01Facts
The petitioner, Balwan, is the Judgment Debtor in execution proceedings pending since 18.12.2017 before the Executing Court.
¶ 2On 27.05.2019, the Executing Court permitted ex parte proceedings against him to continue.
¶ 1, 2On the next date of hearing, he moved an application to set aside the ex parte proceedings and recall the 27.05.2019 order.
¶ 2The Executing Court dismissed that application on 29.08.2019. It reasoned that the Judgment Debtor could not be so remiss as to not remain in contact with his counsel or ascertain the proceedings of 27.05.2019 in time. It also noted that he had not offered a satisfactory explanation for contesting at that late stage.
¶ 2The petitioner then filed a revision under Article 227 of the Constitution challenging both orders.
¶ 1, 1.1It is admitted that no substantive progress occurred in the execution after the ex parte order.
¶ 302Issues
i.1. Whether the Executing Court erred in dismissing the Judgment Debtor's application to set aside the ex parte proceedings, although it was moved on the very next date of hearing and the Judgment Debtor was otherwise unable to show diligence.
¶ 2, 3ii.2. Whether the Judgment Debtor could be wholly precluded from participating in the execution proceedings, or whether the relief should be moulded to permit participation from the stage reached on his appearance.
¶ 3, 403Law Applied
The court exercised supervisory jurisdiction under Article 227 of the Constitution of India to review the Executing Court's orders.
¶ 1The court did not refer to any specific statutory provision (such as the CPC) or precedent.
A litigant's procedural discipline must be balanced against the fundamental requirement that he be afforded an opportunity to contest execution proceedings, without unnecessarily unsettling steps already taken.
¶ 3The timeliness of the application, and the absence of substantive progress after the ex parte order, are relevant to the scope of relief.
¶ 304Reasoning
The court held that the Executing Court's approach produced an unduly restrictive result. The Judgment Debtor was excluded from the proceedings even from the stage at which he appeared.
¶ 3Two factors weighed heavily in his favour. First, he applied to set aside the ex parte order on the very next date of hearing. Second, no substantive progress followed the ex parte order.
¶ 3The court found that, even if recall was not warranted, the petitioner should not have been entirely excluded from participation from the point at which proceedings stood on his appearance.
¶ 3Rather than deciding whether the 27.05.2019 order should be recalled, the court moulded the relief to a limited participatory right. The petitioner accepted this limited relief on instructions.
¶ 4The court confined its observations to the revision and disclaimed any opinion on the merits.
¶ 505Holding
The Judgment Debtor should be permitted to participate in the execution proceedings from the stage at which they stood on the date of his appearance, rather than being wholly excluded.
¶ 3, 4The revision petition is allowed. The order dated 29.08.2019 is modified accordingly, and the Executing Court is directed to proceed in accordance with law.
¶ 4The observations are confined to the revision and do not prejudice either party's rights on the merits.
¶ 5All pending miscellaneous applications stand disposed of.
¶ 6The judgment does not expressly set aside the 27.05.2019 ex parte order.
Original Court PDF
BalwanvsJagdish Singh And Others
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
