01Facts
The plaintiff sued to recover ₹5,44,000, alleging that the defendant had borrowed ₹3,20,000 at 2% monthly interest and signed a bahi/tehrir recording the loan.
p. 1The defendant denied borrowing the money and alleged that the document was forged.
p. 1The Trial Court decreed the suit, finding the loan and execution of the bahi proved; the First Appellate Court affirmed.
p. 1The defendant’s principal argument in second appeal was that the plaintiff lacked a money-lending licence. To support that plea, he relied on photocopies of alleged bahi entries, marked A-1 to A-47, which the First Appellate Court held were not proved in accordance with law.
pp. 1–3, 5–702Issues
i.Whether the plaintiff’s alleged failure to prove that he held a money-lending licence rendered the recovery suit unsustainable
pp. 6–7ii.Whether the concurrent findings of the courts below disclosed a basis for interference in regular second appeal
pp. 7–903Law Applied
The Court applied the limits on second-appeal interference described under Section 100 of the Code of Civil Procedure and Section 41 of the Punjab Act: findings of fact, including findings based on documentary evidence, are not ordinarily open to reassessment in second appeal merely because they are alleged to be erroneous; interference is available where there is an error of law or procedure, or a substantial procedural error.
p. 8It also relied on the principle that photocopies not proved in accordance with law cannot be read as evidence, and that merely exhibiting a document does not dispense with proof.
pp. 6–7On the money-lending issue, the Court approved the First Appellate Court’s reliance on Angrej Singh v. Vijay Kumar, RSA No. 1439 of 2018 (O&M), decided 16 October 2018: a few prior transactions, without proof of their terms and conditions, do not by themselves establish that a person carries on the business of money lending requiring a licence.
pp. 6–7Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
04Reasoning
The appellant relied on photocopies of alleged bahi entries to establish that the plaintiff was conducting a money-lending business, but did not dispute that these were the only materials relied on for that issue. The documents had not been proved in accordance with law and therefore could not support the appellant’s contention.
pp. 6–7The First Appellate Court had also found that the transaction was a friendly loan for domestic needs and that a few earlier entries did not, without more, establish a money-lending business requiring a licence.
pp. 6–7The appellant identified no illegality, perversity, misreading of evidence, or procedural error in the concurrent findings; the limits on second-appeal jurisdiction therefore precluded interference.
pp. 7–805Holding
The Court held that no ground for interference was made out.
p. 9It dismissed the regular second appeal and directed that any pending applications also stand closed.
p. 9Original Court PDF
Parveen KumarvsMahaveer Sangwan
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
