01Facts
The plaintiffs sued for a declaration, with consequential relief of mandatory and permanent injunction, alleging that the defendants had encroached on their land.
The plaintiffs pleaded possession over 116 sq. yards at points CDEF.
The Trial Court partly decreed the suit for 46 sq. yards, relying on a subsequent demarcation report.
¶ 2The Additional District Judge, Sonepat, dismissed the defendants' appeal and affirmed that decree.
¶ 1The demarcation (Ex. P-17) was conducted using a total survey machine/DGPS, and the locations of nearby Khasra Nos. 579, 1012, 1091, 2049 and 2056 were verified before demarcating Khasra Nos. 864, 865 and 866.
¶ 3The defendants did not object to this report before the competent Court.
¶ 3The defendants asserted no ownership of Khasra No. 865 and produced no title document for Khasra No. 864. The plaintiffs did not dispute the defendants' possession of Khasra No. 864.
¶ 3.1The defendants were found in possession of 46 sq. yards of Khasra No. 865, belonging to the plaintiffs.
¶ 3.102Issues
i.1. Whether a decree for 46 sq. yards is impermissible as beyond the pleaded claim of 116 sq. yards, where the decree rests on a subsequent demarcation report without amendment of the plaint.
¶ 2 · ¶ 3.2ii.2. Whether the demarcation reports (Ex. P-3 and Ex. P-17) can be relied upon, given their alleged contradiction, the non-examination of the Local Commissioner, and proof of his report through an interested witness.
¶ 2iii.3. Whether the First Appellate Court exceeded the scope of appeal by recording a finding on the plaintiffs' ownership of the entire Khasra No. 865, without a cross-objection under Order XLI Rule 22 CPC.
¶ 2.103Law Applied
A decree must remain within the framework of the pleadings, and no relief can ordinarily be granted on a case never set up by the parties, as stated in Bachhaj Nahar v. Nilima Mandal, (2008) 17 SCC 491, and Ram Sarup Gupta v. Bishun Narain Inter College, (1987) 2 SCC 555.
¶ 3.2A demarcation report which only ascertains the actual extent of an alleged encroachment within disputed property does not introduce a new cause of action or independent relief.
¶ 3.2The appellants invoked Order XLI Rule 22 CPC on cross-objections in relation to the ownership finding, but the Court did not discuss that provision.
¶ 2.1The Court's review was confined to whether the First Appellate Court's findings rested on proper appreciation of evidence, including the demarcation report, and whether any perversity, misreading of evidence or legal infirmity was shown.
¶ 3.304Reasoning
The appellants' pleadings-based challenge failed because the demarcation report only quantified the encroachment within the plaintiffs' property and did not create a new cause of action or relief. The Bachhaj Nahar and Ram Sarup Gupta principles were therefore held inapplicable on these facts.
¶ 3.2On the evidentiary challenge, the Court relied on the DGPS-based methodology and the verification of neighbouring khasra locations in Ex. P-17. It also noted that the appellants never objected to the report before the competent Court.
¶ 3The Court further observed that the appellants neither claimed ownership of Khasra No. 865 nor produced title to Khasra No. 864, and that the plaintiffs did not dispute the appellants' possession of 864. This implicitly undermined the appellants' defence based on long possession and the location of Balmiki houses.
¶ 3.1 · ¶ 2.1The Court did not separately address the non-examination of the Local Commissioner or the alleged contradiction between Ex. P-3 and Ex. P-17, nor the Order XLI Rule 22 objection to the ownership finding. It held generally that the First Appellate Court's findings rested on proper appreciation of the material evidence.
¶ 3.305Holding
The decree for 46 sq. yards does not travel beyond the pleadings, because the demarcation report only determined the actual extent of the encroachment and introduced no new cause of action.
¶ 3.2No perversity, misreading of evidence or legal infirmity was found in the First Appellate Court's judgment.
¶ 3.3The appeal was dismissed, and the decree of the Trial Court, as upheld by the First Appellate Court, was affirmed. All pending miscellaneous applications were disposed of.
¶ 3.3 · ¶ 1 · ¶ 4The "Whether reportable" field in the judgment is left blank.
Original Court PDF
Krishan @ Krishana Kumar And OthersvsRohtash (Since Deceased) Through His Lrs And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
