01Facts
The appellant was convicted in Sessions Trial No. 13/7 of 2020 arising from FIR No. 25/2020 under Sections 354A, 354D, 376 and 506 IPC and Section 4(2) of the POCSO Act. He was sentenced to 20 years’ rigorous imprisonment under Section 4(2) POCSO, along with additional sentences under the IPC.
¶ 2During the pending criminal appeal, the State sought permission under Section 432 BNSS, corresponding to Section 391 CrPC, to produce the child victim’s Matriculation Certificate and relevant school records, and to re-examine the victim and examine the concerned school record-keeper/Principal.
¶ 1During trial, the prosecution had already sought to establish the victim’s date of birth as 9 August 2004 through a birth certificate proved by the Panchayat Secretary and a Pariwar Register proved by the Investigating Officer.
¶ 4The State submitted that the Matriculation Certificate and school record had not been collected or produced due to inadvertence or the Investigating Officer’s ignorance of the preferential method of age determination under Section 94 of the Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015.
¶ 5–9The appellant opposed the application, contending that the prosecution was attempting to fill a lacuna at the appellate stage and that the application was belated and prejudicial.
¶ 13–1802Issues
i.Whether the Appellate Court should permit the State to adduce additional evidence under Section 432 BNSS, corresponding to Section 391 CrPC, to prove the victim’s age through her Matriculation Certificate and school records?
¶ 19–20, 26–32ii.Whether permitting the additional evidence would amount to filling a lacuna, conducting a retrial, or causing prejudice to the appellant?
¶ 15–18, 22–28iii.Whether the victim should be re-examined and the concerned school official examined for proving the relevant age records?
¶ 32–3303Law Applied
Section 432 BNSS, corresponding to Section 391 CrPC, empowers an Appellate Court to take additional evidence or direct such evidence to be taken where it is necessary for a just decision, provided reasons are recorded and the accused is afforded an opportunity to be present and cross-examine the witnesses.
¶ 20Section 348 BNSS, corresponding to Section 311 CrPC, permits the Court at any stage to summon, examine, recall or re-examine a person whose evidence appears essential to the just decision of the case.
¶ 20Section 94 of the Juvenile Justice Act, 2015 prescribes the preferential evidentiary method for determining the age of a child, including reliance on school or Matriculation records.
¶ 5, 28The Court relied on Natasha Singh v. CBI, Varsha Garg v. State of Madhya Pradesh, Swapan Kumar Chatterjee v. CBI, Rajeshwar Prasad Misra v. State of West Bengal, Rambhau v. State of Maharashtra, Ashok Tshering Bhutia v. State of Sikkim and V.N. Patil v. K. Niranjan Kumar, holding that additional evidence may be permitted where essential to prevent failure of justice, but not as a disguise for retrial, to change the nature of the case, or merely to fill an incurable lacuna; the power must be exercised sparingly, judiciously and without prejudice to the accused.
¶ 21–25Provisions in the judgment · 9 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 432Section 348
Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 391Section 311Section 173
Indian Penal Code, 1860 Section 376Section 506
Protection of Children from Sexual Offences Act, 2012 Section 4
Juvenile Justice (Care and Protection of Children) Act, 2015. Section 94
04Reasoning
The Court held that the proposed evidence concerned an issue already forming part of the prosecution case—namely, that the victim was born on 9 August 2004—and did not introduce any new factual or legal case against the appellant.
¶ 26Although the prosecution had already produced the birth certificate and Pariwar Register, the Court considered that those documents might not be sufficient under the preferential requirements of Section 94 of the Juvenile Justice Act, particularly when a Matriculation Certificate or school record was available.
¶ 28The failure to collect and produce the school record was treated as an irregularity arising from investigative negligence or ignorance, rather than an incurable lacuna.
¶ 26–30Since the additional evidence was limited to proving the victim’s age, would assist the Court in reaching a just decision, and could be tested through cross-examination and rebuttal evidence, it would neither constitute a retrial nor cause prejudice to the appellant.
¶ 26–30The Court therefore found it essential to re-examine the victim and examine the competent school official with the relevant records.
¶ 32–3305Holding
The application was allowed.
¶ 32–33The State was permitted to re-examine PW-1, the child victim, and to examine the record-keeper, Office Superintendent, Principal or other competent official of the concerned school, along with the Matriculation Certificate and complete relevant school record, for the limited purpose of proving the victim’s date of birth in accordance with law.
¶ 32–33The appellant was preserved the right to remain present and cross-examine the witnesses on the additional evidence.
¶ 32–33The Court also directed the Director General of Police, Himachal Pradesh, to circulate guidelines requiring Investigating Officers to collect and prove all relevant age documents in cases involving child victims or children in conflict with law.
¶ 34–38Original Court PDF
KULWINDER SINGHvsSTATE OF HP
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
