Punjab and Haryana High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceCriminal Law

P&H HC Sets Aside Summons To Two Men Named In Suicide FIR Over Alleged Loans, Calls Section 319 Power 'Extraordinary

Dilbaghv.State Of Haryana And Another

P&H HC Sets Aside Summons To Two Men Named In Suicide FIR Over Alleged Loans, Calls Section 319 Power 'Extraordinary. Dilbagh vs State Of Haryana And Another. Punjab and Haryana High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the trial court was justified in summoning the petitioners as additional accused under s. 319 CrPC when the investigation had exonerated them and the only material against them was the complainant's testimony.

The court held

The trial court's order summoning the petitioners under s. 319 CrPC was not sustainable, because the evidence did not meet the stricter threshold of strong and cogent material and the only basis was a statement that investigation had found unsupported.

It also directed

Both petitions, CRR-40-2023 and CRR-125-2023, are allowed, and the common order dated 01.12.2022 of the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani, is set aside insofar as it relates to the petitioners. The petitioners are discharged from the summoning order and are not required to face trial under s. 306 IPC on the basis of this order.

01Facts

The FIR was registered on the statement of Sudhish (PW-2), who alleged that his deceased brother, Pradeep, had lent ₹1,82,000 to Dilbagh and ₹1,10,000 to Naveen, that they had not repaid, and that Pradeep, depressed over these dues, had left home and later died by suicide.

¶ 2

The complainant also alleged that the petitioners and co-accused Bhim Singh had threatened the deceased.

¶ 2

The petitioners argued that the FIR disclosed no offence under s. 306 IPC against them.

¶ 3

During investigation, only a suicide note by Pradeep was recovered. The police found no evidence that Pradeep had lent money to the petitioners, noted that Pradeep's litigation was with Bhim Singh, and found that he had initiated no legal action or complaint against the petitioners.

¶ 3, 8

The petitioners were declared innocent, and the challan was presented only against Bhim Singh.

¶ 3, 8

During trial, PW-2 reiterated his allegations. The prosecution then sought summoning of the petitioners under s. 319 CrPC.

¶ 1

By order dated 01.12.2022, the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani, summoned the petitioners as additional accused to face trial under s. 306 IPC.

¶ 1, 3

The State and the complainant opposed the petitions, relying on the FIR, PW-2's testimony, and the suicide note, which allegedly named the petitioners.

¶ 4

02Issues

i.1. Whether the trial court was justified in summoning the petitioners as additional accused under s. 319 CrPC when the investigation had exonerated them and the only material against them was the complainant's testimony.

¶ 3, 7, 8

ii.2. Whether the degree of satisfaction required under s. 319 CrPC, namely more than a prima facie case supported by strong and cogent evidence, was met on the material available.

¶ 6, 8, 9

03Law Applied

Section 319 CrPC empowers a court to summon a non-accused person when evidence shows that the person has committed an offence triable with the accused.

¶ 6

Hardeep Singh v. State of Punjab (Constitution Bench), as applied in Brijendra Singh v. State of Rajasthan, holds that the s. 319 power is discretionary and extraordinary, to be used sparingly and not casually; that the satisfaction required is stricter than a prima facie case at the framing-of-charge stage, short of conviction-level proof; and that the material may include examination-in-chief but must be strong and cogent.

¶ 6, 8

Juhru v. Karim, (2023) 5 SCC 406, holds that s. 319 is not to be invoked routinely, that summoning at the threshold of trial should be discouraged, and that the power should not be used where there is no credible evidence.

¶ 9

Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 306

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 319Section 207Section 208

04Reasoning

The trial court did not apply the heightened standard required by Hardeep Singh and Juhru. Its only basis for summoning the petitioners was PW-2's statement, which repeated the FIR allegations that investigation had found to be unsupported: there was no evidence of any loan to the petitioners, no litigation or complaint against them, and no record connecting them to the threats.

¶ 8

Apart from PW-2's testimony, the record contained no material capable of supporting the petitioners' complicity. The trial court therefore acted mechanically, without assessing whether the evidence against the petitioners carried weight comparable to the evidence against the accused already facing trial.

¶ 8, 9

The judgment does not expressly address the suicide note relied on by the State, and does not explain why the note, if it names the petitioners, was insufficient to meet the s. 319 threshold.

¶ 4 · no discussion in paras. 7–9

05Holding

The trial court's order summoning the petitioners under s. 319 CrPC was not sustainable, because the evidence did not meet the stricter threshold of strong and cogent material and the only basis was a statement that investigation had found unsupported.

¶ 8, 9

Both petitions, CRR-40-2023 and CRR-125-2023, are allowed, and the common order dated 01.12.2022 of the Additional Sessions Judge, Bhiwani, is set aside insofar as it relates to the petitioners. The petitioners are discharged from the summoning order and are not required to face trial under s. 306 IPC on the basis of this order.

¶ 10
Punjab and Haryana High Court

Original Court PDF

DilbaghvsState Of Haryana And Another

Punjab and Haryana High Court · November 16, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment