01Facts
The petitioner, a Chief Manager posted at Tripura Gramin Bank’s Agartala Branch, was transferred to Poangbari Branch on 9 September 2026. The transfer order attributed the decision to his alleged indifferent attitude and poor customer service toward a senior State Government official, and directed him to join immediately without joining time.
¶ 3The petitioner said that the interaction concerned a request for a personalized cheque book and KYC documents for the customer’s adult son; he maintained that he had explained the applicable requirements and had acted courteously. The Bank later issued a show-cause notice alleging poor customer service, which the petitioner denied.
¶ 4–5He challenged the transfer under Article 226. The Bank relied on its transfer power under Regulation 74 of the Tripura Gramin Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations, 2010, and objected that the petitioner had not pursued the appeal said to be available under Regulation 49.
¶ 6, 1002Issues
i.1. Whether the transfer order was, in substance, punitive and liable to be quashed for being made without prior notice or enquiry.
¶ 13–15ii.2. Whether the availability of an alternative appeal remedy barred the petitioner from obtaining relief under Article 226.
¶ 1603Law Applied
A transfer is ordinarily an administrative incident of service, but it may be interfered with where, among other grounds, it is mala fide or is imposed in lieu of punishment; a transfer based on an irrelevant ground and carrying punitive consequences may be invalid (Somesh Tiwari v. Union of India, (2009) 2 SCC 592, quoted at para. 8 and applied at para. 15).
¶ 8, 15The Court treated the requirement of natural justice as applicable where the transfer order itself made adverse findings about the employee’s conduct without first giving him an opportunity to respond or conducting an enquiry.
¶ 13The Bank relied on its transfer power under Regulation 74 and the appeal mechanism under Regulation 49 of the 2010 Regulations.
¶ 10The availability of an alternative remedy is a rule of prudence, not an absolute bar to Article 226 jurisdiction; the Court may entertain a writ petition where the circumstances justify it, including where the matter has been heard and adjudicated on the merits.
¶ 16Provisions in the judgment · 1
Tripura Gramin Bank (Officers and Employees) Service Regulations, 2010 Section 74
04Reasoning
The Court found that the transfer order expressly attributed the petitioner’s relocation to alleged deficiencies in courtesy, promptness and professionalism, giving it punitive content.
¶ 3, 13The order was made without prior notice or enquiry, and neither it nor the subsequent show-cause notice specified what conduct constituted the alleged misbehaviour or poor service.
¶ 13–14The contemporaneous visit report also recorded that the customer’s requests could not be met immediately because of banking and KYC requirements, and did not identify specific misconduct by the petitioner.
¶ 13Applying Somesh Tiwari, the Court concluded that the transfer was not shown to rest on a sufficient administrative ground and operated as punishment without the required procedural fairness.
¶ 15It rejected the alternative-remedy objection, holding that it did not preclude deciding the petition on its merits in the circumstances.
¶ 1605Holding
The Court held that the transfer order was illegal and arbitrary, with punitive contents and a gross violation of natural justice, and allowed the writ petition.
¶ 15, 17It quashed the transfer order dated 9 September 2026 and directed the Bank to permit the petitioner to rejoin the Agartala Branch within seven days. The Bank was also directed to regularize his absence with wages for the relevant period upon submission of a leave application in due course.
¶ 17Original Court PDF
Dr. Pranajit PaulvsTripura Gramin Bank and 2 Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
