01Facts
Fourteen applicants, Group-C Ambulance Drivers under the Ministry of Health & Family Welfare, sought promotion to Driver Grade-I / Special Grade.
¶ 1The applicants had earlier filed OA No. 2542/2019, which was disposed of on 27.09.2019.
¶ 1By order dated 17.12.2019, the respondents rejected the representation of applicant Amar Chand. The order stated that the Recruitment Rules notified on 22.12.1973 provided no promotion avenue; that DoPT OM dated 30.11.1993 delegated power to frame RRs for Group C & D posts; that amended RRs were under consideration; and that the Ministry had not agreed to ad hoc promotion of Driver Grade-I, Grade-II or Special Grade.
¶ 1The applicants sought quashing of the order dated 17.12.2019, a direction to convene a DPC, and consideration of vacancies under the existing promotion scheme with consequential benefits.
¶ 2During pendency, promotion orders dated 06.05.2023 and 19.08.2026 were issued in respect of seven applicants.
¶ 3Ad hoc promotions from Grade-II to Grade-I had earlier been granted on 21.09.2017 pending finalisation of new RRs.
¶ 4The respondents stated that, with new RRs in place, the seven applicants' cases were considered in their due turn.
¶ 5 · ¶ 7The applicants' counsel sought promotion for those seven applicants with effect from 2012, when they became eligible.
¶ 602Issues
i.1. Whether the OA has become infructuous in view of the subsequent promotion orders issued to seven of the fourteen applicants.
¶ 5 · ¶ 8ii.2. Whether the seven promoted applicants are entitled to promotion with effect from the year 2012 or their due date, and whether that claim can be adjudicated in the present OA.
¶ 6 · ¶ 903Law Applied
DoPT OM No. 22036/1/92-Estt.(D) dated 30.11.1993, clauses 2.7 and 4, which delegate to Ministries/Departments the power to frame RRs for Group C & D posts in accordance with prescribed eligibility guidelines.
¶ 1The Recruitment Rules notified on 22.12.1973, which provided no promotion avenue.
¶ 1A matter is disposed of as infructuous where subsequent developments substantially alter the circumstances in which the OA was instituted, while preserving the applicants' liberty to pursue surviving grievances before the appropriate forum.
¶ 8 · ¶ 9No judicial precedent is identified in the order; applicants' reference to an unnamed "S.C. decision" in relief (b) is not discussed.
¶ 2(b)04Reasoning
The promotion orders of 06.05.2023 and 19.08.2026, issued after finalisation of new RRs, showed that the promotion process had moved forward and that seven of the fourteen applicants had been promoted.
¶ 5 · ¶ 8Because these developments substantially changed the circumstances in which the OA was filed, the Tribunal found it unnecessary to keep the petition pending.
¶ 8The Tribunal did not adjudicate the merits of the 17.12.2019 order or the claim for DPC consideration, as the grievances had been substantially addressed.
¶ 4 · ¶ 5The claim for promotion from 2012 was treated as a surviving grievance not decided in this proceeding, which is why it was left open for agitation before the appropriate forum. The new RRs were not recorded, and the order contains no finding on the validity or effective date of the seven promotions.
¶ 5 · ¶ 6 · ¶ 905Holding
The Tribunal held that the OA stands rendered infructuous due to subsequent developments.
¶ 9The Tribunal disposed of the OA on that basis, granted the applicants liberty to agitate their surviving grievances, including the claim for promotion from the due date, before the appropriate forum in accordance with law, disposed of any pending MA, and made no order as to costs.
¶ 9No relief on the merits, including quashing of the 17.12.2019 order or direction to convene a DPC, was granted.
¶ 8 · ¶ 9Original Court PDF
Manohar LalvsM/o Health And Family Welfare
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Seven of 14 Ambulance Drivers Get Promoted Mid-Case; CAT Closes Petition, Leaves Back-Dated Claims Open. Manohar Lal vs M/o Health And Family Welfare. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/seven-of-14-ambulance-drivers-get-promoted-mid-case-cat-closes-petition-leaves-back-dated-61f6fb19184942b185d5f9afe314ce36.webp)