01Facts
On 2 February 2017, an Insecticide Inspector took a sample of Metsulfuron Methyl 20% WG from a licensed dealer. The analyst found the active ingredient content to be 6.11%, against the stated 20%, and declared the sample misbranded.
¶ 3–4The product was manufactured in Indonesia and imported and marketed by Corteva’s predecessor; Aparajita Chatterjee was named as the company’s Technology Leader.
¶ 3–4Corteva received a notice and, in its reply dated 11 August 2017, stated that it intended to adduce evidence controverting the analyst’s report and reserved its right to seek re-analysis.
¶ 6, 16The authorities did not send the sample to the Central Insecticides Laboratory (CIL); the complaint was filed on 7 June 2018, shortly before expiry of the sample’s shelf life, and the petitioners were summoned after it had expired.
¶ 17Both petitioners sought quashing of the complaint, summoning order and consequential proceedings under Section 482 Cr.P.C.
¶ 1–202Issues
i.1. Whether the petitioners, who were not the persons from whom the sample was taken, were deprived of their statutory right to have it re-analysed by the CIL because of delay attributable to the authorities.
¶ 11, 16–17ii.2. Whether the complaint contained the necessary allegations to prosecute Chatterjee for the company’s alleged offence under Section 33 of the Insecticides Act, 1968.
¶ 22–2703Law Applied
Section 24(3) of the Insecticides Act makes an analyst’s report conclusive unless the person from whom the sample was taken gives notice within 28 days of an intention to controvert it; under Section 24(4), an accused may seek CIL analysis.
¶ 11–15Under State of Haryana v. Unique Farmaid (P) Ltd., (1999) 8 SCC 190, and Northern Mineral Ltd. v. Union of India, (2010) 7 SCC 726, the prosecution must act promptly to preserve the accused’s opportunity for re-analysis.
¶ 11–15M/s Northern Minerals Ltd. v. Rajasthan Government, (2016) 12 SCC 298, clarifies that the 28-day limit applies to the person from whom the sample was taken, not other accused, who also have a right to controvert the report.
¶ 11–15Indofil Industries Ltd. v. State of Punjab, (2017) 7 SCR 140, requires the prosecution to place the sample before the court in time for that right to be exercised.
¶ 11–15Under Section 33, company officers may be vicariously liable only where the complaint contains the requisite allegations that they were in charge of and responsible for the conduct of the company’s business, or that the offence occurred with their consent, connivance or neglect; designation alone is insufficient (State of NCT of Delhi v. Rajiv Khurana, (2010) 11 SCC 469; M/s Cheminova India Ltd. v. State of Punjab, (2021) 8 SCR 360).
¶ 22–25Provisions in the judgment · 12 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482
Insecticides Act, 1968 9 provisions
Section 3Section 9Section 17Section 22Section 24Section 29Section 30Section 31Section 33Drugs and Cosmetics Act, 1940 Section 25Section 34
04Reasoning
Corteva’s written reply expressly communicated its intention to controvert the analyst’s report while the sample still had about ten months of shelf life remaining. The authorities neither obtained CIL analysis nor filed the complaint in time for the petitioners to exercise that right; by the time they were required to appear, the sample’s shelf life had expired.
¶ 16–17The resulting loss of a material defence was attributable to official delay, so the prosecution could not rely on the report as conclusive against Corteva.
¶ 21As to Chatterjee, the complaint identified her by designation but did not allege that she was in charge of or responsible for the company’s business, or that the alleged offence involved her consent, connivance or neglect. The State’s later assertion that she handled day-to-day activities could not cure that omission.
¶ 26–2705Holding
The Court allowed both petitions and quashed the complaint, the summoning order dated 13 November 2018 and all consequential proceedings qua Corteva and Chatterjee only.
¶ 28It left the case against the remaining accused unaffected and directed the trial court to proceed against them in accordance with law.
¶ 29Original Court PDF
Corteva Agriscience India Pvt LtdvsState Of Haryana And Another
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
