01Facts
The petitioner (Arun Fotedar, plaintiff) and respondents (Jitender Fotedar, defendant No. 1, and Sanjay Fotedar, defendant No. 2) are brothers.
¶ 2The plaintiff claims co-ownership of the built-up property on Plot No. C-2/72-73, Lord Krishna Enclave, Sushant Lok, Gurugram.
¶ 2.1–2.2The plaintiff alleges an oral family settlement that defendant No. 1 would occupy the property as a licensee and later shift to his own house on adjoining Plot C-2/71-B.
¶ 2.1–2.2After the father's death in 2017, defendant No. 1 allegedly refused to vacate.
¶ 2.3–2.4The plaintiff alleges that defendant No. 2 obtained a separate electricity connection for defendant No. 1 through a false affidavit.
¶ 2.3–2.4Following an incident on 31.05.2021, a legal notice dated 11.06.2021 was served.
¶ 2.5–2.6Defendant No. 1 replied on 20.06.2021, claiming he was not a licensee, that the property was owned by his brother, and that the family was a Joint Hindu Family.
¶ 2.5–2.6The plaintiff sued for a mandatory injunction for vacant possession of the first floor and mesne profits.
¶ 3In his written statement, defendant No. 1 pleaded that he funded the construction of the house from his own funds, that title stood in defendant No. 2's name, and that he is a co-owner.
¶ 4During trial, the plaintiff applied under Order 11 Rule 12 read with Section 151 CPC for discovery of bank statements, loan and EMI records, cheque counterfoils, contractor receipts, and income tax returns relating to the construction funding.
¶ 5The Trial Court dismissed the application by order dated 03.02.2025 (Annexure P-1).
¶ 6The plaintiff then filed this revision under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1, 702Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court was justified in dismissing the plaintiff's application under Order 11 Rule 12 CPC for discovery of documents as not necessary for fairly disposing of the suit, and as an impermissible fishing inquiry.
¶ 16, 16.1ii.2. Whether the impugned order is illegal or perverse so as to warrant interference under Article 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1703Law Applied
Order 11 Rules 12 and 14 CPC, under which discovery or production may be refused if the court is satisfied it is not necessary or not necessary at that stage, and discovery must not be ordered where it is not necessary for fairly disposing of the suit or saving costs; these provisions are discretionary, not mandatory.
¶ 12, 12.1In Basanagouda v. Dr. S.B. Amarkhed, (1992) 2 SCC 612, the Supreme Court held that the power to order production is coupled with discretion to examine the expediency, justness and relevancy of the documents to the matter in question.
¶ 13, 13.1In M.L. Sethi v. R.P. Kapur, AIR 1972 SC 2379, the Supreme Court held that a party may seek discovery of documents that throw light on the case, even if inadmissible, but must identify documents with reasonable specificity.
¶ 14In Ahuja Distributor v. Sarup Tanneries Ltd., (2008) 151 PLR 484, this Court held that Order 11 Rule 14 operates independently of Rule 12 and that the court may call for relevant documents suo motu.
¶ 15The plaintiff bears the burden of proving title and termination of licence, and Order 11 Rule 12 cannot be used to gather evidence for the applicant's claim.
¶ 16Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The Trial Court identified the core controversy as the plaintiff's title to the suit property and defendant No. 1's alleged illegal occupation.
¶ 16It held that the plaintiff had not explained how the sought documents (funding of construction, loan records, and tax returns) were relevant to proving title or termination of licence, and that the application was an attempt at a fishing inquiry.
¶ 16This Court found the impugned order consistent with Basanagouda and M.L. Sethi, because the plaintiff did not show how the requested documents would throw light on the matters in issue.
¶ 16.1Counsel for the petitioner failed to demonstrate relevance before this Court either.
¶ 17The judgment does not expressly address whether defendant No. 1's written statement, which pleads that he funded the construction and claims a proprietary share, made the funding records relevant to a matter in question. That pleaded defence may have strengthened the relevance argument, and the Court's reasoning rests principally on the petitioner's failure to articulate relevance.
¶ 4, 705Holding
The Court held that the Trial Court's dismissal of the Order 11 Rule 12 application was not illegal or perverse, and that the petitioner failed to demonstrate the relevance of the sought documents to the controversy.
¶ 16.1, 17The civil revision under Article 227 is dismissed, and the impugned order dated 03.02.2025 stands affirmed.
¶ 18All pending applications, if any, stand closed. The suit proceeds before the Trial Court without the discovery sought.
¶ 19Original Court PDF
Arun FotedarvsDr. Jatinder Fotedar And Another
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
