. P-1 they had already sold their shares in Khewats 21, 23 and 71, yet Ex. P-4 described them as still holding shares in those khewats.
¶ 13The First Appellate Court further held that, even if the 2005 mutation was not sanctioned, mutation does not confer title. Since the vendors' ownership at the time of the 2005 sale was not established, the sale deed and mutation carried no significance.
¶ 13Because these findings rested on evidence and on settled principles, no question of law arose for review in second appeal. The Court therefore declined to reappreciate evidence.
¶ 14–1605Holding
The Court held that there was no merit in the appeal and that no substantial question of law arose.
¶ 16The regular second appeal is dismissed, and the concurrent decrees of the Trial Court (dated 24.01.2017) and the First Appellate Court (dated 22.12.2021) are affirmed. The declaration that the 2005 sale deed and mutation No. 5816 are not binding on the plaintiffs, and the consequential injunction against interference, dispossession and alienation, therefore stand. All pending applications are closed.
¶ 17 · ¶ 7 · ¶ 18Original Court PDF
MahendrivsRaj Singh And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
