Punjab and Haryana High CourtAdministrative and Public LawConstitutional Law

P&H HC Upholds Collector's Merit-Based Pick of Lambardar Over Late Incumbent's Son, Says Office Is Not a Hereditary Privilege

Raj Kumarv.State Of Haryana And Ors

P&H HC Upholds Collector's Merit-Based Pick of Lambardar Over Late Incumbent's Son, Says Office Is Not a Hereditary Privilege. Raj Kumar vs State Of Haryana And Ors. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the Collector's choice of respondent No. 4 as Lambardar is perverse, arbitrary, or contrary to law, such that it warranted interference by the Single Judge.

The court held

On Issue 1, the Court answered in the negative: the Collector's choice was not perverse or arbitrary and did not warrant interference.

It also directed

On Issue 2, hereditary preference cannot sustain the appellant's claim, given Karnail Singh.

On Issue 3, Vikramjit Singh is inapplicable because the merits of both candidates were considered.

The LPA was dismissed, and the Single Judge's judgment dated 17.08.2026, restoring respondent No. 4's appointment, was upheld. Pending civil miscellaneous applications were disposed of.

The Court observed that the States of Punjab and Haryana should ensure effective and impartial implementation of existing statutory rules governing the appointment, continuation, and removal of Lambardars. These observations are not framed as binding directions.

01Facts

The appellant applied for appointment as Lambardar of Village Simbalwal after the death of his father, the incumbent Lambardar.

¶ 2

The Sub-Divisional Officer (Civil)-cum-Assistant Collector Ist Grade, Shahbad, recommended the appellant, and the Gram Panchayat passed a resolution in his favour.

¶ 2

Respondent No. 4's candidature was recommended only by the Assistant Collector, Second Grade.

¶ 2

The Collector-cum-Deputy Commissioner, Kurukshetra, appointed respondent No. 4, reasoning that appointment merely because a person is the son of the deceased Lambardar would not be in the interest of justice.

¶ 3

On appeal, the Commissioner, Ambala Division, after a comparative assessment of both candidates, found the appellant more competent and appointed him on 26.09.2018.

¶ 4

The Financial Commissioner, Haryana dismissed respondent No. 4's revision on 30.10.2019.

¶ 5

The learned Single Judge allowed respondent No. 4's writ petition (CWP-36920 of 2019) on 17.08.2026, set aside the Commissioner's and Financial Commissioner's orders, and restored the Collector's appointment of respondent No. 4.

¶ 6

The appellant's revision was dismissed as withdrawn, and he filed this LPA under Clause X of the Letters Patent.

¶ 1, 6

02Issues

i.1. Whether the Collector's choice of respondent No. 4 as Lambardar is perverse, arbitrary, or contrary to law, such that it warranted interference by the Single Judge.

¶ 9

ii.2. Whether the appellant's claim, based on being the son of the deceased Lambardar, can sustain his appointment in light of the constitutional invalidity of hereditary preference.

¶ 10

iii.3. Whether the ratio of Vikramjit Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Cooperation), Punjab applies to the facts, where both candidates appeared and their merits were considered.

¶ 11-12

03Law Applied

The Collector's choice in appointing a Lambardar should not be disturbed unless it is perverse, arbitrary, or contrary to law.

¶ 9

Karnail Singh v. State of Haryana (Law Finder Doc ID #59385), a Division Bench decision, declared hereditary preference in appointment of Lambardars unconstitutional.

¶ 10

Vikramjit Singh v. Financial Commissioner (Cooperation), Punjab (Law Finder Doc ID #634414) is distinguishable where the Collector had failed to consider a contesting candidate's merits, indicating non-application of mind.

¶ 11-12

The Court referred generally to relevant statutory provisions governing Lambardar appointments, without identifying them.

¶ 8

The office of Lambardar is a public responsibility, not a hereditary privilege, and continuance depends on competence, integrity, availability, and performance.

¶ 15-19

04Reasoning

The appellant's principal argument was that the Collector ignored the SDO's recommendation and the Gram Panchayat resolution, and that his candidature rested on reputation and knowledge of the office, not merely on parentage. The Court rejected this.

¶ 7

The Court's review of the comparative merit table, which the appellant himself relied upon, disclosed no ground for interfering with the Collector's choice.

¶ 9

The appellant's sole basis was that he was the deceased Lambardar's son, and hereditary preference has been declared unconstitutional in Karnail Singh.

¶ 10

The Vikramjit Singh reliance failed because there the Collector had not considered a contesting candidate's merits at all, whereas here both candidates appeared, and their merits were duly considered and discussed.

¶ 11-12

Having found no perversity, arbitrariness, or illegality, the Court held that no ground for interference with the Single Judge's judgment existed.

¶ 13

The Court made broader observations on how hereditary succession harms rural governance and accountability, which were not necessary to the dismissal of the appeal.

¶ 15-19

05Holding

On Issue 1, the Court answered in the negative: the Collector's choice was not perverse or arbitrary and did not warrant interference.

¶ 9, 13

On Issue 2, hereditary preference cannot sustain the appellant's claim, given Karnail Singh.

¶ 10

On Issue 3, Vikramjit Singh is inapplicable because the merits of both candidates were considered.

¶ 11-12

The LPA was dismissed, and the Single Judge's judgment dated 17.08.2026, restoring respondent No. 4's appointment, was upheld. Pending civil miscellaneous applications were disposed of.

¶ 13-14, 20

The Court observed that the States of Punjab and Haryana should ensure effective and impartial implementation of existing statutory rules governing the appointment, continuation, and removal of Lambardars. These observations are not framed as binding directions.

¶ 18-19
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

Raj KumarvsState Of Haryana And Ors

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 18, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment