01Facts
The respondent, Gokulanand Pathak, was a constable who retired on 31.12.2022
¶ 18 · p. 1After retirement, the department withheld his retiral dues and pension and demanded either deposit of Rs. 23,08,264/- for alleged excess payment or an undertaking that the amount be recovered from his gratuity
¶ 18 · p. 1By order dated 01.06.2023, the department directed recovery of Rs. 23,08,264/- from gratuity
¶ 19 · p. 1The respondent challenged this before the Uttarakhand Public Services Tribunal in Claim Petition No. 94/NB/DB/2023. The Tribunal found no misrepresentation by the respondent, relied on State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (2015) 4 SCC 334, set aside the recovery order, and directed release of pension and all retiral dues within 60 days
¶ 18–19 · p. 1The State challenged that judgment. Its counsel argued that the respondent had incurred 19 punishments between 1997 and 2003, was therefore aware he was not entitled to the excess salary, and never informed the department of the overpayment
pp. 2–3 · ¶ 3The Tribunal had noted the State's reliance on Rafiq Masih before it
p. 3 · ¶ 4In his rejoinder-affidavit before the Tribunal, the respondent stated he did not contest refixation of pay/salary
p. 4 · ¶ 602Issues
i.1. Whether recovery of an alleged excess payment of salary from the respondent's retiral dues was sustainable where there was no allegation or finding of fraud, misrepresentation, or undertaking by the respondent
p. 3 · ¶ 5ii.2. Whether the respondent's alleged knowledge of the overpayment, inferred from prior disciplinary punishments and his failure to inform the department, justified the recovery
pp. 2–3 · ¶ 3 · p. 3 · ¶ 5iii.3. Whether the competent authority may be directed to refix pay/pension and release retiral dues, given the respondent's non-objection to refixation
p. 4 · ¶ 6–703Law Applied
The Court relied on the Supreme Court's decision in State of Punjab v. Rafiq Masih (White Washer), (2015) 4 SCC 334, as applied by the Tribunal and accepted in this judgment
p. 3 · ¶ 4–5As relied upon by the Tribunal, the principle is that recovery of excess payments made by the employer from retiral dues or from employees is impermissible where the excess was not caused by the employee's misrepresentation or fraud and the employee was not instrumental in securing it, subject to narrow exceptions (such as the employee's knowledge that the payment was excess, or recovery from Class III/IV employees)
The Court further treated the existence of fraud, misrepresentation, or a written undertaking to refund as the material facts that would displace this protection
p. 3 · ¶ 5The Court also recognised that pay and pension refixation is for the competent authority to undertake
p. 4 · ¶ 704Reasoning
The Court first examined whether the State had pleaded facts bringing the case within the protection or exceptions recognised in Rafiq Masih. It found that the State had not alleged that the respondent committed fraud, was instrumental in securing the excess release, or gave an undertaking before the Tribunal to refund any excess
p. 3 · ¶ 5The State's argument that the respondent knew of the overpayment, based on 19 prior punishments, was not supported by any such pleading before the Tribunal, and the Court therefore declined to interfere with the Tribunal's reliance on Rafiq Masih
p. 3 · ¶ 5Because the respondent did not contest refixation of pay, and his counsel stated he had no objection to refixation of pension if made by the competent authority, the Court left the refixation exercise to the department and did not disturb the grant of retiral benefits
p. 4 · ¶ 6–7The operative part does not expressly address the validity of the 01.06.2023 recovery order, which the Tribunal had set aside
p. 4 · ¶ 705Holding
The Court held that there was no reason to interfere with the Tribunal's conclusion, based on Rafiq Masih, because the State had not established fraud, misrepresentation, or an undertaking by the respondent
p. 3 · ¶ 5The writ petition was disposed of by permitting the competent authority to refix the respondent's pay and pension and to release all retiral dues within ten weeks from the date of presentation of the certified copy of the order. The ten-week period differs from the 60-day period fixed by the Tribunal
p. 4 · ¶ 7 · ¶ 19 · p. 1The Court's order does not expressly reaffirm the Tribunal's quashing of the recovery order dated 01.06.2023
p. 4 · ¶ 7Original Court PDF
STATE OF UTTARAKHANDvsGOKULANAND PATHAK
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
