Punjab and Haryana High CourtAdministrative and Public LawEmployment and Labour Law

P&H HC Orders Recheck Of Welder Instructor Candidate’s 5 ‘Fatherless’ Marks Claim, With Appointment Conditional On Revised Merit

Deshrajv.Haryana Staff Selection Commission

P&H HC Orders Recheck Of Welder Instructor Candidate’s 5 ‘Fatherless’ Marks Claim, With Appointment Conditional On Revised Merit. Deshraj vs Haryana Staff Selection Commission. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

Whether the petitioner’s claim to five socio-economic marks should be assessed by treating the submitted certificate as potentially clarificatory, in light of the applicable recruitment conditions and the documents on record.

The court held

The petition was disposed of in terms of Manjeet Kumar.

It also directed

The respondents were directed to verify the petitioner’s entitlement to the five marks, award any marks found admissible, and recast the merit list.

If the petitioner then fell within the zone of consideration, the respondents were to take appropriate steps toward appointment.

If appointed, he would receive notional pay fixation and seniority at par with counterparts appointed in the same selection, but actual salary only from his date of joining.

Candidates already selected and continuously serving were not to be removed.

01Facts

The petitioner applied under the Backward Class-A category for the post of Welder (Gas and Electric) Instructor (Theory), Category No. 26, pursuant to Advertisement No. 12/2019.

¶ 1

The Commission did not award him five marks under the socio-economic criterion for a candidate whose father had died before the candidate attained the prescribed age, and his name was not recommended in the final result dated 23 January 2023.

¶ 1

He sought certiorari quashing the result and mandamus directing the award of those marks, relying on Nisha v. Haryana Staff Selection Commission and Manjeet Kumar v. State of Haryana.

¶ 2

The State did not dispute that the candidate in Nisha had submitted the relevant certificate after the application deadline.

¶ 3

02Issues

i.Whether the petitioner’s claim to five socio-economic marks should be assessed by treating the submitted certificate as potentially clarificatory, in light of the applicable recruitment conditions and the documents on record.

¶ 4–5

ii.Whether, if verification establishes that the petitioner is entitled to the marks and falls within the zone of consideration, consequential appointment-related relief should follow without displacing candidates already appointed.

¶ 5–7

03Law Applied

Article 226/227 of the Constitution provides the basis for the Court’s writ jurisdiction.

¶ 1

The Court relied on the distinction between substantive eligibility and proof of eligibility: although the required eligibility must ordinarily exist by the prescribed date, depending on the circumstances, later submission of proof may be permitted where it does not create substantive eligibility but clarifies information already available to the recruiting authority.

¶ 4

The Court referred to Charles K. Skaria v. Dr. C. Mathew, (1980) 2 SCC 752; Dolly Chhanda v. Chairman, JEE, (2005) 9 SCC 779; Ram Kumar Gijroya v. DSSSB, (2016) 4 SCC 754; Vashist Narayan Kumar v. State of Bihar, 2024 INSC 2; Divya Kalia v. State of Haryana; and Staff Selection Commission v. Smt. Bala.

¶ 4

It also applied the approach in Nisha and Manjeet Kumar: entitlement must be examined against the recruitment conditions and the documents available on the particular candidate’s record, rather than assuming that every later certificate is either automatically acceptable or automatically disqualifying.

¶ 4–5

Candidates originally selected and continuously serving should not be removed where the successful claimant can instead receive appropriate consequential relief.

¶ 7

04Reasoning

Following Manjeet Kumar, the Court did not itself determine that the petitioner was entitled to the five marks.

¶ 4–5

It directed the Commission to verify his claim against the applicable socio-economic criterion and the certificate and other documents on his recruitment record.

¶ 4–5

The distinction between substantive eligibility and proof therefore required an individualized assessment of whether the documents established entitlement, rather than an automatic rejection based on the timing of the certificate.

¶ 4–5

If the petitioner qualified after the merit list was recast, appointment-related relief could be granted while protecting candidates already appointed and continuously serving.

¶ 6–7

05Holding

The petition was disposed of in terms of Manjeet Kumar.

¶ 5

The respondents were directed to verify the petitioner’s entitlement to the five marks, award any marks found admissible, and recast the merit list.

¶ 5–7

If the petitioner then fell within the zone of consideration, the respondents were to take appropriate steps toward appointment.

¶ 5–7

If appointed, he would receive notional pay fixation and seniority at par with counterparts appointed in the same selection, but actual salary only from his date of joining.

¶ 5–7

Candidates already selected and continuously serving were not to be removed.

¶ 5–7
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

DeshrajvsHaryana Staff Selection Commission

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment