Punjab and Haryana High CourtEmployment and Labour LawAdministrative and Public Law

Haryana HC Orders General-Merit Consideration For PGT Candidate With 123 Marks Despite DESM Certificate Defect, As He Used No Relaxation

Sunilv.State Of Haryana And Others

Haryana HC Orders General-Merit Consideration For PGT Candidate With 123 Marks Despite DESM Certificate Defect, As He Used No Relaxation. Sunil vs State Of Haryana And Others. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

Whether a candidate who could not claim horizontal reservation under the ESM (Dependent) General Category because of a deficient certificate could nevertheless be considered in the Unreserved General Category on his own merit.

The court held

The petition was disposed of with a direction to respondent No. 2 to consider the petitioner for the Unreserved General Category post on his own merit, in light of Rohit Soni.

It also directed

If he fell within the zone of consideration, the respondents were to take appropriate steps to recommend his name within four weeks.

If selected and appointed, he would receive notional pay fixation and seniority at par with counterparts appointed in the same selection process, but actual salary only from the date he joined.

Pending miscellaneous applications were also disposed of.

01Facts

The petitioner applied for PGT Mathematics under the ESM (Dependent) General Category, which carried horizontal reservation, and participated in the selection process, including an interview on 7 November 2016.

¶ 1–1.2

His candidature under that category was not considered because he had not uploaded the certificate in the prescribed format.

¶ 1–1.2

By letter dated 15 November 2021, he was declared ineligible.

¶ 1–1.2

He sought consideration on his own merit in the Unreserved General Category.

¶ 1–1.2

The Court recorded that he had secured 123 marks, compared with 90 marks secured by the last selected General Category candidate, and that he had not obtained any relaxation in age, qualifying marks, or otherwise.

¶ 3–4

02Issues

i.Whether a candidate who could not claim horizontal reservation under the ESM (Dependent) General Category because of a deficient certificate could nevertheless be considered in the Unreserved General Category on his own merit.

¶ 4

ii.Whether the petitioner was entitled to consequential consideration for appointment and related service benefits if found within the zone of consideration.

¶ 5

03Law Applied

The Court exercised its jurisdiction under Article 226 of the Constitution of India.

¶ 1

Relying on Rohit Soni and Others v. State of Haryana and Another, CWP No. 35851 of 2025, decided on 5 August 2026, it applied the principle that a candidate who has not secured selection through relaxation and whose claim to a reserved category is not accepted may still be considered in the Unreserved General Category on the basis of merit.

¶ 2

The Court also noted that the DESM category was to be operated after preparation of the final merit list, if vacancies remained, and that the petitioner had not furnished false or incorrect information.

¶ 2, 4

04Reasoning

The petitioner’s failure to upload the prescribed certificate prevented consideration under the ESM (Dependent) General Category, but did not, on the facts recorded, bar consideration in the Unreserved General Category.

¶ 3–5

He had not relied on any relaxation to qualify, and there was no finding that he had supplied false or incorrect information.

¶ 3–5

Applying Rohit Soni, the Court therefore directed consideration on his own merit; his score of 123, above the last selected General Category candidate’s 90, supported his claim for consideration, subject to the applicable zone of consideration.

¶ 3–5

05Holding

The petition was disposed of with a direction to respondent No. 2 to consider the petitioner for the Unreserved General Category post on his own merit, in light of Rohit Soni.

¶ 5

If he fell within the zone of consideration, the respondents were to take appropriate steps to recommend his name within four weeks.

¶ 5

If selected and appointed, he would receive notional pay fixation and seniority at par with counterparts appointed in the same selection process, but actual salary only from the date he joined.

¶ 5

Pending miscellaneous applications were also disposed of.

¶ 7
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

SunilvsState Of Haryana And Others

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 12, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment