01Facts
Employees working under the Samagra Shiksha Project sought Dearness Allowance (DA) at 189%, rather than 164%, with effect from 1 July 2021.
pp. 2–4The learned Single Judge granted that benefit and directed the Chandigarh Administration to pay the employees first and recover the amount from the Union of India.
pp. 2–4The Chandigarh Administration and the Union of India appealed.
pp. 2–4The Administration maintained that the scheme was fully funded by the Union, while the Union contended that it had released the amounts admissible under the scheme.
pp. 2–4The employees’ counsel submitted that the inter-governmental funding dispute should not prevent payment of the benefit awarded to them.
pp. 2–402Issues
i.1. Whether the employees working under the Samagra Shiksha Project were entitled to DA at 189% from 1 July 2021, rather than 164%.
pp. 5–6ii.2. Whether the Chandigarh Administration or the Union of India was responsible for funding and paying the enhanced DA under the scheme.
pp. 4–503Law Applied
The Court applied the principles that employees’ entitlement to a benefit should not be defeated by a dispute between governmental authorities over which authority must fund it, and that differential treatment may be arbitrary or discriminatory where similarly situated employees receive the benefit.
pp. 4–6It also relied on the scheme’s conceded funding arrangement: insofar as Chandigarh was concerned, the scheme was 100% funded by the Union of India, with implementation through the Chandigarh Administration.
pp. 4–6No statute or judicial precedent was cited.
pp. 4–604Reasoning
The Court upheld the DA award because the Union did not dispute that contractual employees were receiving DA at 189% from 1 July 2021, and it found no basis to treat the respondents differently where DA reflected increased cost of living.
p. 5It rejected the Union’s funding-allocation argument as a ground for avoiding payment, particularly since enhanced DA necessarily involved additional expenditure and the scheme was fully Union-funded in Chandigarh.
pp. 5–6However, because the Union was the financially liable authority and could ensure implementation, the Court set aside the direction requiring the Chandigarh Administration to pay first and seek reimbursement.
pp. 4–505Holding
The appeals were disposed of by upholding the employees’ entitlement to DA at 189% with effect from 1 July 2021.
pp. 6–7The Union of India was directed to release the benefit within eight weeks of receiving a copy of the order.
pp. 6–7The direction requiring the Chandigarh Administration to pay first was set aside; the Union was also directed to reimburse any amounts already paid by the Administration on the Union’s behalf, if not already reimbursed.
pp. 6–7Original Court PDF
Union Of IndiavsKuljit Kaur And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
