01Facts
The Institute filed intra-court appeals against a common judgment allowing two writ petitions. In Archit Chauhan’s petition, the Single Judge directed cancellation of his MBBS admission and a refund of the money deposited. In Himani Pandey’s petition, the Single Judge directed the Institute to adjust her to the seat vacated by Chauhan, refund her excess payment, and fill the seat vacated by her in the All India Management Quota.
¶ 6–10The Institute contended that the judgment gave no reasons and failed to consider the counselling conditions and Chauhan’s admission undertaking
¶ 6–1002Issues
i.1. Whether the Single Judge’s judgment, which granted relief without reasoned consideration of the parties’ cases and relevant conditions, could stand
¶ 7–11ii.2. Whether the Division Bench should decide the underlying merits of the students’ claims or remand the writ petitions for fresh consideration
¶ 1103Law Applied
A judicial order must contain reasons; a reasoned decision should address the material facts, issues, submissions, applicable legal principles, and the basis for the court’s findings. An order that lacks reasoning may prejudice the parties by leaving them unaware of why one succeeded and the other failed.
¶ 7The Court relied on Vishal Ashwin Patel v. Assistant Commissioner of Income Tax, Circle 25(3) & Ors., which referred to Central Board of Trustees v. Indore Composite Private Limited, (2018) 8 SCC 443, and Union Public Service Commission v. Bibhu Prasad Sarangi & Ors., (2021) 4 SCC 516
¶ 7The Court held that a cryptic, non-speaking judgment is unsustainable
¶ 1104Reasoning
The Single Judge had allowed both petitions on the stated basis that the Institute was amenable to writ jurisdiction and should not be unjustly enriched, but had not supplied reasons addressing the claims or the relevant considerations
¶ 9–10The Division Bench also noted that the Single Judge had overlooked the counselling notification dated 15 November 2022 and Chauhan’s admission undertaking
¶ 10Because the impugned judgment was cryptic and non-speaking, the Division Bench set it aside without deciding the underlying merits and remitted the petitions for fresh determination
¶ 1105Holding
The Court held that the impugned judgment could not stand for want of adequate reasoning.
¶ 11–12It set aside the judgment and remanded both writ petitions to the Single Judge for fresh decision. The special appeals were disposed of on those terms, without the Division Bench determining the merits of the students’ claims
¶ 11–12Original Court PDF
SHRI GURU RAM RAI INSTITUTE OF MEDICAL AND HEALTH SCIENCES DEHRADUNvsHIMANI PANDEY
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
