01Facts
The plaintiffs, the widow and six daughters of late Chikkegowda, sued for partition and separate possession of the suit properties, claiming a 6/7th share as ancestral property.
¶ 2The defendants, the widows of Chikkegowda's son Ramaswamy, who died on 03.05.2006 without issue, are his only legal representatives.
¶ 2The defendants' written statement pleaded a prior partition between Chikkegowda and Ramaswamy, and that Ramaswamy had borne the marriage expenses of the plaintiffs, but these contentions were not substantiated by evidence.
¶ 3 · ¶ 5, quoting R.A. judgment paras 11–12The trial court decreed the suit, granting the plaintiffs a 6/7th share.
¶ 4On appeal (R.A. No. 69/2015), the first appellate court held that the 2005 amendment to Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 was prospective and did not apply because Chikkegowda died before 2005. It applied the notional partition under the pre-2005 proviso to Section 6 and fixed each plaintiff's share at 1/16th.
¶ 5, quoting R.A. judgment paras 13–14During the pendency of the second appeal, appellant No. 1 (Puttamma) died and her legal representatives (appellants 2–7) were brought on record.
¶ 8The High Court admitted the appeal on the substantial question of law quoted at paragraph 1.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether the first appellate court's judgment dated 05.07.2016 in R.A. No. 69/2015, which applied Prakash v. Phulavati and limited the plaintiffs to notional shares, is in conformity with Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma (2020) 9 SCC 1.
¶ 1 · ¶ 6ii.2. Whether the widow and daughters of a Mitakshara coparcener who died before 09.09.2005 are entitled to equal coparcenary shares with the son under substituted Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956.
¶ 6–703Law Applied
Substituted Section 6 of the Hindu Succession Act, 1956 (as amended in 2005) makes daughters coparceners by birth with the same rights and liabilities as sons.
¶ 6, quoting Vineeta Sharma · ¶ 137.1Under Vineeta Sharma v. Rakesh Sharma (2020) 9 SCC 1, the right accrues irrespective of whether the father-coparcener was alive on 09.09.2005; savings apply only to dispositions, alienations, partitions, or testamentary dispositions effected before 20.12.2004.
¶ 6, quoting paras. 137.2–137.3The statutory notional partition in the original proviso to Section 6 only fixes a deceased coparcener's share and does not effect actual partition.
¶ 6, quoting para. 137.4A plea of oral partition is not a recognised mode of partition unless supported by public documents or a registered deed or decree.
¶ 6, quoting para. 137.5Prakash v. Phulavati, on which the first appellate court relied, was overruled on this point by Vineeta Sharma.
¶ 6, quoting para. 139Section 10, Rule 1 of the Hindu Succession Act provides for equal distribution among class I heirs.
¶ 7Provisions in the judgment · 4 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Code of Civil Procedure, 1908 Section 100
Registration Act, 1908 Section 17
Hindu Succession Act, 1956 Section 6Section 10
04Reasoning
The first appellate court applied Prakash v. Phulavati and restricted the plaintiffs to notional shares because Chikkegowda died before the 2005 amendment.
¶ 5That reasoning was displaced when Vineeta Sharma overruled Prakash. The plaintiffs' rights as coparceners arise by birth, and the death date of the father is irrelevant.
¶ 6–7The plaintiffs were therefore held entitled to equal shares with Ramaswamy, rather than the 1/16th shares granted below.
¶ 7Because Puttamma died during the appeal, her undivided share passed to appellants 2–7.
¶ 8The defendants' prior-partition and marriage-expense contentions were rejected for want of cogent evidence, and no registered instrument of release existed.
¶ 5, quoting R.A. judgment paras 11–12The first appellate court's notional-partition approach could not stand after Vineeta Sharma, and the first appellate judgment was set aside and the trial court's decree modified.
¶ 8–905Holding
The substantial question is answered in the negative. The first appellate judgment dated 05.07.2016 is not in conformity with Vineeta Sharma and is set aside.
¶ 8–9The trial court's decree dated 20.07.2015 in O.S. No. 478/2010 is modified. The shares declared are: appellants 2–7 (Dyavamma, Shanthamma, Bhagyamma, Anithamma, Shivamma, Yogamma) 1/7 each; respondent No. 1 (Shyla) 1/14; and respondent No. 2 (Giddamma) 1/14. The Office is directed to draw the decree accordingly.
¶ 8–9 · ¶ 9Original Court PDF
SMT. PUTTAMMAvsSHYLA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
