01Facts
The plaintiff-respondents sued for a declaration of ownership based on adverse possession, with consequential permanent injunction.
The trial court decreed the suit on 16.12.2002, and the First Appellate Court dismissed the defendants' appeal on 25.09.2009.
¶ 1On 30.08.2010, notice of motion was issued on the limited contention that a suit for ownership based on adverse possession was not maintainable.
¶ 1The appeal was then deferred pending the Supreme Court's decision on whether adverse possession is available as a sword or only a shield. On 05.12.2014, counsel agreed to await that outcome.
¶ 2By order dated 06.03.2017 in another appeal, the Supreme Court remitted the maintainability question to the High Court, leaving all contentions open.
¶ 3On 30.05.2019, the Court directed that the appeal be decided on its merits, as no further wait was needed.
¶ 4In Ravinder Kaur Grewal v. Manjit Kaur, (2019) 8 SCC 729, a three-Judge Bench held that a plaintiff may plead title by adverse possession.
¶ 5On 26.09.2019, on the express submission of the appellants' senior counsel that the appeal was rendered infructuous, the RSA was dismissed.
¶ 5The review applicant, Gajraj Singh (Appellant No. 3), through GPA Dinesh Yadav, filed the review after a 167-day delay, condoned by separate order, CM-1562-C-2021.
¶ 6The review applicant contends that other grounds, including failure to prove the ingredients of adverse possession, were omitted through bona fide counsel error. The applicant also relies on Section 100 CPC and Section 41 of the Punjab Courts Act, 1918.
¶ 6–702Issues
i.1. Whether the review applicant has established a ground for review under Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC to recall the judgment dated 26.09.2019.
¶ 9ii.2. Whether the orders dated 06.03.2017 and 30.05.2019 required the appeal to be decided on all grounds on merits, such that the 26.09.2019 dismissal overlooked a binding direction.
¶ 4, 12iii.3. Whether the omission of grounds through a bona fide mistake of counsel, or the plaintiffs' unexamined burden to prove adverse possession, justifies a fresh hearing of the appeal.
¶ 11, 13–1403Law Applied
Order XLVII Rule 1 CPC permits review only for an error apparent on the face of the record, discovery of new and important matter, or any other sufficient reason.
¶ 9Review is not an appeal in disguise and cannot be used to reargue or rehear the matter, as laid down in Parsion Devi v. Sumitri Devi, (1997) 8 SCC 715, and S. Murali Sundaram v. Jothibai Kannan, (2003) 13 SCC 515.
¶ 9, paras 16–18An error that must be detected by a process of reasoning is not an error apparent on the record, and a mere possibility of two views is no ground for review, as stated in Kamlesh Verma v. Mayawati, (2013) 8 SCC 320.
¶ 10, para 20.2A plaintiff may acquire title by adverse possession and may sue on that basis under Article 65 of the Limitation Act, 1963, thereby overruling contrary authority, as held in Ravinder Kaur Grewal, (2019) 8 SCC 729.
¶ 5Maintainability and proof of adverse possession are separate questions.
¶ 13Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Limitation Act, 1963 Section 5Section 65
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100Section 114
04Reasoning
The 26.09.2019 judgment was passed in the presence of senior counsel, who expressly conceded that the appeal had become infructuous after Ravinder Kaur Grewal. The applicant did not dispute this concession, and no error was shown in the legal proposition accepted and applied.
¶ 11The orders of 06.03.2017 and 30.05.2019 do not alter this outcome. The 2017 order left contentions open in a different appeal and did not remand this RSA, and the 2019 direction did not bar disposal on the concession later made.
¶ 12The applicant's real grievance is that counsel should have pressed the proof-based grounds. That amounts to seeking a fresh hearing, which is outside review jurisdiction.
¶ 11Although the plaintiffs' burden of proving adverse possession remains, the decrees were available for challenge at the time of hearing, and reopening them would require re-examination of evidence.
¶ 13Reliance on Section 100 CPC and Section 41 of the Punjab Courts Act does not change the limited scope of review.
¶ 13The plea that a litigant should not suffer for counsel's mistake cannot justify rehearing where the impugned decision reflects a deliberate concession on binding law.
¶ 1405Holding
The review applicant has shown neither new material nor an error apparent on the face of the judgment dated 26.09.2019. The grievance of a bona fide mistake of counsel, and the request to reargue unpressed grounds, do not justify recall or fresh hearing.
¶ 14The review application is dismissed on merits. CM-1563-C-2021, seeking to restrain alienation of the suit property, is disposed of as infructuous. There is no order as to costs, and all pending applications stand dismissed.
¶ 14–16Original Court PDF
Ramanand And OrsvsRam Kumar And Ors
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
