Punjab and Haryana High CourtProperty and Real Estate LawAdministrative and Public Law

P&H HC Excludes Sale Deeds Of Notification Year In Land Compensation Under 2013 Act, Remands 50 Appeals

Gurnam Chand (Now Deceased) Thr His Legal Heirs And Anrv.State Of Haryana Thr. Collector Distt Sirsa And Anr

P&H HC Excludes Sale Deeds Of Notification Year In Land Compensation Under 2013 Act, Remands 50 Appeals. Gurnam Chand (Now Deceased) Thr His Legal Heirs And Anr vs State Of Haryana Thr. Collector Distt Sirsa And Anr. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Authority under Section 51 of the 2013 Act must first ascertain whether the Collector followed the parameters in Sections 26–30 before determining compensation under Section 69.

The court held

The Authority must determine market value under Section 26 of the 2013 Act using sale deeds of 2010, 2011 and 2012 for the 19.02.2013 notification, and 2008–2010 for the 04.11.2011 notification, with "year" meaning calendar year.

It also directed

The Authority must use sale deeds of the nearest vicinity, or the nearest village if none are available.

The Authority must consider the highest-priced 50% of those deeds.

The Authority must apply Explanation 4 with recorded reasons and reconsider the multiplier after calculating the land's distance from the urban area.

The Authority must award 12% per annum from the Section 4 date to the Collector's award.

All appeals were allowed by way of remand. The 100% solatium and severance findings were upheld.

Landowners need not refund compensation already paid, subject to the final order. The Authority was directed to hear the parties on 15.12.2026 and to receive the Collector's data. Pending applications were disposed of.

01Facts

The State issued a notification under Section 4 of the Land Acquisition Act, 1894 on 19.02.2013 for 202 Kanal 18 Marla of land in Village Chamal, Sirsa, for the Ratta Khera Kharif Channel.

¶ 4

A Section 6 declaration followed on 26.08.2013.

¶ 4

The Collector's award dated 10.01.2014 fixed market value at ₹22,30,000/acre.

¶ 5

On reference, the Rehabilitation and Resettlement Authority, Sirsa enhanced the value to ₹27,87,500/acre, applied a 1.25 multiplier, and awarded 100% solatium and 12% per annum additional compensation.

¶ 6–7

This was the second round of litigation; an earlier remand was ordered in RFA-1313-2018 on 07.09.2022.

¶ 7

A companion batch concerned a Section 4 notification dated 04.11.2011 (Naiwala Kharif Channel).

¶ 2–3, 27

Landowners sought enhancement, arguing for a 01.01.2014 deemed date, use of 2010–2012 sale deeds, a 1.5 multiplier, and 12% addition from the Section 4 date.

¶ 8

The State argued that 2013 was the year of proposed acquisition and that 2010–2012 deeds should be used.

¶ 9

The Authority had excluded the landowners' 2013 sale deed and the State's 2012 sale deeds and upheld the Collector's value for want of evidence.

¶ 13

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Authority under Section 51 of the 2013 Act must first ascertain whether the Collector followed the parameters in Sections 26–30 before determining compensation under Section 69.

¶ 14

ii.2. Whether, where a Section 4 notification under the 1894 Act (19.02.2013) was followed by a Collector's award after 01.01.2014, the "year of proposed acquisition" under Explanation 1 to Section 26(1) is 2013, so that 2013 sale deeds are excluded and the three preceding calendar years are considered.

¶ 11–13

iii.3. Whether the word "year" in Explanation 1 means a calendar year as defined under the General Clauses Act, 1897.

¶ 12

iv.4. Whether the 12% per annum additional compensation runs from the Section 4 notification date (Section 30(3)) or the Section 11 date (Section 69(2)).

¶ 20

v.5. Whether the Collector's or Authority's market value may be reduced or enhanced under Explanation 4 to Section 26(1), and how the multiplier and sale-deed selection should be determined.

¶ 17, 21, 23

03Law Applied

The court applied Sections 24(1)(a), 26, 30 and 69 of the Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013, together with the First Schedule.

¶ 4

Under Section 26(1)(b) and Explanation 1, market value is the average sale price from sale deeds registered in the three years immediately preceding the year of proposed acquisition, and Explanation 2 requires the highest-priced half of those deeds to be used.

