01Facts
Respondents 1 to 4 (legal heirs of Karam Chand, the alleged vendee) sued for possession by specific performance of an agreement to sell dated 03.03.2002 concerning Plot No. 6, measuring 190 sq. yds.
¶ 2The petitioners (defendants) denied execution of the agreement.
¶ 2The suit was instituted on 03.07.2023, more than 21 years after the agreement and after Karam Chand's death on 06.03.2019.
¶ 2The agreement recorded that, owing to suspension of sale deed registration in Ambala, the deed would be executed upon resumption of registration, whenever the vendee required.
¶ 5.2The plaint pleads that the restriction on registration in Ambala City was lifted during Karam Chand's lifetime, that he repeatedly approached Defendants 1 and 2 without response, and that the cause of action arose on Defendant 1's refusal to execute the sale deed.
¶ 5.2, 6The Trial Court (Civil Judge (Junior Division), Ambala) dismissed the petitioners' application under Order VII Rule 11 CPC by order dated 02.01.2025, holding that delay was explained, the agreement was open-ended, and limitation involved disputed facts.
¶ 5.1The petitioners challenged this under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the suit is ex facie barred by limitation on the averments of the plaint, such that it is liable to be rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC, notwithstanding that limitation ordinarily is a mixed question of law and fact.
¶ 5.2, 6ii.2. Whether the Trial Court committed a jurisdictional or material error in refusing rejection of the plaint under Order VII Rule 11 CPC.
¶ 5.1, 603Law Applied
Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC provides that a plaint is rejected where the suit appears from the plaint itself to be barred by law, and the Court must read the plaint as a whole with the documents relied upon.
¶ 5Limitation ordinarily is a mixed question of law and fact, but there is no absolute bar against rejection where the suit is ex facie barred on the plaint's own averments.
¶ 5.2The limitation period applied was three years, reckoned from the date of death (06.03.2019), which the Court treated as the outer limit even on the plaintiffs' most favourable reckoning; the judgment does not expressly name the governing Article of the Limitation Act, 1963 (Article 54 is implied).
¶ 6The plaintiff's pleaded cause of action (refusal after lifting of the registration ban) was treated as determinative of accrual.
¶ 5.2, 6The parties cited Suman @ Suman Punia v. Chameli; Babasaheb Ramdas Shirole v. Rohit Enterprises; Kulabandhu Ram Adarsh Sharma v. Nam Estates Pvt. Ltd.; Krishan Chand v. Nawab Singh; and Harjinder Pal Singh v. Narender Kumar Nangia; the judgment does not discuss their ratio.
¶ 4Supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution was invoked.
¶ 104Reasoning
The Trial Court's reasons (open-ended agreement, disputed facts) did not address the plaint's own chronology. The plaint pleaded that the registration ban was lifted during Karam Chand's lifetime, and that he sought execution without success.
¶ 6Accrual therefore occurred during his lifetime upon refusal, not on his death. Even reckoning limitation from 06.03.2019, the three-year period expired on 06.03.2022, whereas the suit was filed on 03.07.2023.
¶ 6Because the bar appeared from the plaintiffs' own pleadings, the question was not a disputed fact requiring evidence, and the Trial Court's refusal amounted to a material error.
¶ 6The Court's reasoning rests on the plaint and the agreement's recital; it does not engage with the respondents' contention that the agreement's stipulated performance date was unknown or that the cause of action was continuing.
¶ 4, 6, 17 as quoted in para. 5.205Holding
The suit was ex facie barred by limitation on the averments of the plaint, and the Trial Court erred in dismissing the Order VII Rule 11 application.
¶ 6The revision petition under Article 227 was allowed, the impugned order dated 02.01.2025 was set aside, and the plaint was rejected under Order VII Rule 11(d) CPC.
¶ 6Pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of.
¶ 7Original Court PDF
Monika And AnrvsManmohan And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
