01Facts
The respondent (BHEL) issued a Purchase Order dated 16.08.2006 to the petitioner for supply, erection and commissioning of a Chlorination Plant at the 2×250 MW GHTPS Stage-II, Bhatinda.
¶ 2Disputes led to a first arbitration, in which a sole arbitrator was appointed on 19.08.2013. The respondent's counter-claim of ₹95,00,000 was disallowed by the award dated 04.07.2017, which the petitioner states was not challenged and has attained finality.
¶ 2During that arbitration, the respondent terminated the Purchase Order and had the balance work executed through PSPCL.
¶ 2–3The respondent then invoked a second arbitration and a sole arbitrator was allegedly appointed unilaterally. The petitioner says the tribunal proceeded ex parte and, by award dated 18.09.2019, allowed the respondent's claim.
¶ 3The petitioner did not challenge the award under Section 34 of the A&C Act. The respondent filed Commercial Execution Application (L) No. 10291/2021 before the Bombay High Court, with Interim Application No. 2935/2021.
¶ 3The petitioner contends that the award is non est, barred by res judicata, and passed by an arbitrator unilaterally appointed.
¶ 4The petitioner stated it learnt of these defects only during enforcement and has contested executability in its reply to the interim application, which is yet to be taken up.
¶ 5The petitioner sought a declaration that the award and the clarification order dated 23.12.2019 are void ab initio and an injunction against enforcement.
¶ 102Issues
i.1. Whether a writ petition seeking a declaration that an arbitral award is void ab initio and non est, and restraining its enforcement, is maintainable where the award was not challenged under Section 34 and the nullity objection is pending before the executing court.
¶ 5–6, 8ii.2. Whether a party can obtain an independent declaration of an arbitral award's invalidity outside the statutory framework of the A&C Act, or must raise the objection within execution proceedings.
¶ 7–803Law Applied
The Court relied on the settled principle that an objection based on inherent lack of jurisdiction, or that an award is void ab initio, may be examined by the executing court during execution proceedings, as laid down in Matsya Fincap Pvt Ltd. v. Govind Lal (2026:DHC:3759-DB).
¶ 7The Court applied MMTC Ltd. v. Anglo American Metallurgical Pty Ltd. (2025:DHC:11831-DB), which holds that a party acquires no independent right to institute separate proceedings for a declaration of invalidity. Any independent declaratory petition that, in substance, seeks to set aside an award falls outside the statutory framework of the A&C Act and is not maintainable.
¶ 7Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Arbitration and Conciliation Act, 1996 Section 34
04Reasoning
The petitioner's grounds of nullity (unilateral appointment, ex parte proceedings, and res judicata) were pleaded within a writ petition seeking a stand-alone declaration that the award is void and unenforceable. The Court held that such relief, in substance, would set aside the award outside the Section 34 framework, which the petitioner had not invoked.
¶ 1, 3, 4, 7Because the petitioner had already raised executability before the Bombay High Court in the pending execution proceedings, the Court found that the proper forum for the defence was the executing court. The Court declined to entertain a writ on the ground that the objection had not yet been considered, since the petitioner's remedy lay in obtaining a ruling on that objection in execution and, if adverse, in pursuing available appellate or other remedies. The Court also noted that the petitioner's claim of supervisory jurisdiction over a Delhi-seated arbitration was not accepted as a basis for the relief sought.
¶ 5, 805Holding
The Court held that no ground to entertain the writ petition was made out, and that a party cannot maintain an independent writ or declaratory petition seeking to invalidate an arbitral award on the ground that its objection is pending or unconsidered in execution proceedings.
¶ 7–9The petition was dismissed. The petitioner retains the right to press its nullity objection before the executing court, to seek its determination if not yet adjudicated, and to pursue any appellate or other remedy available in law if the objection is rejected. The Court expressly stated that it has not expressed any opinion on the merits.
¶ 8, 10, 11Original Court PDF
M/S Babubhai Narottamdas And CovsBharat Heavy Electricals Limited
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