¶ 10–11, 21

Section 26 Explanation 3 bars earlier compensation prices, and Explanation 4 permits discounting or enhancement on recorded reasons.

¶ 10, 17

Section 69(1) requires the Authority to first examine whether the Collector followed Sections 26–30.

¶ 14

Sections 30(3) and 69(2) provide 12% per annum additional compensation.

¶ 20

The General Clauses Act, 1897, s. 3(66) defines "year" as a calendar year.

¶ 12

The court relied on Madhya Pradesh Road Development Corporation v. Vincent Daniel, 2025 (7) SCC 798, paras. 23–27, which holds that transactions older than three years are excluded, that Explanation 4 is disjunctive, and that the Collector may enhance or reduce value on reasons, including the theory of deduction and belting.

¶ 10, 17

The court noted conflicting High Court views on the cut-off date in State v. Rajbir, 2022 LawFinder (P) 2363, and Krishan Singh v. State of Punjab, 2024 (3) RCR (Civil) 57.

¶ 11

Provisions in the judgment · 21 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Right to Fair Compensation and Transparency in Land Acquisition, Rehabilitation and Resettlement Act, 2013 20 provisionsSection 2Section 3Section 4Section 5Section 6Section 7Section 8Section 9Section 11Section 24Section 26Section 27Section 28Section 29Section 30Section 51Section 60Section 69Section 74Section 1

General Clauses Act, 1897 Section 3

04Reasoning

The Authority was bound to test the Collector's valuation against Sections 26–30 before applying Section 69, and it had not done so properly.

¶ 14, 17

Since the Section 4 notification (19.02.2013) preceded the 2013 Act's commencement and the award was not passed by 31.12.2013, the 2013 Act applies under Section 24(1)(a).

¶ 11, 13

The court rejected the 01.01.2014 cut-off as the reference point for the "year of proposed acquisition". It treated the Section 4 notification under the 1894 Act as the functional equivalent of the 2013 Act's proposal stage, so the year of proposed acquisition is 2013 and the 2013 deeds are excluded.

¶ 11, 13

Reading "year" as a calendar year avoids unstable 365-day windows and is consistent with the statutory text.

¶ 12

Including the proposal year would invite collusive deeds executed during the 12–15 month Social Impact Assessment window, which the Legislature sought to prevent.

¶ 14–16

The court reconciled Sections 30(3) and 69(2) by holding that, as no Section 4(2) notification existed, the 19.02.2013 notification governs, so the 12% addition runs from that date until the Collector's award.

¶ 20

The Authority had not calculated the land's distance from the urban area under the 2018 notification, so the 1.25 multiplier had to be reconsidered.

¶ 23

The Collector had not assessed value per Section 26 and had not produced complete sale-deed data for 2010–2012. The court directed the Collector to produce a chart of all 2009–2012 transactions, which it accepted on record.

¶ 17.1

Severance charges were upheld because no contrary evidence was produced.

¶ 24

Remand was appropriate so that landowners could lead evidence and verify the data.

¶ 25

05Holding

The Authority must determine market value under Section 26 of the 2013 Act using sale deeds of 2010, 2011 and 2012 for the 19.02.2013 notification, and 2008–2010 for the 04.11.2011 notification, with "year" meaning calendar year.

¶ 12–13, 26(i), 27

The Authority must use sale deeds of the nearest vicinity, or the nearest village if none are available.

¶ 26(ii) · ¶ 19

The Authority must consider the highest-priced 50% of those deeds.

¶ 26(iii) · ¶ 21

The Authority must apply Explanation 4 with recorded reasons and reconsider the multiplier after calculating the land's distance from the urban area.

¶ 26(iv) · ¶ 17–18 · ¶ 23

The Authority must award 12% per annum from the Section 4 date to the Collector's award.

¶ 20, 26(v)

All appeals were allowed by way of remand. The 100% solatium and severance findings were upheld.

¶ 24, 26

Landowners need not refund compensation already paid, subject to the final order. The Authority was directed to hear the parties on 15.12.2026 and to receive the Collector's data. Pending applications were disposed of.

¶ 28–29
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Gurnam Chand (Now Deceased) Thr His Legal Heirs And AnrvsState Of Haryana Thr. Collector Distt Sirsa And Anr

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment