Tripura High CourtCriminal Procedure and EvidenceFamily Law

Transfer of wife's maintenance case refused where husband shows no cogent grounds and transfer would burden her

Shri Samarjit Sarkarv.Smt. Rakhi Das (Sarkar)

Transfer of wife's maintenance case refused where husband shows no cogent grounds and transfer would burden her. Shri Samarjit Sarkar vs Smt. Rakhi Das (Sarkar). Tripura High Court. LawLens
The LawLens card for this judgmentXLinkedInWhatsApp

In brief

The question

1. Whether the High Court should transfer the pending maintenance proceedings from the SDJM, Longtharai Valley, to the Family Court at Agartala under Section 407 Cr.P.C. (Section 447 BNSS) on the petitioner's showing of inconvenience and prejudice.

The court held

The petitioner failed to establish satisfactory grounds for transfer under Section 407 Cr.P.C. (Section 447 BNSS), and the transfer petition was found to be without merit. The Court held that transfer would cause undue inconvenience to the respondent-wife and that the petitioner had adduced no cogent evidence.

It also directed

The petition is rejected/dismissed, the parties are to bear their own costs, and a copy of the order is to be sent to the SDJM, Longtharai Valley, for information. Pending applications stand disposed of. The maintenance proceedings therefore remain before the SDJM, Longtharai Valley.

01Facts

The petitioner-husband, a permanent resident of Udaipur, Gomati District, and a teacher in the same sub-division, sought transfer of Crl.Misc.(Main) No. 05 of 2026 and Crl.Misc.(Int.) No. 03 of 2026 from the Court of the SDJM, Longtharai Valley, Dhalai, to the Family Court, West District, Agartala.

¶ 01

The parties are married, and a daughter studying MBBS at TMC, Agartala, was born of the marriage.

¶ 03

The petitioner alleged that the respondent-wife left the matrimonial home without cogent grounds, took shelter at her sister's house in Agartala, and then filed the maintenance case from her paternal home at Manu, Dhalai.

¶ 03

He contended that he was caring for his ailing parents at Udaipur and that the proceedings would seriously prejudice him.

¶ 03

The respondent-wife alleged mental and physical harassment and said she was compelled to leave the matrimonial home and stay at her parents' house.

¶ 04

She stated she has no income, suffers from ailments supported by prescriptions, and cannot afford travel to Agartala or engage counsel there.

¶ 04

The Court found no evidence that the wife has independent income or that she stays at her sister's house in Agartala.

¶ 05

02Issues

i.1. Whether the High Court should transfer the pending maintenance proceedings from the SDJM, Longtharai Valley, to the Family Court at Agartala under Section 407 Cr.P.C. (Section 447 BNSS) on the petitioner's showing of inconvenience and prejudice.

¶ 03 · ¶ 05

ii.2. Whether the petitioner placed cogent material on record to justify transfer, given the respondent-wife's claimed hardship and lack of income.

¶ 04 · ¶ 05

03Law Applied

The Court's power arises under Section 407 Cr.P.C., corresponding to Section 447 BNSS, which governs transfer of criminal cases between courts.

¶ 01

The general principle that a transfer petitioner must establish satisfactory grounds, supported by cogent material, that justify moving the case, and that transfer will not be allowed where it would cause undue hardship to the other party.

¶ 05

The judgment cites no precedent. The reasoning rests on the statutory provision and the Court's assessment of the parties' evidence and circumstances.

Provisions in the judgment · 2 · Linked ones open on LawLens

Code of Criminal Procedure, 1973 Section 407

Bharatiya Nagarik Suraksha Sanhita, 2023 Section 447

04Reasoning

The Court weighed the petitioner's claims of inconvenience against the respondent-wife's evident hardship. It accepted that the wife is the legally married spouse and that she left the matrimonial home after family discord, sheltering at her parents' house in Manu, where she had filed for maintenance because the husband provided no support.

¶ 05

The petitioner produced no evidence of the wife's independent income and none showing she lives at her sister's house in Agartala.

¶ 05

On that record, the Court held that transferring the case to Agartala would be inconvenient for the wife, who would bear travel costs and could not easily engage counsel there.

¶ 04 · ¶ 05

The petitioner's assertions about his parents' ill health and his own difficulties were not supported by cogent material, so the claimed prejudice did not outweigh the hardship to the wife.

¶ 03 · ¶ 05

The judgment does not expressly articulate a "interests of justice" test; its reasoning is fact-driven and turns on the absence of evidence from the petitioner.

¶ 05

05Holding

The petitioner failed to establish satisfactory grounds for transfer under Section 407 Cr.P.C. (Section 447 BNSS), and the transfer petition was found to be without merit. The Court held that transfer would cause undue inconvenience to the respondent-wife and that the petitioner had adduced no cogent evidence.

¶ 05

The petition is rejected/dismissed, the parties are to bear their own costs, and a copy of the order is to be sent to the SDJM, Longtharai Valley, for information. Pending applications stand disposed of. The maintenance proceedings therefore remain before the SDJM, Longtharai Valley.

¶ 06
Tripura High Court

Original Court PDF

Shri Samarjit SarkarvsSmt. Rakhi Das (Sarkar)

Tripura High Court · November 20, 2026

Click to open original judgment

Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in

Click to open original judgment