01Facts
The petitioners, Dr. Sonal Asthana, Dr. Kaisar Raja, Dr. Rajiv Lochan and Marlene Venkat, were engaged as retainers at BGS Global Hospital, Kengeri, including for liver transplantation work.
The hospital's CEO, Dr. Vijay Vemuri (respondent no. 2), complained that the petitioners stole and deleted patient data from the hospital computers, harming data integrity and the hospital's reputation.
¶ 3Crime No. 335/2015 was registered at Kengeri Police Station. During investigation, a 320 GB hard disc was seized under a mahazar dated 04.12.2015 and sent for FSL examination (PF No. 149/2018).
¶ 3 · ¶ 4The police filed a charge sheet, and the Magistrate took cognizance of offences under s. 408 IPC and ss. 43A and 66 IT Act in C.C. No. 26322/2018.
¶ 3The petitioners sought quashing under s. 482 CrPC on the grounds that: (a) they are retainers, not "clerks or servants"; (b) the seized CD's contents were not retrieved or linked to them, and no s. 65B certificate or s. 45A expert opinion was obtained; (c) the Hospital Information System is password-protected and no data could be exported or deleted; (d) the complaint is motivated by a desire to avoid paying about Rs. 70,00,000 in dues after their termination.
¶ 4The respondents contended that the petitioners' retainership is undisputed, that they maintained and operated the hospital's data, and that the matter requires trial.
¶ 5 · ¶ 6The petitioners further argued that no statement regarding stolen data was recorded.
¶ 702Issues
i.1. Whether the Trial Court erred in taking cognizance on the charge sheet, and whether the case warrants quashing under s. 482 CrPC.
¶ 9ii.2. Whether retainers engaged under a contract fall within s. 408 IPC, which applies to a "clerk or servant".
¶ 10iii.3. Whether the absence of a s. 65B Evidence Act certificate and s. 45A expert opinion bars proceedings under s. 66 IT Act at the initial stage.
¶ 11iv.4. Whether defences such as password protection, absence of data theft, lack of dishonest intent, and oblique motive can be decided at the quashing stage.
¶ 13 · ¶ 1403Law Applied
Section 408 IPC penalises criminal breach of trust by a clerk or servant, or a person employed as such, entrusted with property or dominion over property.
¶ 10Sections 43 and 66 IT Act make unauthorised access to or download of a computer system, done fraudulently or dishonestly, penal, as recognised in the Madras High Court order in O.A. No. 3/2023.
¶ 12 · ¶ 15Following the Supreme Court in M.R. Hiremath v. State by Karnataka Lokayukta, a s. 65B certificate is required only for admissibility and may be produced at trial, not at the cognizance stage.
¶ 11Wolfgang Prock-Schauer v. State of Maharashtra (2024 SCC OnLine Bom 3482) discusses the ingredients of s. 66 IT Act and the dishonesty and fraud elements under ss. 24–25 IPC, but these are matters for trial.
¶ 15Section 482 CrPC is not a forum for adjudicating disputed defences, which must be tested at trial.
¶ 13 · ¶ 14Provisions in the judgment · 7 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 482
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 24Section 25Section 408
Information Technology Act, 2000 Section 2Section 43Section 66
04Reasoning
On s. 408 IPC, the court found it undisputed that the petitioners were retainers working as doctors, that they were part of the liver transplantation team, and that the data was stored on hospital systems over which they had dominion. Such dominion, combined with the alleged misuse, could amount to criminal breach of trust, so the "not a clerk or servant" objection could not be accepted at this stage.
¶ 10On the evidentiary objections, the s. 65B certificate and expert opinion are admissibility requirements that may be cured at trial, and their absence does not defeat cognizance.
¶ 11On the password-protection argument, the petitioners' access to the system was undisputed, and the specific allegation of data theft and deletion raised a question of fact for trial.
¶ 13The court treated the allegations of oblique motive, the seizure and examination of the hard disc, and whether the petitioners had control over the data as trial questions.
¶ 14Because the material prima facie disclosed the commission of an offence, and the contractual retainership was undisputed, the court declined to interfere under s. 482 CrPC.
¶ 14 · ¶ 1505Holding
The court answered Point No. 1 in the negative, holding that the Trial Court did not err in taking cognizance and that the case does not warrant quashing under s. 482 CrPC.
¶ 10 · ¶ 11 · ¶ 12 · ¶ 13 · ¶ 14 · ¶ 15The petition is dismissed, and C.C. No. 26322/2018 will proceed to trial on the charges under s. 408 IPC and ss. 43A and 66 IT Act.
¶ 16Original Court PDF
DR SONAL ASTHANAvsSTATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
