01Facts
The petitioner, an 85-year-old senior citizen, is the absolute owner of 24-B, Masjid Moth, MIG Flats, Phase-I, New Delhi, which he acquired from the DDA in 1980 and converted to freehold in 2000.
¶ 2He describes it as his self-acquired property.
¶ 2Respondent No. 1 is his eldest son, and Respondent No. 2 is Respondent No. 1's wife. Both reside in the property by virtue of the familial relationship and have not claimed title.
¶ 2, 26The petitioner alleges that after his younger sons married (2005, 2008), he asked Respondents 1 and 2 to relocate, which they refused. He further alleges financial neglect and harassment, which intensified after his wife's death in 2020.
¶ 3On 03.09.2022, an assault on his younger son was alleged, leading to a police complaint on 07.09.2022.
¶ 4The petitioner then filed S.C. Case No. 126/2022 before the District Magistrate (South) under the Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 ("the Act") seeking eviction and maintenance.
¶ 4Respondents offered Rs. 15,000/- per month as maintenance.
¶ 5The SDM's enquiry report dated 25.02.2023 stated that it could not be ascertained whether the harassment complaint was genuine, and that the matter appeared to be a dispute between brothers.
¶ 6The DM dismissed the case on 25.08.2023.
¶ 7Subsequent appeal proceedings were remanded on 12.06.2025.
¶ 11This Court, in W.P.(C) 12946/2025, directed the SHO to assist the petitioner.
¶ 12, 15A fresh SDM report dated 17.09.2025 concluded in one line that harassment was not established and the dispute was a family matter.
¶ 13The DM dismissed the remanded case on 28.10.2025.
¶ 14The Divisional Commissioner dismissed the appeal on 28.04.2026, holding that the Act cannot be invoked absent clear and credible evidence of neglect or harassment.
¶ 16The petitioner challenged that order under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution.
¶ 1, 1702Issues
i.1. Whether a senior citizen seeking eviction of his children from his self-acquired property under the Act must establish harassment or ill-treatment by "clear and credible evidence."
¶ 24, 29, 33ii.2. Whether the authorities could rely on the SDM's enquiry reports, which were inconclusive and unreasoned, to reject the petitioner's claim.
¶ 35–36iii.3. Whether the existence of a business dispute between the sons defeats the petitioner's claim for eviction.
¶ 3403Law Applied
The Court relied on Sections 4, 5, 7, 8, and 27 of the Act, and Rule 22(3) of the Delhi Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Rules, 2009, which provide a summary, civil-court-equivalent remedy against children, excluding civil court jurisdiction.
¶ 1, 27The Court applied Ravi Kant Gupta v. State of U.P. (SC, 04.08.2026), holding that the Tribunal under the Act may order eviction where necessary and expedient for the maintenance and protection of a senior citizen.
¶ 27, 38Ravi Kant Gupta in turn followed S. Vanitha v. Deputy Commissioner (2021) 15 SCC 730, which treats eviction as an incident of the right to maintenance and protection.
¶ 27, 38The Court relied on Pritam Singh v. GNCTD (W.P.(C) 13840/2022, 13.05.2025), holding that a senior citizen need only show that his property needs protection and need not prove ill-treatment or need for maintenance.
¶ 28–29The Court cited Vinay Varma v. Kanika Pasricha (2019), which permits unconditional eviction where children ill-treat parents.
¶ 30Writ review is limited to perversity, absence of evidence, patent illegality, or jurisdictional error, and does not permit re-appreciation of evidence.
¶ 25Provisions in the judgment · 6 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Maintenance and Welfare of Parents and Senior Citizens Act, 2007 Section 4Section 5Section 7Section 8Section 16Section 27
04Reasoning
The Court held that both authorities erred in law by imposing a requirement of "clear and cogent evidence" of harassment, which the Act and the 2009 Rules do not contemplate.
¶ 33Applying Pritam Singh, the petitioner's entitlement turned on the need to protect his property so that he could live there peacefully, not on proof of ill-treatment.
¶ 29The Court found the SDM reports unreliable. The 2023 report made no finding, and the 2025 report recorded the parties' submissions and a house visit but gave no reasons beyond a single conclusory line.
¶ 35–36The authorities also ignored the petitioner's multiple police complaints and this Court's orders of 26.08.2025 and 29.10.2025 directing police assistance.
¶ 34, 36–37The business dispute between the sons was held not to be a ground to deny protection, as it does not negate the petitioner's genuine grievance.
¶ 34The Court distinguished S. Vanitha, since no proceedings under the Protection of Women from Domestic Violence Act, 2005 were pending, and distinguished Shri Chand Gautam, where the children had filed a civil suit claiming property rights.
¶ 38Recognising that intra-family harassment is difficult to prove independently and that the summary procedure does not demand the standard of a criminal or civil trial, the Court concluded that a senior citizen cannot be compelled to share his home with children against his wishes, particularly where litigation has persisted since 2022.
¶ 39–4005Holding
The Court holds that a senior citizen seeking eviction of children from his self-acquired property under the Act need not establish ill-treatment or harassment by clear and credible evidence, and that inconclusive or unreasoned enquiry reports cannot ground a rejection.
¶ 29, 33, 35–36The writ petition is allowed. The orders dated 28.04.2026 (Divisional Commissioner) and 28.10.2025 (District Magistrate) are set aside.
¶ 41Respondent Nos. 1 and 2 are directed to vacate 24-B, Masjid Moth, MIG Flats, Phase-I, New Delhi within four weeks.
¶ 42The concerned SHO is directed to provide all necessary assistance for compliance.
¶ 43The pending application stands disposed of.
¶ 44Original Court PDF
Subhash Chander MalhotravsRaman Malhotra & Ors.
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
