01Facts
The plaintiff brought a suit for permanent injunction concerning property at House No. 1189, Rama Mandi, Jalandhar.
¶ 1During the suit, he alleged that the defendants had dispossessed him and demolished the property, and applied under Order VI Rule 17 CPC to amend the plaint to plead those events and seek mandatory injunction restoring possession.
¶ 1–2The Trial Court dismissed the application, finding that the plaintiff had not shown due diligence, had not specified when the alleged dispossession occurred, and sought to alter the property’s description.
¶ 1, 5–5.1The plaintiff challenged that order under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1, 5–5.102Issues
i.1. Whether the proposed amendments to plead subsequent dispossession and seek restoration of possession should be allowed under Order VI Rule 17 CPC
¶ 2–4ii.2. Whether the Trial Court’s refusal to allow the amendments disclosed an illegality or material infirmity warranting interference under Article 227
¶ 5–6.103Law Applied
Order VI Rule 17 CPC permits amendments necessary to determine the real questions in controversy, but that discretion is not to be exercised mechanically; the applicant’s bona fides and the circumstances of the application are relevant
¶ 6Where an amendment is sought after commencement of trial, the applicant must establish that, despite due diligence, the matter could not have been raised earlier
¶ 5The Court relied on Rajesh Kumar Aggarwal v. K.K. Modi, recognising that amendments necessary to determine the real controversy may be allowed, while distinguishing that principle where the applicant’s conduct lacks bona fides
¶ 6Article 227 confers supervisory jurisdiction, exercised where the impugned order discloses an illegality or material infirmity
¶ 6.104Reasoning
The Court considered the proposed amendment vague because it did not identify the date, month, or year of the alleged dispossession, despite the defendants’ written statement having asserted from the outset that the plaintiff was not in possession and that possession had already been taken
¶ 6–6.1It also found that the proposed site plan materially changed the property description: the original depicted a ground-floor structure with a dilapidated room, while the amended plan showed a three-storeyed building without that room
¶ 5.1Given these unexplained changes, the delay, and the absence of a satisfactory explanation based on due diligence, the Court found no basis to disturb the Trial Court’s refusal
¶ 5.1, 6.105Holding
The Court held that the Trial Court had rightly dismissed the amendment application and that no illegality or material infirmity justified intervention under Article 227.
¶ 6.1–8The revision petition was dismissed; the Court clarified that its observations did not express an opinion on the merits of the underlying suit, and disposed of any pending miscellaneous applications
¶ 6.1–8Original Court PDF
Surjit SinghvsSandeep Arora And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
