01Facts
The petitioner, a typist with Pattan Panchayat, Yallapur, sought regularisation of her service in Group-C posts.
p. 2She relied on Annexure-C (30.11.2006), a recommendation by the 3rd respondent listing Grade-C employees for regularisation, in which she is at Serial No. 5, and on Annexure-D (18.11.2008).
p. 2 · pp. 3–4Her representation dated 17.12.2015 (Annexure-J) was also pending.
p. 2Counsel relied on W.P. No. 107918 of 2023, in which the Court on 26.11.2025 directed regularisation of a co-listed employee (Serial No. 1) from the date of completion of 10 years' service.
pp. 3–4The State opposed, contending the petitioner was not covered by the Umadevi framework.
p. 6The reference text does not set out the petitioner's own appointment date, the nature of her engagement, or her retirement date with precision beyond the 10-year reckoning date of 19.07.2006 stated in the operative order.
pp. 69–70The Court noted that the earlier co-listed petitioner had been engaged continuously and that, in parallel matters against other municipal bodies, the State's reliance on Umadevi had been rejected.
pp. 6–8 · pp. 20–26Respondents' endorsements rejecting such claims were quashed in those matters.
pp. 21–26 · pp. 67–6802Issues
i.1. Whether a long-serving, co-listed employee of a Panchayat engaged without regular sanction, who has since retired, is entitled to regularisation from the date of completing 10 years' service, notwithstanding Umadevi.
pp. 3–4 · pp. 9–10 · pp. 69–70ii.2. Whether the Court must separately direct consideration of the pending representation dated 17.12.2015 (Annexure-J).
p. 2 · pp. 69–70 (no separate direction recorded)03Law Applied
The Court relied primarily on Secretary, State of Karnataka v. Umadevi (3), (2006) 4 SCC 1, which bars regularisation of illegal or back-door appointments but permits one-time regularisation of irregular appointments of employees with 10+ years' continuous service in sanctioned posts.
pp. 9–10 · pp. 40–41The Court applied the three conditions from State of Karnataka v. M.L. Kesari (2010) 9 SCC 247: 10 years' service in a duly sanctioned post without interim-order protection, appointment not illegal, and possession of minimum qualifications.
pp. 40–41The Court relied on Narendra Kumar Tiwari v. State of Jharkhand (2018) 8 SCC 238, holding that employees with 10 years' service should be regularised absent valid objection.
pp. 31–32The Court relied on Sheo Narain Nagar v. State of U.P. (2018) 13 SCC 432, holding that Umadevi is not to be used to deny regularisation of exploitative long-term engagements.
pp. 32–35The Court relied on Chander Mohan Negi v. State of H.P. (2020) 5 SCC 732 and Amarendra Kumar Mohapatra v. State of Orissa (2014) 4 SCC 583.
pp. 35–40 · pp. 40–42The Court relied on Prem Singh v. State of U.P. (2019) 10 SCC 516 for regularisation of long-serving work-charged employees, with retirement benefits to count.
pp. 43–44The Court relied on Jaggo v. Union of India, 2024 SCC OnLine SC 3826, holding that the nature of work, not the label, governs, and that outsourcing is not a shield.
pp. 44–54The Court relied on Shripal v. Nagar Nigam, 2025 SCC OnLine SC 221, holding that exploitative daily-wage engagement cannot be perpetuated under Umadevi.
pp. 10–19 · pp. 54–64The Court relied on Dharam Singh v. State of U.P., 2025 SCC OnLine SC 1735, holding that continued ad hoc engagement for perennial work is arbitrary under Article 14.
pp. 64–67The Court relied on the Article 14 principle that similarly situated persons must receive similar treatment.
p. 69Provisions in the judgment · 2
U.P. Industrial Disputes Act, 1947 Section 6ESection 6N
04Reasoning
The Court found the material facts undisputed: continuous engagement, the 2006 recommendation for regularisation, and the co-listed employee's favourable order.
pp. 6–7 · pp. 3–4The Court held that the State's reliance on the Umadevi cut-off date of 10.04.2006 had been repeatedly rejected by the Court in identical matters, since later Supreme Court decisions treat Umadevi as permitting regularisation of long-serving irregular appointees.
pp. 20–21 · pp. 30–31 · pp. 64–65Because the petitioner was identically placed to the co-listed employee, the Court applied the parity principle and extended the same relief.
p. 69Although the petitioner had retired, the Court held that regularisation from the 10-year mark would govern the qualifying service for terminal benefits, but not entitle her to arrears of regular salary.
pp. 69–70The Court did not separately adjudicate Annexure-J, as the regularisation direction was held to resolve the grievance.
pp. 69–7005Holding
The Court holds that the petitioner is entitled to regularisation from the date on which she completed 10 years of service (computed as 19.07.2006), with all consequential benefits.
pp. 69–70The petitioner's entitlement is limited to qualifying service for computing terminal benefits, not arrears of regular salary.
p. 70The writ petition is allowed.
p. 69The respondents must compute and disburse terminal benefits within three months of receipt of a certified copy of the order.
p. 70Original Court PDF
SMT. NAGARATNA NAYAK D/O UMESH NAYAKvsTHE STATE OF KARNATAKA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
