01Facts
The petitioners challenged the GST treatment of corporate guarantees furnished by holding or group companies for loans taken by related entities.
¶ 1–4, 8 · pp. 9–10, 23–24They disputed whether such guarantees were taxable supplies under the Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 (CGST Act), and challenged Rule 28(2) of the CGST Rules, inserted by Notification No. 52/2023-Central Tax dated 26 October 2023 and amended retrospectively by Notification No. 12/2024 dated 10 July 2024.
¶ 1–4, 8 · pp. 9–10, 23–24The challenges also concerned Circulars No. 204/16/2023-GST and 225/19/2024-GST, valuation at 1% of the guarantee amount per annum, and the timing and retrospective reach of the levy.
¶ 1–4, 8 · pp. 9–10, 23–24The Court framed five common issues and left certain case-specific questions—including limitation, share pledges, and individual guarantee dates—to the competent authorities.
¶ 40–41 · p. 7602Issues
i.1. Whether a corporate guarantee furnished without consideration for a related person’s borrowings is a supply of services under Section 7(1)(c) read with Entry 2 of Schedule I, and who is its recipient.
¶ 40(a) · p. 76ii.2. Whether the guarantee is excluded from GST as an actionable claim or a security.
¶ 40(b) · p. 76iii.3. Whether Rule 28(2), including its deemed valuation and proviso, is intra vires the CGST Act and consistent with Articles 14, 19(1)(g), 246A and 265 of the Constitution.
¶ 40(c) · p. 76iv.4. When the supply occurs, and how the levy applies to guarantees executed before 1 July 2017, between 1 July 2017 and 25 October 2023, and after the retrospective amendment to Rule 28(2).
¶ 40(d) · p. 77v.5. Whether the impugned circulars exceed the power under Section 168 of the CGST Act or are otherwise unsustainable.
¶ 40(e) · p. 7703Law Applied
Sections 7(1)(c) and 7(2)(a) of the CGST Act, read with Entries 2 of Schedule I and 6 of Schedule III, govern supplies between related persons and the exclusion of actionable claims; Section 2(93)(c) identifies the recipient of a service supplied without consideration as the person to whom it is rendered.
Sections 9, 15 and 164, together with Rule 28(2), govern the levy, valuation of related-party supplies and delegated rule-making; Section 13(2) fixes the time of supply, while Section 34 permits credit notes in qualifying cases.
“Services” under Section 2(102) excludes goods, money and securities, and a supply between related persons may be taxable without consideration.
The Court applied the principles that a charging provision is strictly construed but its plain language is not read narrowly (Commissioner of Customs (Import), Mumbai v. Dilip Kumar & Co.); a statutory fiction is confined to its purpose (Bengal Immunity Co. Ltd. v. State of Bihar; Ashok Leyland Ltd. v. State of Tamil Nadu); and delegated legislation remains subject to judicial review notwithstanding GST Council recommendations (Union of India v. Mohit Minerals Pvt. Ltd.).
It also relied on the distinction between a supply and its valuation, the prospective operation of substantive fiscal provisions (CIT v. Vatika Township (P) Ltd.), and the rule that a circular cannot create or widen a levy (Commissioner of Central Excise, Bolpur v. Ratan Melting & Wire Industries).
Provisions in the judgment · 33 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Central Goods and Services Tax Act, 2017 22 provisions
Section 2Section 5Section 7Section 8Section 9Section 13Section 15Section 25Section 31Section 34Section 35Section 37Section 39Section 44Section 52Section 74Section 143Section 148Section 158Section 164Section 167Section 168Indian Contract Act, 1872 Section 126Section 127Section 128Section 140Section 145Section 172
Transfer of Property Act, 1882 Section 3
Insolvency and Bankruptcy Code, 2016. Section 3Section 5
Companies Act, 2013 Section 186
Special Economic Zones Act, 2005 Section 2
04Reasoning
The Court held that the guarantor supplies credit support by placing its creditworthiness behind the subsidiary’s borrowing and assuming its default risk; that service is rendered to the subsidiary, which obtains access to finance, and is supplied in the course or furtherance of the guarantor’s business.
¶ 49–72, 73–77 · pp. 82–96Entry 2 of Schedule I removes the need for consideration, while neither the lender’s contingent claim nor the guarantee’s collateral function makes the service itself an actionable claim or a statutory “security”.
¶ 49–72, 73–77 · pp. 82–96Rule 28(2) was within the rule-making power, but making 1% per annum an irrebuttable minimum could tax more than the service’s open-market value.
¶ 78–91 · pp. 96–102The Court therefore read the Rule down: the supplier may establish a lower open-market value with cogent, verifiable material, but the related parties’ agreed price or absence of consideration alone is insufficient; the full-input-tax-credit proviso was upheld.
¶ 78–91 · pp. 96–102The supply occurs on execution, and again on renewal, extension or enhancement—not through the guarantee’s continued subsistence.
¶ 92–112 · pp. 103–112It is not a continuous supply, and the tax is computed for the full tenure at the time of supply.
¶ 92–112 · pp. 103–112Pre-GST guarantees are not taxable unless renewed, extended or enhanced; guarantees executed from 1 July 2017 to 25 October 2023 are taxable but must be valued under the Rules then in force, without applying the 1% figure; Rule 28(2) applies to relevant events on or after 26 October 2023.
¶ 92–112 · pp. 103–112The retrospective amendment was upheld, and the circulars were sustained subject to those limits.
¶ 92–112 · pp. 103–11205Holding
The Court held that a related-party corporate guarantee is a taxable supply of services to the related person, even without consideration, and is not excluded as an actionable claim or security.
¶ 121–122 · p. 115Rule 28(2) was upheld but read down to permit proof of a lower open-market value; its full-input-tax-credit proviso and the retrospective operation of Notification No. 12/2024 were upheld.
¶ 123–126 · pp. 116–117The circulars were not ultra vires, but must conform to the judgment.
¶ 127 · p. 117The impugned notices, orders and demands were set aside to the extent inconsistent with the Court’s findings, with liability to be redetermined after hearing the petitioners; specified factual and individual issues were left to the competent authorities.
¶ 128–132 · pp. 117–119The petitions were partly allowed, subject to the stated directions.
Original Court PDF
Sterlite Power Transmission Limited & Ors.vsUnion Of India & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
