01Facts
Ram Dhan was appointed as a driver by the Pepsu Road Transport Corporation in 1972, with his date of birth recorded as 3 February 1939.
¶ 1–7In 1994, relying on the date of issue of his driving licence, the Corporation changed his date of birth to 2 March 1936 and retrospectively retired him from 31 March 1994.
¶ 1–7The trial court declared the retirement order illegal and held that Ram Dhan was entitled to continue in service until 28 February 1997, with consequential benefits and interest; the first appellate court affirmed that decree.
¶ 1–7The Corporation appealed to the High Court.
¶ 1–7During the appeal, Ram Dhan’s legal representatives were brought on record.
p. 102Issues
i.Whether the Corporation could change Ram Dhan’s recorded date of birth at the fag end of his career on the basis of the date of issue of his driving licence.
¶ 8, 11ii.Whether the Corporation could retire Ram Dhan retrospectively from 31 March 1994 by changing his date of birth.
¶ 1–3, 11iii.Whether the concurrent judgments of the courts below warranted interference in the second appeal.
¶ 7, 1203Law Applied
The Court applied the principle that the date of issue of a driving licence is not conclusive proof of a person’s age, and that an employer cannot alter an employee’s accepted date of birth at the fag end of the employee’s career merely on that basis.
¶ 11Before changing the recorded date of birth, the employer must hold an enquiry to ascertain the correct date of birth.
¶ 11The Court also affirmed the principle that an employee cannot be retired with retrospective effect.
¶ 11The judgment identifies no specific statutory provision or precedent as the basis for these principles.
¶ 11Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 151
04Reasoning
The Corporation relied on the driving licence issued on 2 March 1956 to support its conclusion that Ram Dhan was born on 2 March 1936.
¶ 11The Court held that the licence’s issue date did not conclusively establish his age.
¶ 11The Corporation had accepted and acted on the recorded date of birth, 3 February 1939, from the time of his appointment, and did not allege that Ram Dhan had obtained his appointment through fraud or concealment.
¶ 11In those circumstances, the Corporation could not change his date of birth at the end of his career on the licence evidence alone; it was required to conduct an enquiry into his correct date of birth.
¶ 11The resulting retrospective retirement order was therefore unsustainable, and the concurrent findings of the courts below disclosed no ground for interference.
¶ 11–1205Holding
The High Court dismissed the Corporation’s second appeal and upheld the judgments and decrees of the courts below.
¶ 12–13It directed the Registrar to release to Ram Dhan’s legal representatives the amount deposited by the Corporation, together with the interest accrued on the fixed deposit.
¶ 15Pending applications were also disposed of.
¶ 16Original Court PDF
Pepsu Road Transport CorporationvsRam Dhan
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
