01Facts
The Petitioner-wife, Respondent in C.P. No. 611 of 2019 before the Family Court, Bhubaneswar, challenged the order dated 20.09.2025, which rejected her petition dated 29.07.2025 seeking to recall R.W.1 to exhibit documents listed on 13.08.2025
p. 1, para 1The Opposite Party-husband, Petitioner in C.P. No. 611 of 2019, filed a Preliminary Counter Affidavit opposing the writ
¶ 2The wife argued that the documents (Serial Nos. 1-10 photographs; Serial Nos. 11-15 photocopies of documents relating to other case matters) were innocuous and necessary to establish her claim for restitution of conjugal rights
¶ 3The husband argued that the application was a deliberate delay tactic in a dispute pending since 2019, that the documents were filed belatedly on 13.08.2025 without reasons, after the application itself, and that they should have been filed with the plaint in C.P. No. 524 of 2019 (under Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955) or with the written statement in C.P. No. 611 of 2019
pp. 2-4, paras 4, 4.1, 4.2The husband further stated that documents at Serial Nos. 1, 13, 14 and 15 were already marked as exhibits through P.W.1
p. 4, para 4.2The impugned order held that Serial Nos. 1-10 could be referred to only if within the pleadings and only with authenticity certification, and that Serial Nos. 11-15 could be judicially noticed at the final stage only if within the pleadings. The petition was rejected, and the matter was posted for argument on 09.10.2025
pp. 4-5, para 502Issues
i.1. Whether the Family Court was justified in rejecting the wife's belated application to recall R.W.1 and exhibit additional photographs and photocopies at the argument stage, where the documents were not shown to be within the pleadings and lacked authentication.
p. 2, para 3 · p. 5, para 5 · p. 5, para 6ii.2. Whether the High Court should interfere under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution with the impugned interlocutory order.
p. 5, para 603Law Applied
The Court referred to Order VII Rule 14, Order VIII Rule 1A and Order XIII Rule 1 of the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, which govern the production of documents with the plaint, with the written statement, and at the initial stages of the suit, respectively
p. 3, para 4.1 · pp. 3-4, para 4.2The Court relied on the trial court's approach to admissibility: photographs may be considered for reference only if within the pleadings and accompanied by authenticity certification, and photocopies may be judicially noticed at the final stage only if within the pleadings
p. 5, para 5Section 9 of the Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 is the substantive basis of the parallel restitution petition
p. 4, para 4.2The writ jurisdiction under Articles 226 and 227 of the Constitution is the basis for review
p. 1Provisions in the judgment · 1 · Linked ones open on LawLens
Hindu Marriage Act, 1955 Section 9
04Reasoning
The Court examined the pleadings, the parties' submissions, the CPC provisions, and the impugned order, and found no infirmity or illegality warranting interference
p. 5, para 6The wife filed the documents only after the application and at the argument stage, without assigning cogent reasons, which is inconsistent with the pleading-stage scheme of Order VII Rule 14 and Order VIII Rule 1A
p. 3, para 4.1 · p. 4, para 4.2The trial court's conditions (pleading linkage and authentication) were consistent with the evidentiary requirements for photographs and photocopies, and the Court did not find them unreasonable
p. 5, para 5Some of the documents had already been exhibited through P.W.1, which reduced the prejudice claimed by the wife
p. 4, para 4.205Holding
The Family Court's rejection of the application to recall R.W.1 and exhibit the listed documents disclosed no infirmity or illegality, and the High Court would not interfere under Articles 226 and 227
p. 5, para 6The writ petition is dismissed. Interim orders, if any, are vacated, and I.A. No. 19833 of 2025 is disposed of accordingly. An urgent certified copy is to be granted on proper application
p. 5, paras 7, 8, 9Original Court PDF
SHWETA MAHAPATRAvsROSHAN MISHRA
Click to open original judgment
Original judgment, available to read, download and summarize on LawLens.in
