01Facts
The petitioner, a victim of the 1984 Delhi riots, was allotted Plot No. 11-G (40 sq. yds.) in the 475 Acre Bhagat Singh Nagar Scheme under the Sikh migrant quota by the Ludhiana Improvement Trust through a letter dated 12.08.1987, at Rs. 88/sq. yd.
¶ 2–3, 14The allotment required either payment of Rs. 3,520 in lump sum or 1/4th of the price (Rs. 880) within 30 days, with the balance in instalments.
¶ 3, 14The petitioner alleged that, being impoverished, he could not pay.
¶ 3, 15The Trust cancelled the allotment on 20.01.1992 (Annexure P-2) for non-deposit.
¶ 4The petitioner later tendered payment, which the State rejected on 31.05.2007 (Annexure P-3) on the ground that the allotment had already been cancelled.
¶ 4Following the State's Policy dated 29.01.2015 (Annexure P-4), a one-time relaxation allowed defaulting allottees to regularise allotments on payment of dues, interest, penalty and restoration charges, and the petitioner sought relief under it.
¶ 5, 15–16The State rejected the petitioner's request by order dated 24.11.2015 (Annexure P-5) on two grounds: non-deposit of 1/4th of the price, and a 23-year delay. (Para. 1 of the judgment refers to 07.12.2015 for P-5; the operative paragraphs cite 24.11.2015.)
¶ 1, 6–7, 16The plot remained vacant and unallotted.
¶ 9, 27The Trust contended that the State's decision was binding on it, that the petitioner was delayed, and that he was estopped because he had not pleaded his poor economic condition.
¶ 11–12, 2102Issues
i.1. Whether the State was justified in rejecting the petitioner's claim under the 2015 one-time relaxation policy on the grounds of non-payment of 1/4th of the price in 1987 and a 23-year delay in approaching it.
¶ 16–17, 19–20ii.2. Whether the orders dated 20.01.1992 (P-2) and 24.11.2015 (P-5) are arbitrary and violative of Articles 14, 21 and 300-A of the Constitution of India.
¶ 16, 18, 26iii.3. Whether the Trust could defeat the petitioner's claim by objecting that he had not pleaded his economic hardship.
¶ 21–2203Law Applied
Article 14 of the Constitution: arbitrariness is antithetical to equality, and State action must not be arbitrary, as reaffirmed in Association for Democratic Reforms v. Union of India (2024) 5 SCC 1, which followed E.P. Royappa v. State of Tamil Nadu (1974) 4 SCC 3.
¶ 18Article 21 of the Constitution, including the right to shelter: allotment of a plot to a riot victim under a rehabilitation scheme gives effect to that right.
¶ 22Article 300-A of the Constitution.
¶ 26The Trust, as a statutory body, is an "authority" under Article 12 and is bound by norms of fairness and non-arbitrariness.
¶ 22Parens patriae doctrine from Charan Lal Sahu v. Union of India (1990) 1 SCC 613: the State must protect citizens unable to assert their rights due to calamity or displacement.
¶ 23The State is not an ordinary litigant and must not score technical points against its citizens, as stated in Chief Executive Officer, Gujarat Maritime Board v. Asiatic Steel Industries Ltd. (2022) 19 SCC 765, citing Dilbagh Rai Jarry v. Union of India (1974) 3 SCC 554.
¶ 23Articles 38 and 39 (Directive Principles of State Policy) are relied upon to construe welfare policies liberally.
¶ 24Legitimate expectation created by a widely publicised policy.
¶ 16–17Coordinate bench decision in CWP No. 1599 of 1994 (decided 24.04.2014), which granted relief to riot victims in analogous circumstances.
¶ 2504Reasoning
Default was the very condition for which the 2015 policy was framed, and so could not be a ground for disqualification; rejecting the claim on that basis rendered the policy nugatory.
¶ 17The State's reasons were found to be "totally cryptic" and not supported by any cogent explanation of why the petitioner fell outside the policy.
¶ 16, 20Because the policy was publicised widely, the petitioner had a legitimate expectation that his claim would be considered on merit.
¶ 17On delay, the Court accepted that the petitioner had repeatedly sought relief from the Trust and the State, and that the State, once aware he was a riot victim (as shown by the 1987 allotment), was obliged to consider his claim itself. Delay therefore could not defeat the claim.
¶ 19The Trust's objection that the petitioner had not pleaded poverty was rejected. A riot victim's inability to pay was presumed, and proof of what was evident from admitted facts was unnecessary.
¶ 21–22The Court deprecated the Trust for taking this plea as an instrumentality of the State.
¶ 21Applying CWP-1599-1994, the Court held that the principles there would govern the present case despite factual differences.
¶ 25The cancellation was not the reason for the 2015 rejection, and the policy was broad enough to cover restoration of cancelled plots.
¶ 2005Holding
The impugned order dated 24.11.2015 (P-5) is illegal, arbitrary, and violative of Articles 14, 21 and 300-A, and the Trust's estoppel objection is untenable.
¶ 26, 21–22The writ petition was allowed and the orders dated 20.01.1992 (P-2) and 24.11.2015 (P-5) were set aside. The order dated 31.05.2007 (P-3) is not expressly set aside in the operative part.
¶ 26 · ¶ 4, 26The Trust was directed to restore Plot No. 11-G to the petitioner forthwith, with delivery of possession. The petitioner must deposit the 1987 allotment price with 10% simple interest per annum within 30 days of the Trust's resumption order, subject to the condition that he is not already allotted any other plot at a concessional rate under the 1984 riot victims' reserved category.
¶ 29The State and Trust were directed to pass the necessary order within two months.
¶ 30Costs of Rs. 50,000 were awarded: Rs. 25,000 payable by the State and Rs. 25,000 by the Trust within two months by demand drafts.
¶ 31Authorities handling riot-victim claims are directed to exercise due care and not reject them in a casual or routine manner, and a copy of the judgment is to be sent to the Chief Secretary, Punjab.
¶ 32–33Original Court PDF
Mohinder SinghvsState Of Punjab And Anr.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
