01Facts
Mehar Das and Soma Devi, senior citizens, claimed that they had funded the purchase and construction of House No. 1090, Sector 8, HUDA, Panipat, and transferred it to their sons subject to an obligation to maintain them.
¶ 3–8They sought maintenance, residence-related protection and relief concerning the 2019 conveyance deed under Section 23 of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007.
¶ 3–8The Maintenance Tribunal, Israna, passed an order dated 20 March 2025; the Appellate Tribunal, Panipat, subsequently directed each son to pay Rs. 10,000 per month and protected the parents’ residence, but the conveyance-deed claim remained undecided.
¶ 3–8The parents challenged the adequacy of the adjudication, while their son and daughter-in-law challenged the orders, including on the ground that the Maintenance Tribunal had not been constituted as required by the Haryana Rules.
¶ 9–1202Issues
i.1. Whether the Maintenance Tribunal’s order was legally sustainable when it was signed by the Sub-Divisional Magistrate alone, without recorded participation of the two non-official members required by Rule 3(1) of the Haryana Maintenance of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2009.
¶ 14–19ii.2. Whether the statutory authorities adequately adjudicated the senior citizens’ claim concerning the conveyance deed and the alleged failure to maintain them under Section 23 of the Act.
¶ 20–24iii.3. Whether interim maintenance and residence protections should continue while the matter is remitted for fresh adjudication.
¶ 30–3703Law Applied
Section 23(1) of the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 permits a transfer of property by a senior citizen to be declared void, at the transferor’s option, where the transfer was subject to the condition that the transferee provide basic amenities and physical needs and the transferee fails or refuses to do so; application of the provision requires findings on the nature of the transfer, the condition and the alleged failure.
¶ 21Rule 3(1) of the Haryana Maintenance of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2009 requires a three-member Maintenance Tribunal, comprising an official Chairperson and two non-official members.
¶ 15Rule 4(3) provides a limited exception allowing the Chairperson to decide an emergent matter when the Tribunal is not sitting, subject to ratification at its next sitting.
¶ 18The Tribunal must act within its statutory jurisdiction and decide the claims before it through a lawful, reasoned process.
¶ 23, 26Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 Section 23Section 16
04Reasoning
The order of 20 March 2025 bore only the Sub-Divisional Magistrate’s signature and did not establish either participation of the two non-official members or compliance with Rule 4(3), including a subsequent ratification.
¶ 17–19The defect went to the legality of the proceedings, and the Appellate Tribunal had not addressed it.
¶ 17–19Separately, the parties disputed the source of funds for the property and whether its transfer was conditional on the sons’ maintenance obligations.
¶ 22–24Those factual questions required examination of the evidence and reasoned findings under Section 23; neither impugned order had conclusively determined them.
¶ 22–24The High Court therefore remitted the matter rather than deciding the disputed facts itself, while preserving interim protections for the senior citizens.
¶ 26, 32, 36–3805Holding
Both writ petitions were allowed, and the orders dated 20 March 2025 and 25 March 2026 were set aside.
¶ 33–35The original application was remitted to a Maintenance Tribunal duly constituted under Rule 3 and applicable Government notifications for fresh, reasoned adjudication, preferably within three months of the parties’ appearance; the parties were directed to appear on 1 December 2026.
¶ 33–35Pending fresh adjudication or further competent orders, each son must continue paying Rs. 10,000 per month, the senior citizens must be permitted peaceful access to and residence in the house, and the Superintendent of Police, Panipat, must ensure implementation of the arrangement.
¶ 36These interim directions confer no final ownership or possessory rights, and the merits of the parties’ claims remain open.
¶ 37–38Original Court PDF
Mehar Das AnothervsDistrict Magistrate-Cum-Appellate Tribunal, Panipat Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
