01Facts
The petitioner challenged the Haryana Staff Selection Commission’s revised answer key for the Draftsman recruitment under Advertisement No. 7/2015.
pp. 2–6, 8–9He scored 150 marks in the written examination and 9 marks in the interview, for a total of 159, against a cut-off of 160; he was stated to be first on the waiting list.
pp. 2–6, 8–9Although he had objected to several questions, he pressed only his challenge to Question No. 97.
pp. 2–6, 8–9The petitioner selected Option B, “Gussa hona,” while the revised key marked Option C, “Sayam khona,” as correct.
pp. 2–6, 8–9The Commission relied on its expert-review process and submitted that expert opinion should prevail.
pp. 2–6, 8–9It also informed the Court that four vacancies existed in the relevant category.
pp. 2–6, 8–902Issues
i.Whether the Court could interfere with the revised answer to Question No. 97 where the petitioner relied on NCERT material and contended that his answer was correct
pp. 6–7ii.Whether, if the petitioner’s answer were accepted, he should be considered for appointment against an available vacancy
pp. 8–903Law Applied
The Court exercised its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.
p. 6It referred to Ran Vijay Singh v. State of Uttar Pradesh, which recognises judicial restraint in academic matters and deference to expert opinion, and to Siddhi Sandeep Ladda v. Consortium of National Law Universities, which it understood to permit judicial intervention where academic conduct adversely affects candidates and intervention is warranted.
p. 6It also relied on Richal & Ors. v. Rajasthan Public Service Commission, (2018) 8 SCC 81, for the proposition that a court may intervene where a model answer is demonstrably incorrect against authoritative academic sources.
p. 8The judgment’s approach was that deference to experts does not preclude intervention where the answer key is shown to be erroneous or the question and answer are ambiguous.
pp. 6–804Reasoning
The Court noted that the petitioner challenged only Question No. 97 and had selected Option B, whereas the revised key specified Option C.
pp. 6–9It considered the NCERT material relied upon by the petitioner to support Option B and found the answer key’s treatment of the idiom “Apae se bahar hona” erroneous.
pp. 6–9It also observed that the Commission had not placed details of the expert’s qualifications or methodology on record.
pp. 6–9Applying the stated exception to judicial restraint in academic matters, the Court intervened in the revised answer key.
pp. 6–9The petitioner’s score, the two marks assigned to the question, his position on the waiting list, and the existence of vacancies were relevant to the consequential relief.
pp. 6–905Holding
The writ petition was allowed.
p. 9The Court directed the respondents to consider the petitioner’s case for appointment as Draftsman under Advertisement No. 7/2015, Category No. 5, General category, in accordance with law.
p. 9It did not direct his appointment outright.
p. 9Pending applications, if any, were also disposed of.
p. 9Original Court PDF
Manoj KumarvsState Of Haryana And Another
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
