01Facts
The petitioners challenged the rejection of their candidatures for appointment as TGT (English) pursuant to Advertisement No. 09 of 2015 and sought appointment to the posts.
¶ 2–3The advertisement required at least 50% marks in a Bachelor’s degree.
¶ 4–5Both petitioners had obtained 49.66% marks in English at graduation, but relied on Master’s degrees in English with 50% marks.
¶ 4–5The State contended that the relevant postgraduate marks were obtained after the application cut-off date of 21 September 2015; the record indicated that one petitioner’s improved Master’s result was declared on 26 February 2019.
¶ 4–502Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioners’ Master’s degrees in English could satisfy the advertised minimum qualification despite their having obtained the relevant marks after the application cut-off date.
¶ 3–5.1ii.2. Whether the petitioners were eligible for appointment when they had 49.66% marks in English at graduation, against the advertised minimum of 50%.
¶ 4–503Law Applied
The Court applied the principle that eligibility for recruitment is ordinarily determined with reference to the cut-off date prescribed in the advertisement, and that a qualification acquired afterward cannot cure an eligibility deficiency existing on that date.
¶ 5.1It referred to Ashok Kumar Sharma and Others v. Chander Shekhar and Another, (1997) 4 SCC 18, for the rule that eligibility is assessed as of the last date prescribed for applications.
¶ 4The Court considered the petitioners’ reliance on Manjit Singh v. State of Punjab and Others, 2010 (3) SCT 703, but held that it did not assist them on these facts.
¶ 3, 5.1The petitions were brought under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution of India.
¶ 204Reasoning
The advertised requirement was at least 50% marks in the Bachelor’s degree, while each petitioner had 49.66%.
¶ 4.1, 5Because the petitioners had not obtained the requisite postgraduate marks by the cut-off date, the Court held that their later-acquired qualification could not establish eligibility retrospectively or cure the shortfall existing on the relevant date.
¶ 5.1Accordingly, the reliance on Manjit Singh did not alter the outcome.
¶ 5.105Holding
The Court held that the petitioners could not rely on qualifications acquired after the prescribed cut-off date to satisfy the eligibility requirement.
¶ 6–7Both writ petitions were dismissed, and any pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of.
¶ 6–7Original Court PDF
Suman BalavsState Of Haryana And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
