01Facts
The appellant, a CRPF constable, overstayed sanctioned leave by 99 days and did not respond to two directions to report for duty.
pp. 2–5 · ¶ 2.1–3He attributed his absence to infective hepatitis and produced medical and related documents.
pp. 2–5 · ¶ 2.1–3A departmental enquiry found unauthorised absence and disobedience proved, disbelieved the documents, and resulted in his removal from service.
pp. 2–5 · ¶ 2.1–3The learned Single Judge quashed the disciplinary, appellate and revisional orders, but the Division Bench restored the removal.
pp. 2–5 · ¶ 2.1–3The appellant appealed to the Supreme Court.
pp. 2–5 · ¶ 2.1–302Issues
i.1. Whether the Division Bench was justified in setting aside the Single Judge’s order and restoring the removal penalty, including by upholding the rejection of the appellant’s medical evidence
p. 6 · ¶ 7 · pp. 8–9 · ¶ 10–12ii.2. Whether removal from service was proportionate to the appellant’s misconduct in the circumstances of the case
pp. 9–10 · ¶ 1303Law Applied
Under State of Andhra Pradesh v. S. Sree Rama Rao, judicial review in disciplinary matters permits interference where proceedings violate natural justice or statutory rules, rely on extraneous or irrelevant considerations, or produce a conclusion so arbitrary that no reasonable person could reach it; where the enquiry is otherwise proper and supported by legal evidence, the adequacy or reliability of evidence is ordinarily for the departmental authorities.
pp. 6–7 · ¶ 8Under B.C. Chaturvedi v. Union of India, disciplinary authorities determine facts and punishment, while a reviewing court ordinarily cannot substitute its own penalty; it may intervene where the punishment shocks the conscience, including by directing reconsideration or, in exceptional cases, imposing an appropriate penalty.
p. 7 · ¶ 9The Court also applied the principle that unauthorised absence is not necessarily wilful absence, and that the explanation and supporting circumstances are relevant to assessing the misconduct.
p. 8 · ¶ 1004Reasoning
The Enquiry Officer inferred fabrication principally from similarities in the writing or ink and the absence of an inpatient or outpatient number, without verification from the treating doctor, medical establishment or pharmacy.
pp. 8–9 · ¶ 11–12Those circumstances could warrant clarification but did not, without more, reasonably establish that treatment had not occurred or that the documents were forged; the Single Judge therefore correctly found the rejection to rest on conjecture.
pp. 8–9 · ¶ 11–12Although the appellant’s prolonged absence, failure to communicate, prior overstays and service in a disciplined force were relevant, the Court held that removal was grossly disproportionate in the particular circumstances.
pp. 9–10 · ¶ 1305Holding
The Supreme Court allowed the appeal, set aside the Division Bench’s judgment and restored the Single Judge’s order.
p. 10 · ¶ 14It directed the respondents to reinstate the appellant immediately, pay 50% of his back wages for the period from removal to reinstatement, and provide all other consequential benefits.
p. 10 · ¶ 14Original Court PDF
Mithilesh Kumar PathakvsUnion Of India
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
