01Facts
The late Shri Vijai Krishna, Ex-Joint Director, Ministry of Defence, married Smt. Binu Ratan on 14.02.1990. She left the matrimonial home in 1991.
¶ 2The deceased then began cohabiting with Applicant No. 1, Smt. Shakuntala Devi, as husband and wife from 1995. Applicant No. 2, their daughter, was born on 28.08.1996.
¶ 2, 15The deceased retired on voluntary grounds after suffering paralysis.
¶ 3In his pension papers dated 10.01.2019, he named Applicant No. 1 as his wife.
¶ 3, 11Service records showed nominations in favour of Smt. Binu Ratan (1992) and the deceased's sister and brother (1994). These were never modified.
¶ 7, 10The Respondents treated the case as "Two Wives or Disputed Case" and issued the Pension Payment Order without including any dependants.
¶ 11Applicant No. 1 submitted a Notary-attested affidavit and a divorce decree dated 15.02.2020. The Respondents sought proof of marriage, such as a registration certificate or Executive Magistrate-attested affidavit, and rejected the claim as she was not the legally wedded wife.
¶ 5, 12The deceased died on 15.01.2022.
¶ 4The claim was rejected on 15.02.2023.
¶ 5The Respondents contended that the first marriage subsisted until the decree of 15.02.2020, so the second marriage was void.
¶ 10, 1302Issues
i.1. Whether Applicant No. 1 is entitled to family pension as the legally wedded spouse of the deceased, where the deceased's first marriage was dissolved only on 15.02.2020 and the claimed second relationship began in 1995.
¶ 13, 27ii.2. Whether a presumption of valid marriage arises from long-standing cohabitation under Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, and whether that presumption was rebutted by the Respondents.
¶ 19, 23, 27, 30iii.3. Whether the claim of Applicant No. 2 (daughter) must be examined independently of the marital status of Applicant No. 1.
¶ 20, 3003Law Applied
The Tribunal noted Rule 50(6) of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 2021, which the Respondents relied on to define "widow/widower" as a spouse legally wedded to the deceased.
¶ 13The Tribunal noted GOI Decision No. 13 under Rule 54 of the CCS (Pension) Rules, 1972, which the Respondents cited to deny family pension to a second wife where the second marriage was contracted during the subsistence of the first.
¶ 13The Tribunal relied on Section 114 of the Indian Evidence Act, 1872, under which long cohabitation as husband and wife raises a rebuttable presumption of valid marriage.
¶ 19, 22The Tribunal applied Smt. Shiramabai v. Captain, Record Officer, Sena Corps Abhilekh, Gaya (Civil Appeal No. 5262 of 2023, 2023 INSC 744), which holds that a strong presumption of wedlock arises from long cohabitation, that the presumption is rebuttable only by unimpeachable evidence, and that the burden on the party challenging it is heavy.
¶ 21–24Per Shiramabai, a pensionary entitlement may rest on this presumption even where an earlier marriage was dissolved late, as long as the deceased continued to cohabit and acknowledged the relationship.
¶ 24Provisions in the judgment · 1
Indian Evidence Act, 1872 Section 114
04Reasoning
The Tribunal did not decide the statutory validity of the second marriage. It instead held that the Respondents rejected the claim solely on the disputed marital status without examining the full record.
¶ 26, 29Applying Shiramabai, the Tribunal considered that the relationship lasted from 1995 until the deceased's death in 2022, with a child born from it.
¶ 25, 28It also considered the deceased's own declaration of Applicant No. 1 as his wife in the 2019 pension papers.
¶ 26, 29The Tribunal found that the dissolution decree of 15.02.2020 was not challenged, and that cohabitation continued after it.
¶ 28It treated the nomination lapses and the non-disclosure during service as matters that do not by themselves defeat the presumption.
¶ 16, 18The Tribunal found that the Respondents had not placed "unimpeachable evidence" to rebut the presumption. The Tribunal did not separately analyse Rule 50(6) or GOI Decision No. 13 in its reasoning.
¶ 30Applicant No. 2's claim was left to be decided under the rules for eligible children.
¶ 20, 3005Holding
The Tribunal held that Applicant No. 1 had made out a case, that the Respondents failed to rebut the presumption of marriage arising from long cohabitation, and that the rejection dated 15.02.2023 could not be sustained.
¶ 30The OA was allowed. The impugned rejection was set aside. The Respondents were directed to reconsider and process Applicant No. 1's family pension claim as the eligible spouse, and to release admissible arrears and benefits within eight weeks of receiving a certified copy of the order. Applicant No. 2's claim was to be examined independently under the rules for eligible children. No order as to costs.
¶ 30, 31Original Court PDF
SHAKUNTALA DEVIvsDEFENCE
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
![Tribunal Reopens Family Pension Claim Of Woman Who Lived As Defence Officer's Wife For Years, Citing Long Cohabitation. SHAKUNTALA DEVI vs DEFENCE. CAT - ['Delhi']. LawLens](/stories/thumbnails/tribunal-reopens-family-pension-claim-of-woman-who-lived-as-defence-officer-s-wife-for-yea-3d3b5c1d3e10493799d52cdb60fc0820.webp)